Love my NY style pizza. I couldn't find a decent pizza. Thank you Nicantoni for bring the New York taste to Arizona and Gilbert
Catherine M
Great pizza, but pricey. I still go every time though, because it's the closest thing I can get to NY pizza in Arizona. $15-20 for a 14-inch pizza.
barbara costa
Waited over an hour to be served. Had to ask about 1 appetizer that we never received. Veal was sour, sauce on lasagna cold. Was comped for 2 entrees. Not eager to return. Chose this restaurant, due to be totally satisfied with their pizza for takeout
Andre Whyte
Average at best. It's definitely bar food. I don't drink alcohol so I can imagine that the food taste better if you're intoxicated.
Brian F.
Perfect neighborhood restaurant. Cheers atmosphere and amazing staff combined with great Italian food. Phill knows his customers and appreciates them! Perfect restaurant any time
Blossom M.
I want to start by saying, this Pizza joint is in the cutest complex I've ever seen!! The location is very pretty and transports you outside of Gilbert haha. The restaurant seemed to be family-owned and nice. My friend and I were there a couple minutes after they opened, so understandably we were the only customers until we were about to leave- then the place filled up. We had the Chicken pizza and Bacon wrapped stuffed Jalapeño, the latter being my favorite. Service was really nice and our server was very sweet with her recommendations. The staff and location had covid precautions in place. Everyone was wearing a mask and every other booth was blocked off to give everyone plenty of space of be socially distant, so I was quite happy about that.
Garon M.
straight up the BEST pizza in Gilbert - not only is their pizza fast, but their staff is so welcoming and nice it makes the atmosphere one you want to stay in. Now as for the pizza.... it has that Crispy bottom to the soft middle dough, the toppings are insanely fresh and hot! If you like pizza.... and you're in Gilbert.... go here
Nick Friese
I used to work there as a cook over a decade ago when they were by the islands. I worked daily with the owner - this man expected nothing less than perfection and customers always came first. I've been to the new spot a few times and it's a good thing nothing's changed. I learned a lot as an early 20 year old working for him and couldn't thank him more for the knowledge and experience he handed me. So glad to see he's still around! Will be back again this weekend but dining in this time.
Drew Armstrong
I have been wanting to try this place for a really long time. I've heard good things about it, but sadly I was a bit disappointed. They didn't have anything close to a supreme type pizza on the menu. I asked the server about it and she said the owner would do something similar for us. That was nice, but I guess I should have asked the price ($30). The pizza itself was just ok, not very flavorful. And it's a good thing we like onions, because there were tons of them. The crust wasn't that good either, was pretty dry. Glad we finally went, but I won't be back.
James B.
Nicantoni's is excellent. It is locally owned and the food is delicious and reasonably priced. We always get the antipasta salad, it is large and contains a wide variety of ingredients. Just delicious - my wife and I split it and it is plenty. Then we get the pepperoni pizza. The crust is just fantastic and all of the ingredients are of the highest quality. They have daily specials and a happy hour. You should definitely give them a try, you will be a regular before you know it.
First time trying it ! Very good ! We got a large cheese pizza, kids Mac and cheese and honey hot wings. The pizza was good, the Mac and cheese is sooo creamy and delicious, and the honey hot wings are HOT! Be warned... sooo hot ! Delicious and we would order them again but they're hotter than we anticipated ! Wow! My lips are on fire !! Yummy food ! Will try again !
Sheyenne Frederickson
BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!! I've been searching for great pizza for a few years now in the East Valley and finally found it! Delicious pizza that never disappoints!!!!! I have yet to sIt on their patio but it looks gorgeous! I am ecstatic that I finally found a place with amazing Pizza! Even the first time I came I was sitting across from a couple who was commenting on each bite they took just like I was! It's undeniable! Whenever I want pizza this is the place I go to!
Jenn
Consistently high quality. Our favorite pizza in all of Arizona. We were customers of the original Buono's in Mesa and this brings back all our old memories. We pickup at least once a week but it's also one of our go to spots to sit down with the family as well. Love the staff too!
Maritza Carey
Ordered a fresh take and bake from here and it smelled so amazing in the oven. it's much appreciated that they brought the pizza to the car. I was very impressed with the taste and they are able to stay open while we are facing this pandemic. This was my first time here and highly recommend.
