12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Delaware

“Pizza is awesome and the garlic bread is great as well. The best part about pick up is drive thru. Also, here's something that's genius and underrated, the homemade ranch with is awesome by the way, comes in a container that is not circle. It's way easier to dip your entire slice which is great. Definitely recommend trying this place“

“I'm pretty pizza obsessed. I've been making pizza at home for over 15 years and have tried most all of the bigger pizza spots around Columbus. I was recently in Delaware and had an opportunity to try Mohio Pizza.I’ll be the first to tell you that, while I really enjoy Columbus style pizza, it’s not my absolute favorite style. I personally make a Neapolitan style and I seek out similar style pies around town. I was impressed as hell with this pizza. I wanted to try a couple flavors, so I got half pep and half sausage and poblano pepper.The freshness of the pie was immediately evident. The toppings, sauce and cheese were in perfect harmony. Both halfs were equally delicious. The crust was crispy, chewy and flavorful. I suspected that it was sourdough and that was confirmed with a chat with the owner and pizza chef, Moe. I’ve tried a ton of pizza shops in the nearly 25 years I’ve lived in Columbus and this was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in central Ohio. I’m back at home and all I can think about is going back up to Delaware to grab another pizza.“

“We have recently moved to the area and have already been here 3x, the food is THAT good. We dined in once and carried out twice. Their pizza is hot, delicious, fresh, full of flavor. The prices are reasonable for today's dining market. Service was excellent for our dine in experience. The antipasto appetizer is a MUST if you enjoy roasted vegetables, off the hook good. Street parking with parking for pickup available. My only comment on the downside was that the hazy IPA beer I had from the tap was flat.“

“The best Deep Dish pizza I ever had! I always get the Pepperoni deep dish pizza. Its only a take out location. No dine in. The pizzas are cut into 8 squares I believe and each one is a pretty big portion. The curst is nice and crunchy, which is what I look for on a deep dish pizza. 100% recommend!“

“A favorite of mine it has good pizza and subs. The wings though are the top thing I like to get. Biggest issue with the service is that they are usually so busy.Parking: Usually very busy on Friday and Saturday nights. Parking can be a premium.Kid-friendliness: The place is great and horrible for kids at the same time. It is great in that the food fits their style and they welcome them.It is horrible in that they are usually packed and the tables are jammed that it can be hard to move around with child carriers.“

“I had the opportunity to stop at this staple up north today known for their Stromboli and pizza. I was pleasantly surprised with my visit. The service was wonderful, our server Emily greeted our group of grouchy gals with a smile and was happy to accommodate our requests. I went with the The Destroyer Stromboli and it didn't disappoint. With house ground sausage and oozing cheese dipped in their marinara, it made it a crave worthy experience. Don't skimp on their brunch, their french toast with bananas was decadent and a must order! As for ambiance- I loved the addition of the moose.“

“Local sports pub with plenty of TV's to watch the games. Tried the pizza done the "Scoreboard way" (loaded) & it was VERY good! Service was a little slow at first, but our server was present without hovering later. Worth checking out if you're in the area.“

“We stopped in for lunchI usually always regret going out for pizza lol I never think it taste good anywhere we go.However this was delicious ??? I got a personal supreme and it was hot fresh and so good. I ate half and enjoyed the other two pieces later at home .The hubby got pizza and the kids wings and fries the fries were so fresh and hot and so good ?We will definitely be back to this locationThe guy working the counter was great!Great service“

“Pizza Perfection at Payne's Pizza & More!Payne's Pizza in Delaware, Ohio, is a pizza lover's dream come true, delivering a dining experience that goes above and beyond.The menu is a masterpiece of pizza creations, offering a variety of flavors and toppings to suit every taste. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous with unique combinations, Payne's Pizza & More has you covered.The quality of the ingredients and the perfect balance of flavors make every slice a delight. The crust is just right – crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside.The staff is friendly, efficient, and ensures a prompt and positive dining experience. Whether you're dining in, ordering for delivery, or grabbing a quick takeout, their service is consistently excellent.The ambiance is casual and inviting, making it a great spot for a family meal, a night out with friends, or a cozy dinner for two.For pizza perfection in Delaware, Payne's Pizza & More is the place to be. Five stars for their delicious pies, excellent service, and overall fantastic dining experience!“

“[CHECK OUR PROFILE FOR MORE]Hello everyone and welcome back in today’s review we are going to be reviewing HUNGRY HOWIE’S after enjoying a nice brunch today.Our review it’s based in multiple visits to the restaurant to be fair with our star’s review so we are going to grade it with honesty.What makes HUNGRY HOWIE’S so special and unique in comparison with others?:1. Waiting it’s just normal for a call for pick up or delivery.2. Great customer service.3. Food is great.4. Nice and clean facility.5. Free parking lots.6. Wheelchair access.7. Friendly service and they are always happy to serve.8. Not dining in.9. Pick up or delivery.If this review was helpful please hit ?? button and follow us for more.We Accept Tips, Invitations, Rewards, Blessings or a lot of Thanks by Rating our Reviews and Following Us.Blessings ??“

“I asked for thin dough rolled out. The owner Zamir told his staff and it was the best NY style I’ve had since I lived in NY. Always ask for Zamir to instruct the staff before you order and you won’t be disappointed. He usually leaves by 2 PM so he leaves note for staff for later orders. Best NY style pizza in the city of Delaware. Thank You!!!“

“Donatos Pizza in Delaware, Ohio, has won my taste buds over with its consistently delicious offerings! The pizza here is a true masterpiece, featuring a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and high-quality toppings.Whether enjoying a classic pepperoni or opting for one of their creative specialty pizzas, Donatos never disappoints. The staff is friendly, and the service is prompt, ensuring a satisfying dining experience every time.As a pizza enthusiast, I highly recommend Donatos to anyone in the Delaware area craving a slice of pizza perfection. It has become my go-to spot for a flavorful and enjoyable pizza experience. Five stars well-deserved!“