Post Office Pies

270 Rele St, Mountain Brook
(205) 848-2092

Recent Reviews

Miles DeBardeleben

Addie’s service was top tier. It would have made a Chick-fil-a employee of the month look like a new hire at Captain D’s. She ran after me for 2.7 miles trying to return my jacket that I had left. She hosted, bussed, and waited on several tables without allowing us to feel forgotten. Pies were good too. I’m about to eat The Midnight Special for breakfast.

Rod Gaddy

Really great wood fired pizza. Great beer selection. And the kids drinks are free. Jarrod has excellent customer service.


Ridiculous price. I paid $70 for two pizzas and delivery and there is NOTHING special about this place. Smallest pizza ever for the price. What a freaking rip off. There are too many good pizza places in Birmingham for this and Papa John's is even better.

Jennifer Tatum

Honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had!

Alec Olander

I'm only giving it 4 stars because I've waited for over 15 min to receive my pick up order. Always delicious and super friendly. Usually, they are on top of their shiz, but a little disappointed tonight. Still a staple in the community.

Ty Reed

Always great pizza at Post Office Pies. Our server was incredibly friendly. Fresh ingredients and a great crust.

Jason Gaston

Excellent food, knowledgeable wait staff, ample parking, clean tables/bar area, eclectic decor

Hollis Taylor Hawkins

Spectacular pies-think we almost ordered one of everything ?????

Chase M.

Decent pizza and salad for a night in while staying the night in the area on the way to the beach the next day. 12 inch pizza was a good size for 2 of us to share. Their red wine vinaigrette salad dressing was nice and creamy. Good food overall!

Virginia B.

Yum! Had four different types of pizzas and all were excellent. Flavorful and crust was perfect, not chewy or soggy. Can't wait to go back!

Haley Thomaston

Love post office pies! Been my favorite pizza place in Birmingham for years!!! It has shown me that a sunny side up egg can elevate a pizza…BUT WHY…why must the price of an egg go up by $2 in a matter of a few months. I sat debating today whether I should pay $3 for an egg on pizza when I can buy a dozen at the store. I understand the consequences of inflation, don’t get me wrong, but make it make sense, people. Can I bring my own egg for you to put on my pizza?? 10/10 pizza overall. 11/10 with an egg. Will continue to frequent this establishment.

Andrew Mcdoogie

The food was excellent! I got the margarita pizza with the pepperoni breadsticks. 6 out out of 5.

Bob Opkins

Pizza was ok, very little sauce, not many mushrooms. Chicken on pizza was good. Staff very good

Leah Stone

I was in town for a night and decided to grab a bite here. By far some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!!

Wyatt E.

Amazing lil spot, great choice after spending time at the zoo. Great service and awesome pizza.

Load More