New American Restaurants near Saint Petersburg, FL

Stillwaters Tavern American • $$
224 Beach Dr NE, St. Petersburg

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Cheese Steak French Dip
Nashville Hot Chicken
Citrus-Ginger Salmon
Creole Shrimp Pasta
House Smoked Wings
Fried Chicken Salad
Gulf Shrimp Grits
The Sausage Board
Tavern Pot Roast

“The pluses were fun people watching and being in the mix of everything. The food was good, not great but good. The bad, although we had reservations we still had to wait 15 mins. We then waited another 15 for a waiter to approach us and the rest of our meal I had to wave him down for service. The cocktail was delicious but very little alcohol.Parking: Parking is nutty on a weekend in season so we took uber“

4.5 Superb304 Reviews
Brick & Mortar American • $$
539 Central Ave, St. Petersburg

Customers` Favorites

Cavatelli with Roasted Mushrooms and Shrimp
Hand Cut Truffle Parmesan Fries
Charred Slow Braised Octopus
Glazed Donut Bread Pudding
Brick & Mortar Carbonara
Seasonal Salad Feature
Seafood Bouillabaisse
Roasted Octopus
Filet & Frites
Charcuterie

“This was the best burger iv ever had … the meat melts in your mouth and with it being filet/short rib it makes for the best tasting meat . Mixed with that aioli sauce it just explodes in flavor. Top it with the amazing truffle fries it’s my favorite meal in st pete hands down.“

4.4 Superb81 Reviews
Caribbean Cafe Cafe • $
4801 Central Ave, St. Petersburg

Customers` Favorites

Black Beans & Yellow Rice Plate 22oz with Cuban Toast
Veggie Sandwich with Beans and Rice
Portabella Mushroom Sandwich Combo
Vegetarian Sandwich with Mushrooms
Black Beans Yellow Rice Plate
Authentic Cuban Sandwich
Matooks Calypso Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Melt
Black Bean Soup
Cheese Sandwich

“10/10 - If you know you know. The Caribbean Cafe Cuban is the best Cuban in the Area. Yes Pipos, Bodega ( I don't always want Pulled Mojo Smoked Pork Shoulder) and Columbia are all Great, but this as been my go to for years and NEVER Disappoints. It is a TRUE AUTHENTIC CUBAN. Plus the Price is Right and the Rice and Beans are also F I R E . AND THAT BREAD!!! LOVE LOVE LOVE!ALSO - This gets Delivered from Central Ave to Tierra Verde by Uber Eats REALLY Well.Will continue to be a happy customer.“

4.4 Superb60 Reviews
Mad Fish Seafood • $$$
5200 Gulf Blvd, St. Petersburg

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail and Filet Mignon
Flash Fried Brussel Sprouts
Beef Tenderloin Brochette
Lobster Crusted Grouper
Homemade Key Lime Pie
Oysters Rockefeller
Baked Goat Cheese
Beef Wellington
Surf and Turf
Chateaubriand

“This restaurant was a great choice! The menu had great options but not an overwhelming amounts of items. Everything we tried we well above my expectations. The seafood was prepped perfectly. The meat was so tender. I filled up on apps before dinner even came but devoured it upon arriving home. Superb! Staff was friendly and gave great suggestions. Owner was on site and so welcoming. I would recommend this to any locals as well as visitors as a number one dining experience in st. Pete’s. We had reservations at Maritana and this place. And it did not disappoint! Ordered the rack of lamb, beef tenderloins, baked oysters, and shrimp with scallop risotto.“

4.2 Good118 Reviews