I Like Pie Bakeshop

38 S Raymond Ave, Pasadena
(626) 345-5959

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Salted Caramel Banana JJ
Chocolate Chip Chess
Mixed Berry Pie
Assorted Pies
Key Lime Pie
Butter Pecan
Pumpkin Pie

Menu

Sweet Jelly Jar
S'mores Jelly Jar
Imagine a rich layer of chocolate ganache and pastry cream inside graham crust. Now top that with housemade marshmallow fluff, perfectly toasted, and garnished with a chocolate square. You've got a fireside treat turned luxurious indulgence.
Pumpkin Praline Jelly Jar
Sept-Nov This popular fall flavor starts with creamy, lightly spiced pumpkin filling in traditional crust. Then gets a decadent ILP upgrade with a sweet cream cheese center and salty-sweet pecan praline crumble.
Chocolate Chip Chess Jelly Jar
Our Chocolate Chip Chess pie takes a twist on a classic favorite with the chocolatey, gooey goodness of a warm cookie and brown sugar custard in our buttery, sweet crust and garnished with a dusting of powdered sugar, chocolate chips and an individual chocolate chip cookie.
Traditional Pumpkin Jelly Jar
Dig into this, and it's officially fall. Delightfully creamier than most, our pumpkin filling is lightly spiced and showcased in our buttery, tender traditional crust. Of course, it gets topped with fresh whipped cream.
Caramel Apple Jelly Jar
Caramel Apple pie is one of the most nostalgic pies. Tart granny smith apples are baked in sweet cinnamon sugar, topped with the crunch of a cinnamon shortbread crumble, and garnished with a dollop of Salted Caramel.
Salted Caramel Banana Jelly Jar
This is sweet + salty at its tastiest. Dig into a layer of ripe bananas, homemade pastry cream, and a dollop of salted caramel in our traditional crust. Topped with whip and salted toffee bits. (It's OK to drool.) Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Butter Pecan Ice Cream!
Key Lime Jelly Jar
You know this one: classic key lime filling, salty sweet graham crust, and a must-have mound of fresh whipped cream. Tart, creamy and here year-round thanks to customer pleas. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Ube Coconut Ice Cream!
Mixed Berry Jelly Jar
Meet our most popular fruit pie. It's sweet, tart, and brimming with blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and cherries. Baked in our traditional crust and topped with shortbread crumble. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Triple Berry Cream Cheese Ice Cream!
Butter Pecan Jelly Jar
Crunchy pecans and extra-buttery brown sugar custard make this a fall classic. The traditional crust and dollop of salty-sweet pecan cream cheese make it an irresistible ILP creation. Another reason why we love fall!
Cookie Butter Jelly Jar
Baked in our signature graham cracker crust, this pie is layered with cookie butter cream cheese filling and topped with mounds of whipped cream and Speculoos cookie crumbs. Topped with a Speculoos cookie. A popular treat year-round!
Dutch Apple Jelly Jar
Dutch Apple pie is one of the most nostalgic pies. Tart granny smith apples are baked in sweet cinnamon sugar, topped with the crunch of a cinnamon shortbread crumble, and garnished with an apple crust cookie.
Peach Strawberry
Peaches & Cream
Peanut Butter Chocolate
Cherry Oatmeal Jelly Jar

Hand Pies
Apple Hand Pie
Sept-Oct Full apple pie flavor in the palm of your hand. We bake a beautifully balanced filling of tart Granny Smith apples and cinnamon sugar into chewy hand pie crust, then sprinkle on cinnamon sugar. Yes, warm it. Yes, add ice cream.
Mixed Berry Hand Pie
For a sweet, tart treat, get your hands on this bounty of cherries and berries in our flaky, chewy crust. Sprinkled with a crunch of raw sugar. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Salted Caramel Ice Cream!
Peach Hand Pie
Cherry Hand Pie
The Cherry Hand Pie is our flaky, chewy hand pie crust with tart cherries topped with a vanilla glaze drizzle. This hand pie is one of our most requested! This is Annika's favorite hand pie on the menu.

