Brown Butter Cookie Company

801 12th St, Paso Robles
(805) 239-5894

Recent Reviews

Heather Stone

These taste like “astronaut food” cookie dough you might get at a space museum. The flavor is sort of there, but they’re so dry and crumbly and light, almost freeze-dried tasting. Also they aren’t cheap for small, not very good, cookies. I could see getting really into this bizarre texture because it is so different, but unfortunately I think the average person who’s looking for a cookie is going to be disappointed here.

Tomo

Creamy cookies. Delicious.

Ted Fletcher

A great local spot. I've had numerous of the smaller cookies.

M. S.

Two stars because one flavor of cookies was decent. No stars for the store or customer service last night. The store owner or employee seemed very confused and reluctant to sell us cookies. She seemed as if she was being held at gunpoint having to nervously put money in a bag at the bank. Is she not used to people walking up to her "stand" (not store because she's blocking off the whole thing) and offering her money for her goods? We are two very normal looking people but we do happen to be Hispanic so maybe that was it? Keep your salty dusty cookies lady. We won't be back.

Greg Kaganyuk

Melt in your mouth delicious-ness!

Laura Mavis

Love it way to much

Lorraine Keeland

If you are ever in Paso Robles or Cayucos Beach, stop in for these ? cookies. We always stop in to buy many cookies ? for friends & family.

Supriya

The cookies are great - not the regular cookie but sort of shortbread but denser, we loved them! The almond flavor is great. The place and the staff could be a bit more welcoming however.

Christian V Lawrence

The cookies are amazing ?

E. Y. Hao

Excellent cookies!! They are to die for. However, the main (original) store in Cayucos has more selections to choose from.

Rob Haworth

Been here a few times in the past, small pricy ? cookies with different flavors. Will be nice when sampling is allowed again.

Anastasiya Paukova

Tasty cookies. Covid-safe service! Kids friendly!

Spencer Quan

Cookies: 2/5I got three different flavors that all came in packs of 3. So the rating is consistent with all three versions. They all had a crumbly texture...one that basically disintegrates in your mouth as it soaks up your saliva. The flavors were fairly subtle so while you can taste the distinct flavor of each flavor it wasn’t much of an impact.

Danika Nutile

These cookies are my favorite. They have never failed to disappoint me. Every single flavor is so amazing and the cookie delicate and delicious. Every single time I walk in, friendly, cheerful employees offer me a sample of their original brown butter cookie, or any cookie I would like to try before purchasing. This place is a must try!

Spencer Q

Cookies: 2/5I got three different flavors that all came in packs of 3. So the rating is consistent with all three versions. They all had a crumbly texture...one that basically disintegrates in your mouth as it soaks up your saliva. The flavors were fairly subtle so while you can taste the distinct flavor of each flavor it wasn’t much of an impact.

Load More