10 Best Mexican Restaurants in Hilliard

Explore Hilliard's Mexican food scene with our favorite restaurants. Enjoy a range of Mexican flavors, from Chimichangas to Tortillas, and relish top-notch Thai dishes in the area.

Casa Jalisco Mexican • $
5445 Roberts Rd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Queso Fundido Con Chorizo
Camarones Al Mojo de Ajo
Enchiladas Casa Jalisco
Enchiladas de Camarón
Chuletas & Salsa Verde
Camarones A la Diabla
Queso Fundido Shrimp
Burritos Supremos SP
Chicken Big Burrito
Jalisciense Fajita

“We came here for our first time as a group of four and were seated immediately on a Thursday evening. The menu offers a wide variety of great options from traditional to Tex mex style food. I opted for the birria tacos and one hard taco to try as I love my hard tacos!The birria tacos were very good and were prepared perfectly with the grilled cheese and crispy outer layer. I wish it had a bit more seasoning and heat but still overall was very good. The hard taco was also very good and perfectly prepared.The chips and salsa were both homemade and tasted great, the chips were still warm! The service staff was very friendly and helpful. The restaurant also has a bar where you first walk in if you would rather sit at the bar and watch some sports. The cost was very good based on the portions you get. I will definitely be coming back to eat here again soon.“

4.6 Superb115 Reviews
Habaneros Fresh Mexican Grill Mexican • $
3680 Fishinger Blvd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Fish Tacos Chicken Taco Shrimp Taco
Chips and Guacamole
Fried Cheesecake
Chips and Queso
Chicken Burrito
Pastor Torta
Black Beans
Cubana Torta
Steak Taco
Pastor Taco

“Stopped in for lunch, got a torta. The gentleman that helped me was extremely friendly and happy to help me decided on protein. The food is fantastic, the bread for my torta was perfect, crispy outside and soft inside. They portions are good and having a fast casual style restaurant is great. You could be in and out in minutes or sit for a meal. Highly recommend if you in the area.“

4.6 Superb69 Reviews
Local Cantina Hilliard Mexican • $$
3975 Main St, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Fajita Quesadilla with Chorizo
Nashville Hot Chicken Taco
Ground Beef Chimichanga
Chicken or Beef Taco
Local Guacamole
Chicken Fajitas
Americano Taco
Chips & Salsa
Fried Cookies
Burrito Bowl

“The food was great on 4/18/24 and service was good. The atmosphere was horrific. So many crying babies and out of control children. I couldn’t even speak to my husband across the small table! We couldn’t hear each other! Maybe the restaurant needs to have a children’s only area. It is not the facility fault rather rude parents who expect us to put up with their wailing children. Please keep them home“

4.2 Good102 Reviews
Louies Grill Fusion Restaurant Cuban • $
4453 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Burrito with Home Fries
Breakfast Enchiladas
Breakfast Quesadilla
Side of Black Beans
Side of Rice & Beans
Fried Plantains
Chicken Fajitas
Side of Rice
Everything
Ropa Vieja

“Wow & Yummy! Is the words I'm always left with, when I eat at Louie's Grill Fusion. The love you put into every dish to give us that amazing satisfaction. Thank you! We’ve had almost everything on the menu. Absolutely amazing.“

4.2 Good73 Reviews
Talita's Burritos and Coneys Mexican • $
6542 Hayden Run Rd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Loose Beef Sandwich
Smothered Burrito
Hard Taco Platter
Basket of Fries
Chips and Salsa
Refried Beans
Onion Rings
Coney Fries
2 Slaw Dogs

