I got bbq wings and pizza … wings were overcooked so bad I couldn’t eat them and pizza was just horrible all around please don’t waste your money I’m reading these other comments and there is no way these are real reviews… that or they have new owners because I’d never eat here again if you paid
Food: 1
Kemecia Arthur
Use to order here a long time ago, and ordered recently not knowing it was under new management. Felt for a slice of pizza, but since they didn't have slices, I brought a small pizza. The second time I requested it a certain way and he delivered. I ate the entire box, you would think I was eating for 2, guest my appetite is back. The sauce did not burn my chest at all and I ate it late at night. I would recommend ordering from here.
Carrie Dodge
Worst people ever to deal with. Ordered a grinder with extra meat and had half the bread covered. They wouldn't fix anything. The guy was completely rude and saying well what do you want me to do about when I called to ask to fix it. Just plain stealing from customers.
Service: 1
Marion R
Pizza one of my favorites would love if they had a gluten free option.
Anthony C.
Just easy going and I love their pizza. Highly recommend for trying if you're in the area.
Igor Khokhlov
Very tasty pizza!I already tried seafood pizza.Also I ordered a special pizza but by mistake I was given a cheese pizza. After a call they apologized and made me the one I ordered. What can I say, the cheese pizza was very good as well as the special pizza.Now my plan is to try all other pizzas from this pizzeria.I would definitely recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Barnett
It's a very personal feeling of welcome when you enter the establishment. They cook the food towards the customers taste. Usually other pizza places the crust is difficult to chew, the pizza at pizza choice you can eat the crust also, The prices are affordable, and the pizza is not greasy or dry, try it you'll love. Mike B.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Shivani Reddy
We just placed an order today from pizza choice The menu looks very nice so figure out to try it out hands-down pizza choice have the best food it was so hot and delicious thank you pizza choice Definitely have our business
Lebron Marie
Definitely the best Buffalo Chicken pizza I’ve tried around!!!!!
michael carey
Update: went back a day later to order dinner and once again exceeded my expectations. Great food and I'm a picky one. If you haven't checked it out you need to!Kid-friendliness: They are always extremely nice to my little one and that makes me appreciate the business even more
I really love pizza but definitely not this place.
Anthony D.
Pizza Choice, it is my favorite place in New haven. I know sally's, pepe's, modern get all the attention but the new ownership at pizza Choice is incredible. I live very close so I go there like three times a week and it's always the same two guys, very respectful everything is made to order and they make sure you are satisfied... I've ordered just about everything possible from the menu and have been happy every single time. They also make thin crust pizza if you want, it's not your normal neighborhood little pizza place, it's really really good. And I'm Italian so I am very fussy, even their sauce on the subs are delicious. Definitely worth taking a shot on.
Colby
Best pizza around that area, for sure. I would stop by there on my home from work when I lived in that area. The owner was very personable and funny!
I got bbq wings and pizza … wings were overcooked so bad I couldn’t eat them and pizza was just horrible all around please don’t waste your money I’m reading these other comments and there is no way these are real reviews… that or they have new owners because I’d never eat here again if you paid
Food: 1
Use to order here a long time ago, and ordered recently not knowing it was under new management. Felt for a slice of pizza, but since they didn't have slices, I brought a small pizza. The second time I requested it a certain way and he delivered. I ate the entire box, you would think I was eating for 2, guest my appetite is back. The sauce did not burn my chest at all and I ate it late at night. I would recommend ordering from here.
Worst people ever to deal with. Ordered a grinder with extra meat and had half the bread covered. They wouldn't fix anything. The guy was completely rude and saying well what do you want me to do about when I called to ask to fix it. Just plain stealing from customers.
Service: 1
Pizza one of my favorites would love if they had a gluten free option.
Just easy going and I love their pizza. Highly recommend for trying if you're in the area.
Very tasty pizza!I already tried seafood pizza.Also I ordered a special pizza but by mistake I was given a cheese pizza. After a call they apologized and made me the one I ordered. What can I say, the cheese pizza was very good as well as the special pizza.Now my plan is to try all other pizzas from this pizzeria.I would definitely recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a very personal feeling of welcome when you enter the establishment. They cook the food towards the customers taste. Usually other pizza places the crust is difficult to chew, the pizza at pizza choice you can eat the crust also, The prices are affordable, and the pizza is not greasy or dry, try it you'll love. Mike B.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
We just placed an order today from pizza choice The menu looks very nice so figure out to try it out hands-down pizza choice have the best food it was so hot and delicious thank you pizza choice Definitely have our business
Definitely the best Buffalo Chicken pizza I’ve tried around!!!!!
Update: went back a day later to order dinner and once again exceeded my expectations. Great food and I'm a picky one. If you haven't checked it out you need to!Kid-friendliness: They are always extremely nice to my little one and that makes me appreciate the business even more
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food, great owners and staff.
I really love pizza but definitely not this place.
Pizza Choice, it is my favorite place in New haven. I know sally's, pepe's, modern get all the attention but the new ownership at pizza Choice is incredible. I live very close so I go there like three times a week and it's always the same two guys, very respectful everything is made to order and they make sure you are satisfied... I've ordered just about everything possible from the menu and have been happy every single time. They also make thin crust pizza if you want, it's not your normal neighborhood little pizza place, it's really really good. And I'm Italian so I am very fussy, even their sauce on the subs are delicious. Definitely worth taking a shot on.
Best pizza around that area, for sure. I would stop by there on my home from work when I lived in that area. The owner was very personable and funny!
Love it great pizza