Pizza Restaurants near Carthage

“This review is based on one slice of cheese pizza. I stopped here for a quick slice at lunch. The slice was a little thicker than I like but not doughy. It still had a nice crisp when I bit into it. The cheese was good and sauce was solid. This place is a small mom and pop type pizza shop which I appreciate. They had a few other types of pizzas and some food ready. It all looked good. The guy behind the counter was friendly and quick to acknowledge me. This is a solid spot to stop for a slice.“

“We love having Stefano's in our community. With several locations around northern New York it's nice to have Stefano's Pizzeria just outside the gate of Fort Drum. They have a great sauce and crust. Try their garlic knots and I love to order my wings extra crispy.“

“Thanks Jay for your great customer service. Appreciate your help“

“You screwed up my mobile order, but you know what? You’re humans and we all make mistakes! You went above and beyond to fix it! In the end the food was very good and I felt like you wanted to make it right! Honestly, to me, it’s generally not about making a mistake, but is about how you fix it! Thank you!“

“Incredible burgers… wow! It has been while since i walked out of a place feeling good about a dine in experience. These guys do it right!“

“Jacobs has good pizza. It's pretty much just a takeout place and the service is good. They have subs too but I haven't tried them. The pizza is pretty tasty and prices seem competitive. If you go there bring cash. They don't accept credit cards. And don't expect to get Jacob's pizza for watching football. They're closed on Sundays.“