Since they reopened under new ownership, a new chef and menu, and recently a new brewer, the food is good but a bit overpriced, and the beer is good but in limited variety compared to the original ownership.
Mason Francoeur
The pretzel appetizer is a g.d. scam! $14 for two pretzel sticks? Seriously? Have fun losing business! I just went to the canyon club brewery in Moraga and for $10 i got three pretzels. The portion size to price ratio is infuriating. I didn't know this place got bought out by Jewish people.
Don Frasco
Lots of free parking spaces are available. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Make reservations for big groups. Great place to enjoy craft beer and watch sports. Must try their Tasmanian and Stout beers. Their fish and chips were humongous and crispy.
Mike Juarez
That was OUTSTANDING....!!!! Everything was So Delicious.. We ordered a few things off the menu... Wow .Definitely gonna make this place a Regular Hangout.... CHEERS and SEMPER FIDELIS.....!!!!!
Carolina Alcota
The menu does not have the prices, we ordered a pizza, it arrived and it was almost personal size, apart from it was poorly prepared and to my surprise I asked for the bill and ICost 41 dollars? a pizza whose value does not exceed 10 anywhere elseI WOULD NOT GO AGAINWE HAVE TWO BEERS AND A PIZZA 65 dollarsA THEFT ????????????
Ben Morrison
Great beer, great food, great service! Loved the Italian pizza!! Ricochet Red ale was very tasty. So was the Alimony Ale.
Aakash Mhankale
Variety of ? Beer options. Loved Chocolate tres leches, Must try. Up scale ambience. Expensive food options.
Lesley Semmel
So happy they have reopened. The food is still good but I was disappointed that they got rid of the chicken sausage pizza!!! It was one of my favorites!!! Hope they will consider bringing it back PLEASE!!!!
Karan Bhansali
Buffalo Bill's is an excellent brewery to visit if you are in the Hayward area. There is ample public parking behind Buffalo Bill's which makes this place very accessible.They have a large menu with a wide variety of appetizers, sandwiches, pizza, beer, wine & non-alcoholic beverages.We ordered the Veggie Pizza, Nachos, Pretzel & Mac and Cheese - all the items were well cooked and had good flavor.
vu nguyen
stopped by for beer and snacks. really liked it. disappointed the alimony IPA was not bitter hahaha. would come back.
Soooo happy and excited that this place has re-opened! I've been coming to this place for over 25 years. Beer was good, but didn't taste quite like it used to. Service was decent, despite a few minor issues. But the staff tried their best to quickly rectify. The food definitely needs some work. It wasn't horrible, but everybody knows this place was well known for their food. Pizza needs some work but still decent. Despite the other reviews, I think the prices were fairly reasonable. Was really torn on how to write this review, because I really want to see this place succeed. This place is a historic monument for a lot of us locals. It has a lot of potential to be very successful. And it's in a prime location. I'll still be coming back to support this business. Big "Thank You" to the owners for keeping this place alive.
Rachael R.
Went on a Wednesday evening and was sat immediately (there was just 2 of us). The place looked properly busy, more than I would've expected on a weekday night, but still had plenty of empty tables open as well. Unfortunately we waited 10 minutes after being sat at our table, and with not a single server coming by we decided to leave. 10 minutes and nobody came with water, nobody said "I'll be right with you", nobody asking if we had been helped. We even were sat right by the kitchen so staff was constantly walking past us.Buffalo Bill's is very well known and we were really looking forward to trying it. My friend has been in the beer industry for a long time (10+ years), so I was excited to take him here. We were also surprised there was no beer or drink menu, especially since it's a brewery! With everything considered - no service, no drink menu, and surprising prices for basically pizzas/burgers/wings - I don't know if we'd try coming again.Since we never got to try any food or drinks, I can't comment on that and will therefore leave this review with 2 stars instead of 1.
Kish K.
I am glad Buffalo Bills re-opened. However, their prices are absolutely ridiculous. I took my nephew and niece on a Thursday evening. My nephew ordered a kids cheese pizza and fries with a soda. My niece ordered chicken strips and waffle fries and a soda. I ordered a pizza and 2 beers. Total cost without tip $122. The food was good, but $23 for a personal pizza is ridiculous, and $9 for a pint. I really want to support local businesses. However, I refuse to be fleeced. Blue Crown has more reasonable prices and they are still trying to work out the kinks. With that being said, I may go for the beer but not the food.
Louie hernandez
Great Thursday night with a friend and great service and food. Miss this place when it was closed
Stacey Madamba
So glad they are back!!! Had my pumpkin beer and a chicken Caesar salad. Kids had burgers and they were excellent. It’s as if it never left! Beer is amazing there! I hope they bring back their orange crème beer one day. Fun place and livens up downtown.
