Broadway Pizza Cafe

4558 E Broadway Blvd, Tucson
(520) 322-5865

Recent Reviews

Dylan McCollum

Mike is the best. That guy can GET IT. Great drinks and pizza!

Jennifer Silberschlag

We had the best pepperoni pizza tonight! It was sooo good! We can’t wait for the next one! Thank you so much!

Armando Cervantes

last night was the first time we went to this magnificent restaurant. But It is surely not the last. We had a good time with the courteous service, with the superb meal and booze and with the modest payment. We will absolutely return there in a short time.

The D.

People are very nice but the pizza is ok. Mine was very greasy and I think they forgot a topping. In a pinch but not sure I'd order again.

lavelle killebrew

One of the best pizzas I have ever tasted. They are huge! One was enough for me. I recommend this place if you are coming to Arizona or you live here. It a must go??!

Camille Ramos

The pizza is delicious. The beer is spot on. But be prepared to wait for your food.

Chris D.

I've left a couple of 5 star reviews for Broadway pizza in the past.  When I first moved here 5 years ago, it was my first choice... always.  Then the food got a  inconsistent.

A couple of years ago I had a bunch of friends staying with me before we drove down to Mexico and we got several pies.  1/2 the pies were made with the regular dough and 1/2 the pies were made with some new dough that the distributor wanted them to try out.  The new dough was terrible.

They got back on track for a while and then again again it became inconsistent.  Shortly after that if I wanted Broadway Pizza I had to go by myself because my family wouldn't eat there.

I picked up my kids tonight and my Brother, who was with me for the dough experimentation a couple years earlier, went over to Broadway to pick up the pizza.  The guy up front was very nice.

I noticed the guy making the pizza was pulling anchovies out of the can and sticking them on the cooked pizza.  I asked about this.  The guy at the front said sometimes the toppings go into the cheese.  This has been my experience with all pizza toppings and is my preferred method.  It's also the way they used to make the pizzas as you can see from my previous reviews and pictures.  The maskless pizza maker tried to cook the anchovies separately and put them on top of the pie.  He then brought the pizza out to me without his mask.

When we got home, the box was already soaking through with grease, the crust sucked and was soggy (I'm about 6 or 7 minutes away) from Broadway Pizza.  My kids hated it so I'm having burgers delivered now while I'm typing this review.

I've been here many times, but this is the last.  Do what you will with your pizza, but put a mask on like the rest of us.  Give me a break!

Mark B.

No stars, worst pizza I ever had. Greezzy grease is a understatement, the dough was worst than shoe leather, trust me this joint should be ashamed of themselves, the bottom of the box fell out from the all grease, we order 4 pizza threw away 3-1/2. Uh no, on a one bite 1.8

James Lehmann

I was craving that perfect New York slice at 6pm on Saturday in Tucson Arizona. WhichI was sure did not exist. I did some searching and after a few good guides decided this had to be the closest I could get. I rolled the dice.....I ordered the classic 16” pepperoni and was in absolute pizza heaven. The crust was foldable and chewy with a good pizza flavor. Earthy and just slightly fermented with a perfect steamy crumb in the edge.The pepperoni was exactly what I expected and wanted. Salty and spicy it was a nice balance to the slightly sweet but mostly rich tomato sauce that was fresh and full of deep tomato flavor.Well worth a stop anytime you can. One of the best slices I’ve had in a very long time.

Nick James

Pizza was really good. Sauce really stood out. And everyone was really nice.

K. Taylor

When in town best place to go for Pizza, love the small local shops!

Eva Lewisky

By far the best pizza in town. My pain center across the street let me know about this place. I happened to run into the Director who raved about this Pizza place and the famous Marcos. Cant tell you how good it is. Felt like I was back in Long Island.

Kevin Smith

Pizza is delicious and great customer service. Give these guys a shot – I’ll definitely be back.

Michael Dunaway

Best pizza in town, no question. Become a regular.

Cianna A.

Get the large cheese pizza, and you won't regret it. Easily the best slice of cheese pizza my husband and I have ever had. Once you try it, there's no going back. We're hooked.

Load More