11 Best Ice Cream Shops in Fishers

“I enjoy getting cookies from here. I’ve always had great customer service from this location. You can order on the app or go in to order on the kiosks. Either way works great. Cookie flavors change by the week. Some weeks are better than others but that’s personal preference. The cost is a little bit expensive. As it’s definitely a treat & not something to get all the time… even though I wish I could since they are so delicious.“

“I love Handel's very much me and my girl go there alot. A guy in a nice red 86 Cadillac cut me in line with his whole family. Still thinking about it today. Bit my tounge cause I'm a changed man today. Not Handel's fault but I needed to vent it out.“

“Avocado popsicles! I came for the avocado popsicles, and have since tried many of Nicey Treat's more conventional popsicles, and I love them all. My last visit, I got a pineapple basil popsicle and it was amazing. It was kind of sweet, kind of savory. The thing with Nicey Treat is that there are flavors here for everyone. Even the unconventional flavors (like avocado) are tasty and I'm sure even the most picky people would like them if they just ventured out of their comfort zone. But even if you're not a person who wants to try new things, there are lots of tried-and-true flavors like banana cream, pink lemonade, watermelon and frozen hot chocolate. They also offer lots of vegan popsicles -- I'd say a good half of their menu is vegan. I always get my popsicles plain, but you can get them dipped in chocolate (milk chocolate or dark chocolate), and then top them with things like sprinkles, nuts, chopped peanut butter cups, toasted coconut or streusel. There are a few places inside the store to sit and eat, but Nicey Treat is located at the Fishers Yard District, where there are lots of things to see and do. So I suggest getting your popsicle to go and walking around The Yard.“

“One of the best ice cream shops in the area. Pricey but a single scoop is huge. The chip flavors are a specialty but all the flavors are good. Only downside....if you get a new person on a busy night you will get half scoops. But that is rare“

“Hi all! My husband and I go to this DQ all the time. The staff is always very respectful, kind and definitely have manners. I think the food is always good and hot. And the ice cream treats are the best! I think some of the staff might be high school students and they are never rude, and have a smile. The manager I think she is the manager, anyway she is always working and always kind and her employees definitely treat her with respect . So I just wanted to say we Love going there. They never disappoint!“

“Absolutely delicious! I was blown away at how amazing these all were - gs cookie tagalong, maple bacon, reese's pieces, sprinkles & raspberry malasadas's. Loved the donut wall in the dining room & the fast friendly service as well.“

“Mmmmm. Brusters is very good! I would say it's a little much expensive than some of the other shops around but it's good! My favorite flavor so far has been a seasonal one that was a almond wedding cake flavor with black raspberry jam in it. Please bring it back and I will come daily!!“

“Friendly service as always! Love all the flavor options!“

“I love going to Dairy Queen because I can always count on good ice cream! We got a large royal blizzard to split and it was good! The fluffernutter in the middle definitely wasn't a "core" like they advertise. It only went maybe halfway down. The toppings also don't stretch all the way to the bottom of the cup if you order a large! These are small problems in my opinion considering the quality of their actual ice cream. I can't speak on their food, because I didn't have any!“

“Okay...I am guilty. Hope my wife doesn't read this, but I am a big butter burger fan! Thank God Culver's came to town several years ago. It's a reminder of days gone by. Back when you to visited the burger drive-in. Fast forward to today. Still driving to CULVER'S for a great burger and ordering a burger in a basket.Yes! They remind good old days. Except now I don't have to sit in the back seat with my brother.Now I sit up front with my girl of 25 years, still in love, married to my wife and Culver's BUTTER BURGER served in a basket like the good old days. Some things just don't change.Wheelchair accessibility: Ada compliant if you choose to dine inside.“

“Service has been good every time I've been there. The young people working are knowledgeable about their product and can answer ingredients questions (such as dairy or lactose free, etc). Incidentally they do have lactose free milk options but not dairy free (you can get tea without any milk if you'd prefer). The original bobas have been just a touch chewy and couple times, but the last 3 times I've been there, the original bobas have been really soft--sooo good! I've liked everything I've tried so far: the green milk tea (made with lactaid powder) with original bobas and no sugar, ginger milk strike (also made with lactaid), and their chai milk tea without sugar-which is also really good. When you order, you look at the menu (which can overwhelm you at first with all the options!) and tell them what size drink, then what kind of drink, any extras--bobas, poppers, red beans, etc--how much ice, how much sweetener (some drinks come with a couple shots of brown sugar or other sugary syrup, but I'm not much of a fan for really sweet drinks. So it's great that they make it to order. Also noteworthy is the Asian atmosphere. It's airy, minimalist, and pleasant. There's even a small shrine in the corner. Very clean. The restroom was very clean and properly stocked as well. Almost forgot--the store is well-situated on the corner near several other restaurants with plenty of parking, several entrances into the parking lot, and a traffic light making it easy to get to even during rush hour. If you love bubble tea, then I definitely recommend this establishment.“