I think the star rating system is more objective than anything I would write ...this cookie monster was there too...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Melokidi 97
Easy decision you'll make! GREAT cookies. It's a must whenever I'm in the neighborhood. The selection is always just right. No matter your interest, you'll love these!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Various Cookies, Toffee Chip
Lesley W.
Definitely delicious cookies . Good thing I don't live in the area, I'd be there wayyy to often
Rafael Reyna Jr
Never been just wondering what people go here for
M C.
For a cookie shop, this place is really big. But no real place to sit. The cookies are fresh and quite good, but they are not particularly big portions. Service is nice.
Janaiah M.
Amazing cookies & business owner!! Sooo delicious, the chocolate walnut are legendary
Ray B.
Ok, so that's what we're going to do?? Say how great this place is when it's not even in the top 20? And that's not good considering there aren't many cookie-only spots around. Nothing against AC, but giving an honest review helps everyone on this platform. That being said, AC is way too big, the cookies are way too small and they're overpriced, which would be ok if they were amazing, but they're not. They're only slightly better than the frozen roll from the supermarket you make yourself - and that's only because you have to make them yourself! My suggestion to the AC owners is to get on the giant cookie trend - like Bang Cookies from the East Coast and Hot Cookie in SF. They both charge more for a bigger and better product - but if business is good, disregard my suggestions and carry on. BB
Alok Jain
The cookies might have been nice but the place was running out of almost everything. Most of the cookies were not even available.
Christopher R.
Yesterday I stop by Anthony cookies. I ordered two chocolate chip, one chocolate chip with nuts and one cookies and cream cookies. The cookies and cream cookies was delicious and very soft. The chocolate chip cookies were delicious too. The cookies and cream were my favorite. The customer service service was great. Staff was very helpful about the menu and what is available. Ambiance is great and there is parking right up front. This is a great cooking place to go.
Marissa D.
We came in during mid afternoon and there weren't a lot of cookies but a fair amount to choose from. We got a mixed selection of several different flavors. The cookies were tiny, over priced, and every single one was burnt. The edges were so dark that every bite was burnt cookie taste that just wouldn't leave your mouth. The chocolate covered shortbread was so thick and crunchy that it just wasn't the right texture and was flavorless. The chocolate chip was just meh and not much flavor to them as well. The peanut butter cookies were absolutely the worst peanut butter cookies I have ever had, I took one bite and had to spit it out because it was so salty. I will definitely never be back again unfortunately. I really was looking forward to trying them but I was left severely disappointed and sticker shocked. I would not recommend these cookies anyone.
These cookies are not worth the price!!! The flavors are mediocre and the size is ridiculously small...2.50 for a cookie that in general would be .50. You can get bigger & better elsewhere... Another downside card only & couldn't get a paper reciept..
Mary S.
The cookies are good but way overpriced. The cookies are tiny and run about $2.50. These are the type of cookies you buy in pack at a grocery store/ get catered for event, not to buy one offs. Would rather pay for hot cookie.
Tracy C.
I finally got to try this place. The shop is pretty big with a menu on the wall and at the cashier. You wait in line to order and grab to go. I went at noon, which is when they open because I read other reviews saying if you go later during the day, they might be sold out of certain flavors. Also, there's only street parking, but I didn't have any trouble finding parking. I ordered chocolate chip, cookies and cream, peanut butter, toffee chip, and chocolate covered short bread. All the cookies were delicious. My personal favorite was cookies and cream, but my partner's favorite was chocolate chip. Peanut butter cookie was soft and buttery, while short bread cookie melted in my mouth. All the other cookies were crispy and chewy. I highly recommend this place and can't wait to go back to get more cookies.
Sen T.
These cookies changed my life. The absolute best. All my life I've never really had sweet tooth until I've tried these cookies. I've tried most of the flavors but the one that I got addicted to were the cookie and cream flavor. I told myself no place or other cookie would ever beat this one. That is until they released a German chocolate flavored cookie. It instantly become my favorite one, however I haven't seen it available the last few times I've gone. So until then I'll continue to get 7 cookie and cream cookies when I visit. One for each day of the week, because my life is in shambles if I don't start my day off with one of these cookies.
Jessica G.
Big fan of Anthony's cookies over here. I'll stop by every time I'm in Berkeley without fail. My fiancé first brought home Anthony's cookies when he got it as a gift from work during the pandemic. Since then, we've been hooked. When we learned they had a shop here in the East Bay, it was even better. They've always got some great cookies stocked throughout the day but if you can, definitely try to get there in the morning/early afternoon to get your choice before some cookies sell out! My fav is the toffee chip and my fiancé loves their German chocolate (but it always sells out) and cookies and cream. Truly the perfect balance of everything - not too crunchy, not too soft, not too sweet. Service is always great and one time I even got to meet Anthony himself! It was so great to learn about his passion for baking and the story behind the shop. I've yet to make it to the SF location, but rest assured, I'll be coming back to the Berkeley location probably forever lol.