Martin Miller
Great place, love supporting small businesses.Outdoor seating was perfect, nice and quiet with a perfect atmosphere
Love my NY style pizza. I couldn't find a decent pizza. Thank you Nicantoni for bring the New York taste to Arizona and Gilbert
Great pizza, but pricey. I still go every time though, because it's the closest thing I can get to NY pizza in Arizona. $15-20 for a 14-inch pizza.
Waited over an hour to be served. Had to ask about 1 appetizer that we never received. Veal was sour, sauce on lasagna cold. Was comped for 2 entrees. Not eager to return. Chose this restaurant, due to be totally satisfied with their pizza for takeout
Average at best. It's definitely bar food. I don't drink alcohol so I can imagine that the food taste better if you're intoxicated.
Perfect neighborhood restaurant. Cheers atmosphere and amazing staff combined with great Italian food. Phill knows his customers and appreciates them! Perfect restaurant any time
I want to start by saying, this Pizza joint is in the cutest complex I've ever seen!! The location is very pretty and transports you outside of Gilbert haha. The restaurant seemed to be family-owned and nice. My friend and I were there a couple minutes after they opened, so understandably we were the only customers until we were about to leave- then the place filled up. We had the Chicken pizza and Bacon wrapped stuffed Jalapeño, the latter being my favorite. Service was really nice and our server was very sweet with her recommendations. The staff and location had covid precautions in place. Everyone was wearing a mask and every other booth was blocked off to give everyone plenty of space of be socially distant, so I was quite happy about that.
straight up the BEST pizza in Gilbert - not only is their pizza fast, but their staff is so welcoming and nice it makes the atmosphere one you want to stay in. Now as for the pizza.... it has that Crispy bottom to the soft middle dough, the toppings are insanely fresh and hot! If you like pizza.... and you're in Gilbert.... go here
I used to work there as a cook over a decade ago when they were by the islands. I worked daily with the owner - this man expected nothing less than perfection and customers always came first. I've been to the new spot a few times and it's a good thing nothing's changed. I learned a lot as an early 20 year old working for him and couldn't thank him more for the knowledge and experience he handed me. So glad to see he's still around! Will be back again this weekend but dining in this time.
I have been wanting to try this place for a really long time. I've heard good things about it, but sadly I was a bit disappointed. They didn't have anything close to a supreme type pizza on the menu. I asked the server about it and she said the owner would do something similar for us. That was nice, but I guess I should have asked the price ($30). The pizza itself was just ok, not very flavorful. And it's a good thing we like onions, because there were tons of them. The crust wasn't that good either, was pretty dry. Glad we finally went, but I won't be back.
Nicantoni's is excellent. It is locally owned and the food is delicious and reasonably priced. We always get the antipasta salad, it is large and contains a wide variety of ingredients. Just delicious - my wife and I split it and it is plenty. Then we get the pepperoni pizza. The crust is just fantastic and all of the ingredients are of the highest quality. They have daily specials and a happy hour. You should definitely give them a try, you will be a regular before you know it.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying it ! Very good ! We got a large cheese pizza, kids Mac and cheese and honey hot wings. The pizza was good, the Mac and cheese is sooo creamy and delicious, and the honey hot wings are HOT! Be warned... sooo hot ! Delicious and we would order them again but they're hotter than we anticipated ! Wow! My lips are on fire !! Yummy food ! Will try again !
BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!! I've been searching for great pizza for a few years now in the East Valley and finally found it! Delicious pizza that never disappoints!!!!! I have yet to sIt on their patio but it looks gorgeous! I am ecstatic that I finally found a place with amazing Pizza! Even the first time I came I was sitting across from a couple who was commenting on each bite they took just like I was! It's undeniable! Whenever I want pizza this is the place I go to!
Consistently high quality. Our favorite pizza in all of Arizona. We were customers of the original Buono's in Mesa and this brings back all our old memories. We pickup at least once a week but it's also one of our go to spots to sit down with the family as well. Love the staff too!
Ordered a fresh take and bake from here and it smelled so amazing in the oven. it's much appreciated that they brought the pizza to the car. I was very impressed with the taste and they are able to stay open while we are facing this pandemic. This was my first time here and highly recommend.
Great place, love supporting small businesses.Outdoor seating was perfect, nice and quiet with a perfect atmosphere