5th Ave New York Pizza

954 Fifth Ave, San Diego
(619) 236-9006

Recent Reviews

Jekaterina Novikova

Good pizza!!!! I love their dough and sauce with the best crust there is. I moved to the area fairly new this is by far the best tasting pizza i tried in dt.

Dmitrijs Fedorenko

My favorite pizza in downtown. Best spot to eat after the club. The personnel is super friendly.

Chris Topher

Yeah I agree with alot of these poor reviews. Pizza was pretty sub par. Sorry

Jean PBR

Just a great place overall to eat an authentic good pizza 100/10

Rasheeda Sarguro

I ordered the vegetarian pizza and a mushroom lasagna. The pizza was too crunchy and tasted over baked.The sauce in the lasagna and pizza tasted the same, like bland tomatoey sauce from a jar. You couldn’t taste anything but tomato in the lasagna. I was so surprised because it was so highly rated, but it was just so bad.Definitely wouldn’t order from this place again

Jullie G.

Most HORRIBLE pizza place EVER. IT IS NOT NY style pizza. And the delivery SUCKS. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. SAVE YOUR $$. pizza sauce is overwhelming with basil... like what are you trying to hide with all that basil?? Chewing the crust of ONE slice gave me a headache. NOT TO MENTION... ordered pizza at 5pm... didnt find it placed in front of our door till 7pm. No door bell rung. O wait... AND ordered 2 pizzas, and got only 1. Wow.... what a HORRIBLE experience.

Willie Irwin

A top place for delicious pizza. Food was so delish. The staff was very welcoming and observant. This place has a good design.

Shay Jones

I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was mediocre and hard as a rock. The crust was so hard that it was hard to chew it. It’s not NY style, it taste like frozen oven-baked pizza. I would never order again

Shalese J.

I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was mediocre and hard as a rock. The crust was so hard that it was hard to chew it. It's not NY style, it taste like frozen oven-baked pizza. I would never order again

Hazel Torres

Went in last night and the lady in the front was super rude. Didn’t answer my questions. She basically didn’t want to serve us. The pizza was very chewy I wouldn’t recommend it.

Kambri P.

So sweet and accommodating when others are not during Covid. Great food and adorable location and fabulous customer service

Dan B.

Great, friendly service! Accommodated to all our wants & the pizza was so yummy- nice thin new york style!

Brenda M.

This is definitely not NY pizza!! It does have a thin crispy crust but that is it!! I liked the cheese and tomato sauce but the crust is poor quality. Taste kinda like the Celeste frozen pizza crust. It is obvious that they do not use good ingredients for the crust. Also the neighborhood is seedy- lots of bums!

Marie F.

If you like a nice crispy crunch to your pizza like I do you'll love the crust! I got a veggie pizza and it was a nice balanced amount of cheese and veggies. Would order again!

Skyler Puckett

The pizza was great my spouse and I tried pizza by the slice places all over the city during our week vacation there and this place is by far #1 you have to give a try. It's New York style and served with a smile!! The buffalo chicken was my favorite and the spouse like the basic cheese pizza!! Good food, nice service. Awesome choice for lunch with a beer or drink. Great happy hour & reasonable prices.

Load More