5th Ave New York Pizza

954 Fifth Ave, San Diego
(619) 236-9006

Recent Reviews

Josie R.

Looks like frozen pizza. Tastes like a frozen pizza you make at home. Pizza looks like it's been sitting. It was yuck. No bathrooms for customers, if you want water they sell you a Costco water bottle for $2. Just ridiculous.

Eric W.

Just yuck. Worse than Dominos. Even late at night and drunk it didn't hit the spot.Come on guys. You're at fifth and broadway. You can't fail here, just make a decent pizza.

John W.

This pizza insulted me and my friends on a very special occasion. The cheese was wanting, the dough was leatherous; tanned like an ox's hide. The bell peppers were raw and the pie arrived colder than the loneliest heart. I would not recommend it to a friend or an enemy. How could something be dry and greasy at the same time?! Long story short,this pizza sucked... and I regret to inform you - our night is f****** It takes a lot of courage to deliver this to people.

Jean Cotis

Medium pizza wasn't fresh with them adding cheese to old pizza to appear fresh; just shameful. Also ordered chicken wings which tasted off because it was also reheated. It all ended in the trash: a $30 waste.

Michael Garwoood

Not the best quality,But good ol reliable pizza. Inexpensive. Best of all, sales tax Figured Into the price, HEH!

shahad namnqani

I picked up the Pizza so so so Cold Can’t even Bite It ?! Its not fresh i think they just Put it in the oven and give to us ? , Also the Garlic bread too cold . Unfortunately Disappointed we are soo mad to this restaurant and service ??

Eric

Really good fast pizza . Thin crust, flavorful sauce , sufficient cheese levels, and fast service. A great restaurant.very crispy, very perfect texture.

Gabrielle Vergara

This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had here in San Diego. I ordered one supreme slice and a Cesar salad. As the slice was heating up in the oven, the cashier began making my salad. At first glance I realized he wasn’t wearing gloves and then I realized, he didn’t even wash his hands and was handling everything on my salad. I was disgusted and wanted to call him out but honestly I was so hungry, I had no energy. I took my overpriced slice and salad and left. Ate the pizza slice in my car, had zero flavor, crust was way too hard, and I didn’t even touch my salad. I plan on rinsing the entire salad before I eat it today. Assuming that it is still good to eat. Honestly, Little Cesar’s is better than this place. This is the first and last time I come here.

Armando Urzua

They sent me the wrong pizza and refused to send me the correct pizza. I ordered the works and they sent me a cheese pizza and it was cold. Worst experience I have ever had with a pizza place. I will not be coming back ever again. When I called to get this resolved they were very rude and hung up on me. If you want horrible customer service this is the place for you.This was an Uber Eats order and both Uber eats and the pizza place refused to take accountability to the mistakes made on both ends. Pizzeria for not making the correct pizza and Uber eats for not checking pizza before dropping it off to me. I feel like I was robbed by both Uber eats and pizza place

Jasmine Henson

Terrible service. Sent us the wrong pizza with our name on it and blamed it on Uber eats.

Marilyn R.

Terrible pizza terrible people. Pizza arrived cold and it was also the wrong pizza. When we called they didn't let us talk. Very rude and refused to fix our order that THEY messed up. We ordered "the works" and we received a cheese pizza. THEY wrote our name on the box and said it was not their fault the order was wrong then hung up on us. Absolute worst experience I've had in San Diego. Very unfortunate

Kassandra rose Flaherty

Favorite spot after a night out! They’re super nice and the pizza is DELISH!!!☺️

Chris K.

Frozen pizza is better. Plus $5 a slice, big mistake walking in here, never again. Sorry, the lady behind the counter was nice, but the product is pretty average at best.

Donna G.

I'm only giving this a little star because they are open late till 3 in the morning. I got my pizza through Uber eats and when I received it the crust was really hard and it was a thin pizza . Not worth it but if you're coming home late from partying on a Saturday night it was my only option to select since I wasn't going to drive

Oby Oby

Fresh and fast pizza! Very friendly and helpful workers. Location is nice so close to everywhere. You can find fresh pizza anytime. If you don't eat carbs, there are salad options. Thank you for your service ❤️

Load More