58 Shake & Pizza Shack

229 OH-58, Sullivan
(419) 736-2658

Recent Reviews

Lisa Wiley

Onion rings are amazing hamburgers used to be very good as well, but not so much this time ?

Nichole Bentley

Friendly staff, great pizza and shakes!

Jon Schaffer

BLT sub bun black so burnt frozen lettuce and tomatoes very little bacon practically no mayo onion rings weren't bad but ordered jalapeño poppers but wasn't told they were out until pick-up which was 15mins later than the 40mins I was told on the phone won't be going back

Fred T.

their lake perch isn't lake erie perch! (the way that their menu says) and that is what got my attention!! and then i asked the girl that worked there if it was lake erie perch and she said "of course"! and then i found out the truth. is that it was greasy ocean perch!! and they should really get their phone fixed, , or get the girls to answer it! unbelievable! because i live a good 5 miles away and tried to order a pizza and then had to drive over there to order it! other then that their not bad! lol!

Steven Collyer

Are you guys closed down wondering because no one ever picks up the phone ?

Megan and Matthew Nussbaum

Stopped by to grab a milkshake and was pleasantly surprised by all of the options available. Snagged some french fries too and I thought they were great. Kitchen was running a little slow, but they were kind and courteous -keeping me updated along the way. I saw they had a "hiring" sign up, so I'm sure it's just temporary a little slower paced. Would go back if I was in the area and would recommend to others.

June Drake

What ice cream shop doesn't have ice cream?Been trying to get ice cream cones. One day, chocolate only and the next visit, vanilla only. Today the sign says No Ice Cream, so I drove in and right back out.

Barbie Smith

The best chicken bacon ranch sub in Ohio

Tonya Sibert

Absolute joke after waiting outside for at least 4 minutes I was completely ignored and she went to the other window and waited on someone that was there after me then I ordered chocolate cone oh that's right you don't have chocolate cones

Scott L.

Great food and ice cream. The new owners close earlier which hinders our ability to go as often. The new owners own the market across the street, so they want to make one trip for the deposit. Wish they didn't change closing time.

Ana Tomblin

I like that place for ice cream I want to go back and try their food it looked really good and smelled really good look like they would do good for Mama & Pop shop

Jacob Hasselback

Shakes and Ice Cream Cones on a hot day

Vincent V

Quick little snack and fast food place to hit if you're at Terrence Lake

Charles Hollan

Service is usually really good but not tonight!!

Matthew Nussbaum

Stopped by to grab a milkshake and was pleasantly surprised by all of the options available. Snagged some french fries too and I thought they were great. Kitchen was running a little slow, but they were kind and courteous -keeping me updated along the way. I saw they had a "hiring" sign up, so I'm sure it's just temporary a little slower paced. Would go back if I was in the area and would recommend to others.

Load More