Surprisingly good pies, especially for the price. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Angel Moscoso
Best pie in the bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica G.
What a GEM! And a hidden one at that.Celebrated Thanksgiving a bit early with #ThankYouThursday and decided to check out pot pie paradise after seeing the great reviews on Yelp. I'm not normally a pot pie type of person, but with the cold weather, it was definitely the way to go.Pot Pie Paradise is nestled in an industrial part of Hayward so it's a bit of a drive through back roads to get there. They've got a decent parking lot and when I stopped by after lunch time, it wasn't too busy. They have a really helpful menu that shows all the options they have for pies, sandwiches, and other lunch choices. It's also updated to show which pies they're sold out of. I wanted to try the bulgogi beef but unfortunately they were sold out that day. Instead, I went for the Thai chicken curry. The Thai chicken curry pot pie ($10) had noodles, green beans, chicken, and carrots in it. It was delicious! I don't usually have noodles with thai chicken curry but it worked here. It's a pretty good portion for lunch and can maybe even be shared with two people. Though for me, I ended up just having the rest later for dinner.The service was great and the staff was very helpful. I loved reading the newspaper articles they have posted around the shop as I waited. They've got lots of seating inside if you prefer to dine in but I opted to take it to-go.Such a great local business! I'll definitely be back to try other pot pie options.
John Shi
These are the best pot pies I’ve ever had, and they are easy to make from frozen. I will be eating these pies for as long as I live here. The flavor diversity is amazing.
Mark S.
My Beef Spicy Chili pie was awesome. Amazing crust and the filling was flavorful and cooked to perfection.I liked it so much, I got a few others to take home and eat later!Great service too.
LaRee J.
I haven't had a pot pie yet but my turkey sandwich was really good... fresh, I had sliced wheat bread and cheddar cheese... my supervisor put in the order so that's how I found out about the place I will definitely be back
Sophia K.
I didn't think I would like this place so much, but damn the pot pies are good! I got the gumbo and the husband got the thai duck. Both were packed with protein, veggies and flavor and the crust was so flaky! It does take about 10 minutes to make/heat up which was the only downside, but it was still worth it. Overall, delicious pot pies and I can't wait to try the other ones!
Kathy T.
Found this hidden gem on a drive one day going to work and I knew I had to make time to stop by. I was very excited to try the various pies given the range of flavors and options! I decided to go with the classic American chicken pot pie, because I figured you can't go wrong with a classic for a first try. And it definitely held up to my expectations! The crust was flakey, buttery, and so savory and the chucks of chicken were hearty and plentiful! Paired with the peas, carrots and melt in your mouth potatoes. It definitely hit the spot on a gloomy day! I ate it in the store so there's an additional $0.50 charge for that but they also have plenty of frozen pies as well! It's a cute little shop ran by some of the nicest staff and the sweetest owner who is often seen at the register. If you have the chance, make sure to stop by to find your favorite pie! It may be hard to locate because it's in a very industrial area and on the corner of a warehouse type building, but once you find it you'll be glad you did!
Kat J.
My husband picked up the Thai Chicken Curry and the Spicy Duck with Red Curry for lunch. They were made to order, hotter than hades, but oh so delicious. Just the right amount of spicy and the texture of the pastry was just perfection. I cannot wait to try their other pot pies like the Chicken & Mushroom and Lemon Capers Chicken. They also have dessert pies, vegetarian and vegan!
Val M
Great hidden gem in Hayward with a surprisingly diverse menu. There are many international flavors and vegetarian options. I had the Thai currency sweet potato pie to go. It was absolutely delicious. Macaroons and cookies are available for dessertVegetarian options: Plenty available
Came here for a quick lunch at the recommendation of a friend and was blown away! If you like pot pies, this is truly a pot pie paradise, one you won't soon forget.Tip: They are only open until 3 p.m. most days and popular items tend to sell out quickly so I would swing by earlier if there's a specific menu item you wanted to try. I wanted the lamb shepherd's pie and the lobster seafood pie, but they were both sold out so I settled for a traditional chicken pot pie with a side of soup. The menu items are of a decent size; I was full after both pie and soup (and I tend to have a heartier appetite than most). The service was friendly and relatively quick, and while I didn't opt to eat in, there are plenty of small tables for those who want a dine-in experience (probably not good for large groups though).Best of all, the menu is extensive with a list of pies galore - and so many interesting flavors and combinations to choose from (including Kobe beef, chicken masala, and much more). I'm definitely coming back again when I next have a craving for pot pie!