Savory Pies
Chicken Pot Pie
White meat chicken, diced carrots, celery, onions, and peas in a creamy herb sauce surrounded by our savory crust. A year-round favorite and an ILP classic.
Turkey Gravy with Harvest Stuffing
A personal feast awaits with slow-roasted turkey and house gravy hugged by a buttery crust and topped with oh-so-delicious stuffing (carrots, celery, onions, roasted chestnuts). Comes with an extra side of gravy.
Spicy Potato Hand Pie
For his hearty veggie option, we fill buttery, flaky hand pie crust with roasted potatoes and butternut squash in a craveable shallot cream sauce. Brightened by fresh herbs, lemon and spices for a little kick. This one's perfectly portable and served with vibrant mint cilantro chutney.

Vegan Pies
Vegan Mixed Berry Jelly Jar
Meet our most popular fruit pie. It's sweet, tart, and brimming with blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and cherries. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Vegan Chocolate Honeycomb Ice Cream!
Vegan Apple Jelly Jar
Dutch Apple pie is one of the most nostalgic pies. Tart granny smith apples are baked in sweet cinnamon sugar, topped with the crunch of our Vegan crumble.
Vegan Peach Strawberry
Vegan Cherry Oatmeal Jelly Jar

Gluten Free Pies
GF Pumpkin Praline Jelly Jar
Sept-Nov This popular fall flavor starts with creamy, lightly spiced pumpkin filling in GF crust. Then gets a decadent ILP upgrade with a sweet cream cheese center and salty-sweet pecan praline crumble.
GF Butter Pecan Jelly Jar
Crunchy pecans and extra-buttery brown sugar custard make this a fall classic. The GF crust and dollop of salty-sweet pecan cream cheese make it an irresistible ILP creation. Another reason why we love fall!
GF Key Lime Jelly Jar
You know this one: classic key lime filling, Gluten Free crust, and a must-have mound of fresh whipped cream. Tart, creamy and here year-round thanks to customer pleas.
GF Mixed Berry Jelly Jar
Meet our most popular fruit pie. It's sweet, tart, and brimming with blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and cherries. Baked in our traditional crust and topped with shortbread crumble. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Triple Berry Cream Cheese Ice Cream!
GF Peach Strawberry
Gluten Free Pumpkin Praline
Gluten Free Cherry Oatmeal Jelly Jar

I Like Pie Digital Gift Cards
Gift Card 1
Please specify "in-store pick-up" as your delivery method when checking out.
Gift Card 3
Please specify "in-store pick-up" as your delivery method when checking out.
Gift Card 2
Please specify "in-store pick-up" as your delivery method when checking out.

Beverages
Hot Coffee
Hot coffee - choice of coffee blend
Hot Cocoa
Iced Tea
Iced Coffee
Iced coffee - choice of coffee blend
Diet Coke
IBC Root Beer
Hot Tea
San Pellegrino
Water Bottle
Cold Brew Coffee
Milk
Topo Chico
Coke (Bottle)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: ubereats
+27 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+26 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

The CUTEST little pie shop in Old Town! I love their individual pies. They're perfectly packaged with so much flavor.

They have so many options. From savory to vegan friendly. My favorites are the classics: key lime, apple and chocolate.

They are a bit pricey, but you are paying for quality ingredients. 3 pies for around $26.

I usually just pick up a couple when I'm running errands, but they'd be a great party...
October 2024
Cute pie shop that sells delicious mini pies. All pies are mini pies and a few hand pies. So don't come here expecting a whole pie or regular pie slice. Nice cafe setting that also serves coffee and lattes. I got the Salted Caramel Banana which was delicious. Next time I'll try their Pice Cream which is bits of a berry pie mixed with vanilla ice cream.
October 2024
I might cry… I just had pie. It’s hard you see, to find crust free… of gluten but still light, crispy. But look no more, for you have scored. They’ve mastered it, like, oh my lord… Let all your doubts slip away and die. Now taste anything here and shout “I LIKE PIE”

Key lime was my fave.
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sato Ramen House - 34 S Raymond Ave
Ramen, Japanese Curry, Noodles, Vegan, Vegetarian
Lucky Baldwins Pub - 17 S Raymond Ave
Bar, British, Pubs, Fish & Chips, Pet Friendly
Copa Vida - 70 S Raymond Ave
Coffee Shops, American, Coffee & Tea, Cafe, Coffee

I Like Pie Bakeshop

38 S Raymond Ave, Pasadena, CA 91105
(626) 345-5959