“Jumped "the fence" and ordered the fried bologna sandwich with the pickles, onions, and mustard, basket of fries, and an order of onion rings, just to switch it up. All good and unhealthy. I've had the burritos and coneys many times before. It's a great place to stop on the way home for a quick pick up and efficient service. Again, it's a fast food place! So, what do you think the ambience is like? In and out despite the few tables and chairs and flat screen tv inviting you to sit and digest. Four stars...you have to have ambiance (hint: fancy to go boxes) to get five stars!“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
Habaneros Fresh Mexican Grill Mexican • $
3650 Main St, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Soft Taco or Quesadilla
Al Pastor Street Tacos
Fish and Shrimp Tacos
Chips and Guacamole
Ham & Oaxaca Torta
Chimichanga Style
Chips and Salsa
Barbacoa Torta
Carnitas Taco
Barbacoa Taco

“Okay I've eaten here a bunch now. This place is fantastic. The churros are the best I've ever had. The carnitas tacos are delicious. The fish tacos are fire. The tortas are awesome. Has to be some of the best street tacos in the Columbus area. $1 Al pastor on Tuesdays. Friendly staff.“

4.1 Good105 Reviews
Skyline Chili Hot Dogs • $
3693 Fishinger Blvd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Coney Oyster Crackers Cold Iceless Pepsi & Their Signature Hot Sauce
3 Way with Cheese Coneys
Skyline Oyster Crackers
Chili Cheese Coney
Chili Cheese Fries
Habanero Cheese
Bowl of Chili
Funnel Fries
5 Way Chili
Burrito

“Stopped in on 12/30 and the place was packed. That did not stop the staff from committing to giving it their all. Sat at the bar and they did not stop pusing orders and keeping the drive thru flowing. Compared to Hillard Rome Rd. & South High St. this location will be my new go to. Got three loaded cheese coneys, was made fresh and got to me quickly.“

4.1 Good69 Reviews
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
1780 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Soft Chimichanga Supreme
El Vaquero Margaritas
Enchiladas Supreme
El Manjar Vaquero
Chicken Fajitas
Tacos Al Pastor
Refried Beans
Street Tacos
Carne Asada
Quesadilla

“This is a pretty tasty Mexican spot and their Micheladas are fantastic. The service was great as well. We actually ate here two days in a row. The queso dip and chips are pretty delicious. For dinner I had the Tacos de Birria and it was so good.“

4 Good84 Reviews
Crazy Burrito Mexican • $
4081 Trueman Blvd, Hilliard

Customers` Favorites

Ground Beef Chimichanga
Enchiladas Supremas
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Fajita
Tacos de Bistek
Crazy Burrito
Crazy Fajita
Chorizo Dip
Cheese Dip
Tortillas

“The food was fresh and great! This was our first time here so I tried their signature dish which is the crazy burrito and it was great! I even had some to take home. My wife had the tacos play carne asada and she really enjoyed them.She said the guacamole was really good as well!The corn tortillas and chips are handmade here at the restaurant.Paco what's our server and he did a great job, he was on top of everything.“

3.9 Good77 Reviews
Santiago Supermarket Mexican • $
5431 Roberts Rd, Hilliard

“This review is for take out from Su Taco Kitchen, located inside this store. I've never shopped here, but I ordered delivery through Grubhub with a couple of friends. Everyone needs to know about this place, because it is, by far, the best Mexican food I've had in Columbus. The Pizza Birria in the center of the attached picture was basically a giant quesadilla, and it was delicious. The other stand-out item was the Ramen Birria (marked with an arrow in the picture because it's hard to see in the back there). I only got one bite of it before the rest was eaten, but from what I tasted, and what the people who ate it said, it was amazing. Everything else was really good, too. (Next time I'd skip the queso and the churros, though, and try a couple more things.) In the attached picture, note that we ordered everything with no beans, extra rice. 1) Platillo Alambre, 2) Chips & Queso Dip, 3) Pizza Birria, 4) Huevos Con Chorizo (Eggs & Sausage), 5) Birria Ramen*, 6) Churros, 7) Included Tortillas, Salsas, & Birria Consommé. [*The Birria Ramen is also marked with the arrow in the picture.] My picture isn't that great. There are much better pics on their social media accounts.“

3.5 Good18 Reviews