Large Raccoon
Curry and pot pie are my two favorite foods and i never thought I'd see a place that combined the two, it was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brenda Delgadillo
Super delicious freshly made pot pies. The owner is an absolute sweetheart with hands of gold. Whether you're an omnivore, vegetarian or vegan, there are many options to choose from! Over the years I've tried their meat pies, vegetarian pies, and since I've recently gone vegan... Their vegan pies! (Yes multiple vegan pies! Not just an option or two, but 8+ options!). From American cuisine to spicy pies inspired from Asian inspired pies, there is a pie for everyone. Their coconut cookies are also house made. They have pies to eat on the spot or frozen pies you can take home.I used to not be particularly attracted to pot pies and didn't care for them, until I tried this place. Now I am a pot pie lover.They are a bit out of the way but worth the trip 100 times over.They also sell dessert pies which l have yet to try.This is one of my favorite places to eat. THANK YOU FOR YOUR DELICIOUS FOOD!!!!Try one or try them all. You literally can't go wrong. They are ALL amazing. Just depends what you're on the mood for ?Vegetarian options: Beyond this world! Check their menu online, there are many options and flavors. Yum!Dietary restrictions: As mentioned before they have many options to fit many dietary restrictions. Also the owner is super nice and is honest and open about her recipes and more than happy to talk to you for any questions or ingredients. If you're really super worried about something specific.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ronald Pummer
Ver friendly, very clean. Pies have fresh ingredients with good flavor. Good choice when you don't feel like cooking and don't feel like going to a restaurant.
Michael Manning
The pot pies are delicious, I just wish they made more regular chicken ones so they weren't always sold out
Surprisingly good pies, especially for the price. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pie in the bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a GEM! And a hidden one at that.Celebrated Thanksgiving a bit early with #ThankYouThursday and decided to check out pot pie paradise after seeing the great reviews on Yelp. I'm not normally a pot pie type of person, but with the cold weather, it was definitely the way to go.Pot Pie Paradise is nestled in an industrial part of Hayward so it's a bit of a drive through back roads to get there. They've got a decent parking lot and when I stopped by after lunch time, it wasn't too busy. They have a really helpful menu that shows all the options they have for pies, sandwiches, and other lunch choices. It's also updated to show which pies they're sold out of. I wanted to try the bulgogi beef but unfortunately they were sold out that day. Instead, I went for the Thai chicken curry. The Thai chicken curry pot pie ($10) had noodles, green beans, chicken, and carrots in it. It was delicious! I don't usually have noodles with thai chicken curry but it worked here. It's a pretty good portion for lunch and can maybe even be shared with two people. Though for me, I ended up just having the rest later for dinner.The service was great and the staff was very helpful. I loved reading the newspaper articles they have posted around the shop as I waited. They've got lots of seating inside if you prefer to dine in but I opted to take it to-go.Such a great local business! I'll definitely be back to try other pot pie options.
These are the best pot pies I’ve ever had, and they are easy to make from frozen. I will be eating these pies for as long as I live here. The flavor diversity is amazing.
My Beef Spicy Chili pie was awesome. Amazing crust and the filling was flavorful and cooked to perfection.I liked it so much, I got a few others to take home and eat later!Great service too.
I haven't had a pot pie yet but my turkey sandwich was really good... fresh, I had sliced wheat bread and cheddar cheese... my supervisor put in the order so that's how I found out about the place I will definitely be back
I didn't think I would like this place so much, but damn the pot pies are good! I got the gumbo and the husband got the thai duck. Both were packed with protein, veggies and flavor and the crust was so flaky! It does take about 10 minutes to make/heat up which was the only downside, but it was still worth it. Overall, delicious pot pies and I can't wait to try the other ones!