Since they reopened under new ownership, a new chef and menu, and recently a new brewer, the food is good but a bit overpriced, and the beer is good but in limited variety compared to the original ownership.
The pretzel appetizer is a g.d. scam! $14 for two pretzel sticks? Seriously? Have fun losing business! I just went to the canyon club brewery in Moraga and for $10 i got three pretzels. The portion size to price ratio is infuriating. I didn't know this place got bought out by Jewish people.
Lots of free parking spaces are available. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Make reservations for big groups. Great place to enjoy craft beer and watch sports. Must try their Tasmanian and Stout beers. Their fish and chips were humongous and crispy.
That was OUTSTANDING....!!!! Everything was So Delicious.. We ordered a few things off the menu... Wow .Definitely gonna make this place a Regular Hangout.... CHEERS and SEMPER FIDELIS.....!!!!!
The menu does not have the prices, we ordered a pizza, it arrived and it was almost personal size, apart from it was poorly prepared and to my surprise I asked for the bill and ICost 41 dollars? a pizza whose value does not exceed 10 anywhere elseI WOULD NOT GO AGAINWE HAVE TWO BEERS AND A PIZZA 65 dollarsA THEFT ????????????
Great beer, great food, great service! Loved the Italian pizza!! Ricochet Red ale was very tasty. So was the Alimony Ale.
Variety of ? Beer options. Loved Chocolate tres leches, Must try. Up scale ambience. Expensive food options.
So happy they have reopened. The food is still good but I was disappointed that they got rid of the chicken sausage pizza!!! It was one of my favorites!!! Hope they will consider bringing it back PLEASE!!!!
Buffalo Bill's is an excellent brewery to visit if you are in the Hayward area. There is ample public parking behind Buffalo Bill's which makes this place very accessible.They have a large menu with a wide variety of appetizers, sandwiches, pizza, beer, wine & non-alcoholic beverages.We ordered the Veggie Pizza, Nachos, Pretzel & Mac and Cheese - all the items were well cooked and had good flavor.
stopped by for beer and snacks. really liked it. disappointed the alimony IPA was not bitter hahaha. would come back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Soooo happy and excited that this place has re-opened! I've been coming to this place for over 25 years. Beer was good, but didn't taste quite like it used to. Service was decent, despite a few minor issues. But the staff tried their best to quickly rectify. The food definitely needs some work. It wasn't horrible, but everybody knows this place was well known for their food. Pizza needs some work but still decent. Despite the other reviews, I think the prices were fairly reasonable. Was really torn on how to write this review, because I really want to see this place succeed. This place is a historic monument for a lot of us locals. It has a lot of potential to be very successful. And it's in a prime location. I'll still be coming back to support this business. Big "Thank You" to the owners for keeping this place alive.
Went on a Wednesday evening and was sat immediately (there was just 2 of us). The place looked properly busy, more than I would've expected on a weekday night, but still had plenty of empty tables open as well. Unfortunately we waited 10 minutes after being sat at our table, and with not a single server coming by we decided to leave. 10 minutes and nobody came with water, nobody said "I'll be right with you", nobody asking if we had been helped. We even were sat right by the kitchen so staff was constantly walking past us.Buffalo Bill's is very well known and we were really looking forward to trying it. My friend has been in the beer industry for a long time (10+ years), so I was excited to take him here. We were also surprised there was no beer or drink menu, especially since it's a brewery! With everything considered - no service, no drink menu, and surprising prices for basically pizzas/burgers/wings - I don't know if we'd try coming again.Since we never got to try any food or drinks, I can't comment on that and will therefore leave this review with 2 stars instead of 1.
I am glad Buffalo Bills re-opened. However, their prices are absolutely ridiculous. I took my nephew and niece on a Thursday evening. My nephew ordered a kids cheese pizza and fries with a soda. My niece ordered chicken strips and waffle fries and a soda. I ordered a pizza and 2 beers. Total cost without tip $122. The food was good, but $23 for a personal pizza is ridiculous, and $9 for a pint. I really want to support local businesses. However, I refuse to be fleeced. Blue Crown has more reasonable prices and they are still trying to work out the kinks. With that being said, I may go for the beer but not the food.
Great Thursday night with a friend and great service and food. Miss this place when it was closed
So glad they are back!!! Had my pumpkin beer and a chicken Caesar salad. Kids had burgers and they were excellent. It’s as if it never left! Beer is amazing there! I hope they bring back their orange crème beer one day. Fun place and livens up downtown.