Eaton Pizza & Subs

123 1st St, Eaton
(970) 454-1068

Recent Reviews

Tessa Swanner

I live in Gill, so it's hard to get anywhere to deliver to my home, I called ahead to see, and they were up front about it taking a while to get here, I said thanks but I may try to find another place, then the owner called me back and after I explained my situation he offered to personally deliver our pizza! He made it in less time than was originally expected, and the guy who answered was so kind! Everything's home made, including pizza dough, they chop up their veggies same day, their house ranch is A1, we'll definitely be returning customers from now on. I wasn't able to get a pic of my pizza before we devoured into it ?Thanks Jim! Your pizza is definitely better than dominos ???

Burnie Fellars

I had a pizza and 3 subs over the course of 3days. I have to aSay that the pizza was the best I've had in over 10 years. The Italian sausage subs are amazing. I will be eating here alot in the next few months.

Cody Ayd

I appreciate Jim for giving me great customer service and the pizza here is very good! Definitely coming back

Jolene W

Good pizza sandwich! Ordered for delivery at the hotel and received very timely.

C Dub

Reliable quality! They are one of the few places we can count on around here.Food: 5/5

Valerie Elliott

Spent $30 bucks and didn’t even eat it. The pizza was terrible and the cinnamon sticks were even worse. Waste of $$ and didn’t eat it. Won’t ever go back.

Beth S

Stopped for pizza today. Delicious!! Loved the crust!

Scot Randolph

Small town gem! Pizza is great! Have some lemon Ice Cream you will not regret it! Fair pricing to say the least! If your driving by stop and have a slice... Ask for FABIO ??

marquis fraker

Fast delivery, friendly owner and amazing pizza! Will definitely keep supporting this local business!

The A's

Pizza, subs and cheese bread were great and the lemon ice cream was unique and delicious! Very friendly and helpful staff. Will be back!


Pizza was good. Folks working there were neither friendly or unfriendly. Overall a so so dining time. Also, beverages were bottle and Pepsi.

Analise Alarid

Pizza was delicious and the staff was really nice. So patient with our big softball group

Elijah Johnsen

Pizzas good just a little bit expensive but the atmosphere is really cool and very enjoyable.

Matthew James

Ok #1 I read reviews and after reading how somebody else got a messed up taco pizza and owner commented it would not happen again. WELL HE WAS WRONG! Let's just say worse taco pizza I every ate. The house salad had more flavor! It had cheese a few crumbs of hamburger meat maybe half a dozen pieces of tomato. No tortilla chips no taco sauce and a bunch of lettuce. BLAND! I had them add jalapeños to it or I would not have been able to even choke it down.

Ken Burns

Commitment to quality and service. Top notch.

Load More