Pizza Restaurants near Watkins Glen

“We spent the day in town and the signage drew us in for an after dinner treat. Sweet, friendly service and the BEST cannolis we have ever had! Thank you! ♥️“

“Sandwich and soup were pretty decent. Certainly, it has an old-school feel to it. It appears a little cold though. The indoor lighting had several burned out fluorescent lights that gave me a murky feeling. I also wasn't expecting all the drink choices to come in a can or bottle.“

“Delicious wood fired pizza made to order; by hand! We were hungry after after hiking the Watkins Glen State Park so we walked down to the Colonial Inn for their outside pizza! Ordered the Margharita pizza and was not disappointed! Waited about 20 minutes since there was 3 pizzas in front of ours - but totally worth the wait. We took it to go and ate every piece. $17 for the whole pie and it was cut into 4 pieces. It was just the two of us so it was the perfect size and amount.We will be returning tomorrow for the ice cream portion!“

“Great food, music, drinks and atmosphere“

“Best place in town 10/10 recommend“

“Always delicious! From the wings to the Stromboli to the pizza! My favorite way to the order the wings is with their medium sauce and ask for some garlic on them as well. The restaurant is always clean and the employees are kind and helpful. This is always my husband’s favorite stop when we travel up to visit my family. Their outdoor seating area is wonderful in the Summer!Parking: Plenty of free parking is available in their parking lot, even during peak tourist season in the Spring and Summer.Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly. My kids have grown up eating here. They also have multiple tvs placed around the seating area.“