Found this hidden gem on a drive one day going to work and I knew I had to make time to stop by. I was very excited to try the various pies given the range of flavors and options! I decided to go with the classic American chicken pot pie, because I figured you can't go wrong with a classic for a first try. And it definitely held up to my expectations! The crust was flakey, buttery, and so savory and the chucks of chicken were hearty and plentiful! Paired with the peas, carrots and melt in your mouth potatoes. It definitely hit the spot on a gloomy day! I ate it in the store so there's an additional $0.50 charge for that but they also have plenty of frozen pies as well! It's a cute little shop ran by some of the nicest staff and the sweetest owner who is often seen at the register. If you have the chance, make sure to stop by to find your favorite pie! It may be hard to locate because it's in a very industrial area and on the corner of a warehouse type building, but once you find it you'll be glad you did!
My husband picked up the Thai Chicken Curry and the Spicy Duck with Red Curry for lunch. They were made to order, hotter than hades, but oh so delicious. Just the right amount of spicy and the texture of the pastry was just perfection. I cannot wait to try their other pot pies like the Chicken & Mushroom and Lemon Capers Chicken. They also have dessert pies, vegetarian and vegan!
Great hidden gem in Hayward with a surprisingly diverse menu. There are many international flavors and vegetarian options. I had the Thai currency sweet potato pie to go. It was absolutely delicious. Macaroons and cookies are available for dessertVegetarian options: Plenty available
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Came here for a quick lunch at the recommendation of a friend and was blown away! If you like pot pies, this is truly a pot pie paradise, one you won't soon forget.Tip: They are only open until 3 p.m. most days and popular items tend to sell out quickly so I would swing by earlier if there's a specific menu item you wanted to try. I wanted the lamb shepherd's pie and the lobster seafood pie, but they were both sold out so I settled for a traditional chicken pot pie with a side of soup. The menu items are of a decent size; I was full after both pie and soup (and I tend to have a heartier appetite than most). The service was friendly and relatively quick, and while I didn't opt to eat in, there are plenty of small tables for those who want a dine-in experience (probably not good for large groups though).Best of all, the menu is extensive with a list of pies galore - and so many interesting flavors and combinations to choose from (including Kobe beef, chicken masala, and much more). I'm definitely coming back again when I next have a craving for pot pie!
Curry and pot pie are my two favorite foods and i never thought I'd see a place that combined the two, it was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super delicious freshly made pot pies. The owner is an absolute sweetheart with hands of gold. Whether you're an omnivore, vegetarian or vegan, there are many options to choose from! Over the years I've tried their meat pies, vegetarian pies, and since I've recently gone vegan... Their vegan pies! (Yes multiple vegan pies! Not just an option or two, but 8+ options!). From American cuisine to spicy pies inspired from Asian inspired pies, there is a pie for everyone. Their coconut cookies are also house made. They have pies to eat on the spot or frozen pies you can take home.I used to not be particularly attracted to pot pies and didn't care for them, until I tried this place. Now I am a pot pie lover.They are a bit out of the way but worth the trip 100 times over.They also sell dessert pies which l have yet to try.This is one of my favorite places to eat. THANK YOU FOR YOUR DELICIOUS FOOD!!!!Try one or try them all. You literally can't go wrong. They are ALL amazing. Just depends what you're on the mood for ?Vegetarian options: Beyond this world! Check their menu online, there are many options and flavors. Yum!Dietary restrictions: As mentioned before they have many options to fit many dietary restrictions. Also the owner is super nice and is honest and open about her recipes and more than happy to talk to you for any questions or ingredients. If you're really super worried about something specific.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ver friendly, very clean. Pies have fresh ingredients with good flavor. Good choice when you don't feel like cooking and don't feel like going to a restaurant.
The pot pies are delicious, I just wish they made more regular chicken ones so they weren't always sold out
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie