8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Willoughby

“Very nice people, but I think we caught them at a bad time. Several menu items were unavailable. My meal was delicious and the replacement menu items they suggested for my companions were well received.Vegetarian options: Several vegan options.“

“I don’t eat pork so finding a pizza place with topping options for me can be difficult. A random search led me to Best Pizza and I am so glad! I haven’t had a meat lovers pizza in YEARS but have had two in two weeks bc this pizza was so good! They’re a few miles from my house, always fast and friendly, and the food is top tier.Dietary restrictions: Halal menu!“

“Always amazing food and service. It was so busy tonight, but everything runs so smoothly. Even Frank, our chef, came out to check on us. Always great service from Dominic, Ava and Toni!! Can’t wait to go back. The pork chop is the best!!!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options are available“

“The Wild Goose serves up the usual pub grub, but it also happens to be exceptionally good pub grub! The draft beer list was quite respectable and featured a good balance of local and regional craft beers mixed with the usual macrobrew suspects. As for the food, the loaded goose fries were a surprisingly smashable and satisfying mess of starchy potatoes, gooey cheese, tangy aioli, smoky bacon… and a sprinkling of tomatoes to make the whole thing healthy. The pizza was, unbelievably, even more of a flavor explosion, featuring rich (but not greasy) sauces and cheeses layered atop a thin and crispy crust. (The char from the on-site pizza oven really shone through in a positive way!) The staff, meanwhile, were all very attentive and friendly. My only complaint was that the sports bar vibes didn’t do anything for me, but by the end of the meal I was in too much of a food coma to really care about my surroundings.“

“When I come here I usually order the boneless chicken with ranch for lunch and eat inside at the one table they have. I love their chicken sooo much and it always comes out smoking hot but not too hot to where it burns my mouth. The ladies who take my order are so friendly and I’ve come in so much that now they know what I want. ? but I did switch it up one time and get one of their pepperoni slices and it was delicious. The wait isn’t long and the table is always clean. Most of the time when I go to grab drinks their cold and there’s plenty of options.Parking: In a plaza so there’s plenty of parking“

“An absolutely amazing establishment that also supports the community! Geracis- Willoughby was a sponsor of our 13th annual autism awareNESS dance a thon at Eastlake Middle School and donated some delicious pizzas to help keep our dancers nourished for the 12 hours they were on their feet. Everyone I talked to from their employees to their manager was very kind and accommodating. The kids loved the pizza, and I'm happy we got to highlight this amazing local business in our brochure and slideshow throughout the dance. Thank you Geracis for supporting our mission! Eastlake Middle School appreciates you!“

“Great pizza. Staff remains despite ownership change. Stay away from the tip jar, management keeps it.“

“A friend and I stopped here for dinner one evening after a busy day sight-seeing. Neither of us are from this area, but we were both delighted to see this Pizza Hut offered indoor dining. I know that is probably seen as a hang-up to my friends, but not everyone is able to carry out or have it delivered, especially those traveling. The food was very good, typical of most Pizza Hut restaurants. The employees were very nice. It was a very good dining experience.“