20 Best American Restaurants near Middlebury

“Delicious food! Reasonably priced! Gorgeous atmosphere! A real gem in the middle of Middlebury! ♡“

“Fried mush is just awesome! Love when it's homemade!! First time back since reopening, and it is very nice. Wait staff were great too!! Highly recommended!!“

“Great food & servers. We have gone there for years & will go back soon for my 82nd birthday.“

“Great food & servers. We have gone there for years & will go back soon for my 82nd birthday.“

“My daughter and I stopped in for our first time on our way to see a show in a neighboring town. We were amazed at how good the food was. We started with an appetizer of very good homemade pie followed up by the best buttermilk pancakes I have ever had.“

“Great little joint, with tasty food.“

“We were undecided about buffet or sit down dining. The staff allowed us to look at buffet and the menu for sit down as well. Buffet looked good but we chose sit down. I had the creamed chicken over biscuits and mashed potatoes. I ordered the small portion, which was pretty big. The biscuits were delicious and fluffy. The mashed potatoes were great as well. BF had the same but with egg noodles and mashed potatoes. Noodles were great as well. We were served rolls, we only ate the whole wheat and took white with us. BF also had the beets, which were amazing, not acidic, but sweet. Would definitely recommend“

“These smash burgers are quite tasty, with an array of delicious topping options. My spouse was also glad they had gluten free options too.Update: loved the fiesty chicken wrap and the salad was good too!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free buns available (for a $2.50 upcharge) and they're pretty good too.Parking: You can park on the street (pull in - not parallel parking in downtown Goshen) or in the parking lot across Washington St.“

“Definitely a fan fave of the locals that reside around the lakes nearby. Very good service. Robust menu and beer selection. Fried chicken & fish (and Thursday Frog Legs) appear to be the favorites. We know family members from both Elkhart & Edwardsburg that frequent this venue.“

“Been here twice, both meals have been outstanding, staff is awesome!! Beer is cold ..“

“A regular because of the food and the people. It is an atmosphere where I can relax. And you're surrounded by handmade candy.Parking: The availability for parking varies because the closest is street parking. There is a city parking lot nearby.Wheelchair accessibility: The front door is wheelchair accessible. It can be a bit tight inside because the building is more than 100 years old. I have worked with the staff to bring someone in with a wheelchair though.“

“We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here last night. We could not have asked for a better experience. The staff was incredibly helpful during planning the event, the bartenders Jordan and Sinclair were the absolute nicest people we could have gotten. The drinks were great, the food was amazing, and the building was beautiful. Absolutely would recommend them for any event or a night out!“

“Grew up in Goshen and my family still lives here, every time I visit I MUST stop at good ol’ gbco. This place is a little slice of heaven right here in Goshen, very accepting and kind welcoming to guests. I know my first time I was a little confused on where to go but ask and you shall receive, amazing service! Definitely add it to your list as a visitor or local.“

“Fast service at a reasonable cost“

“Have went to Culver’s many times after a game or for a late night meal. Everyone is always super kind and helpful there. The food has a good taste but is a tiny bit expensive and serving sizes seem to be a little smaller. Other than that it’s a great place and they have a very calm atmosphere.“

“A great menu with so many choices you will not go hungry. So many neat antiques around the building . Really good service they really know how to take care of guests. The food was good with big portions you will not leave hungry.“

“Great food. Very clean!“

“nothing at all. needs alot of improvement. specially answering phones and how they serve people“

“The food was amazing! I had the Portabella Fingers as an app and the Gnocchi with shrimp for my entree. The gnocchi were so delicious! This was my first time at your restaurant and your food is excellent!“

“great friendly staff and awesome food!!!“