I think the star rating system is more objective than anything I would write ...this cookie monster was there too...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Easy decision you'll make! GREAT cookies. It's a must whenever I'm in the neighborhood. The selection is always just right. No matter your interest, you'll love these!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Various Cookies, Toffee Chip
Definitely delicious cookies . Good thing I don't live in the area, I'd be there wayyy to often
Never been just wondering what people go here for
For a cookie shop, this place is really big. But no real place to sit. The cookies are fresh and quite good, but they are not particularly big portions. Service is nice.
Amazing cookies & business owner!! Sooo delicious, the chocolate walnut are legendary
Ok, so that's what we're going to do?? Say how great this place is when it's not even in the top 20? And that's not good considering there aren't many cookie-only spots around. Nothing against AC, but giving an honest review helps everyone on this platform. That being said, AC is way too big, the cookies are way too small and they're overpriced, which would be ok if they were amazing, but they're not. They're only slightly better than the frozen roll from the supermarket you make yourself - and that's only because you have to make them yourself! My suggestion to the AC owners is to get on the giant cookie trend - like Bang Cookies from the East Coast and Hot Cookie in SF. They both charge more for a bigger and better product - but if business is good, disregard my suggestions and carry on. BB
The cookies might have been nice but the place was running out of almost everything. Most of the cookies were not even available.
Yesterday I stop by Anthony cookies. I ordered two chocolate chip, one chocolate chip with nuts and one cookies and cream cookies. The cookies and cream cookies was delicious and very soft. The chocolate chip cookies were delicious too. The cookies and cream were my favorite. The customer service service was great. Staff was very helpful about the menu and what is available. Ambiance is great and there is parking right up front. This is a great cooking place to go.
We came in during mid afternoon and there weren't a lot of cookies but a fair amount to choose from. We got a mixed selection of several different flavors. The cookies were tiny, over priced, and every single one was burnt. The edges were so dark that every bite was burnt cookie taste that just wouldn't leave your mouth. The chocolate covered shortbread was so thick and crunchy that it just wasn't the right texture and was flavorless. The chocolate chip was just meh and not much flavor to them as well. The peanut butter cookies were absolutely the worst peanut butter cookies I have ever had, I took one bite and had to spit it out because it was so salty. I will definitely never be back again unfortunately. I really was looking forward to trying them but I was left severely disappointed and sticker shocked. I would not recommend these cookies anyone.
Restaurantji Recommends
These cookies are not worth the price!!! The flavors are mediocre and the size is ridiculously small...2.50 for a cookie that in general would be .50. You can get bigger & better elsewhere... Another downside card only & couldn't get a paper reciept..
The cookies are good but way overpriced. The cookies are tiny and run about $2.50. These are the type of cookies you buy in pack at a grocery store/ get catered for event, not to buy one offs. Would rather pay for hot cookie.
I finally got to try this place. The shop is pretty big with a menu on the wall and at the cashier. You wait in line to order and grab to go. I went at noon, which is when they open because I read other reviews saying if you go later during the day, they might be sold out of certain flavors. Also, there's only street parking, but I didn't have any trouble finding parking. I ordered chocolate chip, cookies and cream, peanut butter, toffee chip, and chocolate covered short bread. All the cookies were delicious. My personal favorite was cookies and cream, but my partner's favorite was chocolate chip. Peanut butter cookie was soft and buttery, while short bread cookie melted in my mouth. All the other cookies were crispy and chewy. I highly recommend this place and can't wait to go back to get more cookies.
These cookies changed my life. The absolute best. All my life I've never really had sweet tooth until I've tried these cookies. I've tried most of the flavors but the one that I got addicted to were the cookie and cream flavor. I told myself no place or other cookie would ever beat this one. That is until they released a German chocolate flavored cookie. It instantly become my favorite one, however I haven't seen it available the last few times I've gone. So until then I'll continue to get 7 cookie and cream cookies when I visit. One for each day of the week, because my life is in shambles if I don't start my day off with one of these cookies.
Big fan of Anthony's cookies over here. I'll stop by every time I'm in Berkeley without fail. My fiancé first brought home Anthony's cookies when he got it as a gift from work during the pandemic. Since then, we've been hooked. When we learned they had a shop here in the East Bay, it was even better. They've always got some great cookies stocked throughout the day but if you can, definitely try to get there in the morning/early afternoon to get your choice before some cookies sell out! My fav is the toffee chip and my fiancé loves their German chocolate (but it always sells out) and cookies and cream. Truly the perfect balance of everything - not too crunchy, not too soft, not too sweet. Service is always great and one time I even got to meet Anthony himself! It was so great to learn about his passion for baking and the story behind the shop. I've yet to make it to the SF location, but rest assured, I'll be coming back to the Berkeley location probably forever lol.