Fratelli's Italian Restaurant

248 New Haven Ave, Milford
(203) 877-1170

Recent Reviews

April khanthaphixay

Just left Fratelli’s, had a great night out with my husband. Food and service was amazing. It takes a lot for me to write a negative review but the response I received tonight from the manager on duty left a bad taste in my mouth.The waiter and attending staff was awesome and deserved the generous tip I left but this manager will unfortunately have to be responsible for this one star. You know what you did.

Thomas Langrieger

Simply amazing food,service,price and great family atmosphere. I’ve there with my bride several times and never once been disappointed. Top notch and they always get 4 thumbs up from us !!!


Yesterday was our sons baptism and we decided to hold a lunch at Fratellis after church. It was a decent size party of almost 50 people. The service they provided was beyond what I expected. It’s hard to find a business these days that will cater, and care about the needs of their customers and Fratellis did just that. Today was one of the most special days of our lives, and what the people at Fratellis did for us, was a big reason why. Not a single complaint about the food or service from any one of our guests. This is only my second time there. (First time was to have lunch and pay our deposit for the room) I will continue to recommend anyone to go there, and will go there again myself any chance I get. Thank you guys so much for the awesome job. We really appreciate it.

Jenna Van Hise

Crab cakes were bread cakes. Same with stuffed mushrooms. Eggplant rollatini was terrible and the sauce tasted like Prego. $16 martinis for a patio on Rt 162 smelling car fumes. The service was good by the bussers, that’s about it. They used to be great. Not sure what happened?

John Firimonte

This family owned restaurant reminds me of Italian Restaurants from yesterday. The food was fresh, the pasta was done to perfection. I had hot antipasto and seafood fra diavlo platter with a fresh crisp salad. I haven't enjoyed Italian food like this in years. The service was excellent. The only small beef I have is I wish they keep the parmesancheese on the table. Cant wait to go back again.

Chris D.

Soup appetizers were served in a reasonable time. Entrees were NOT. My guest's dish was cold. Waiter promised entrees would be coming out right away. That did not happen until 30 minutes later.

Lee M.

Got the shrimp and scallop a la vodka tonight, the sauce was tasteless and it came with 2 scallops and 2 shrimp... 27 dollars for 2 of each. Crazy. High price point and no flavor.

Alec A.

Amazing service, drinks, and food. Got the hot antipasto as an app and wow. I got the Tour de Italy as my entree and it went perfect with a glass of red.

Annie S.

My boyfriend and I checked out this place tonight for our anniversary & we totally loved it! Great environment, staff and amazingly scrumptious food. Plenty of parking. Safe area. We ordered appetizers, entrees and an alcoholic beverage each and desert! Will definitely come back! Bathroom was clean and staff was so friendly & accommodating! percent recommend it to everyone I know!

N R.

Very short and easy review. High prices and very underwhelming food! Below average Italian food especially compared to other Italian restaurants in CT. Milford doesn't have a great food scene, so maybe people in area enjoy it. Appetizers were okay, everything else was terrible and overcooked. Everyone at table food was over cooked. Asked for medium rare and provided medium well. Maybe should have tried pasta dish, but I assume would be the same. I would t return unless a group wanted to.

Dan Drago

Overpriced dinner was way below expectations. Started with a dirty wine glass, Veal Florentine was bland at best, way too much egg batter and very little veal. Our server didn't ask us how the meal was, maybe he already knew. The atmosphere is pretty good but the meal and service were disappointing. Will not return.

Nancy G.

From start to finish everything was perfect. Reservations were made for six we were seated promptly the way they space out the serving of food and drinks is that a nice piece so that you don't feel rushed. Tables are spaced out enough so that you don't feel like you are sitting on top of people. Food appetizers and drinks for oil delicious. Our waiter was fantastic not one complaint. This has been my fourth time going to them over three years and it is always perfect

Rachel M.

Best Italian food in CT!! Service and food are always incredible. My go to special occasion spot but I definitely don't need an excuse to come here.

Catherine R.

Upon entering we stood and waited to be seated while servers stared and walked around. Finally a hosts seats us and there was just an overwhelming smell like a porta potty. After a while you get used to it. Food was way overpriced for what was provided and DO NOT get any seafood. The veal made my friend sick and have stomach issues next day and I had similar problems from the shrimp. The staff is quick to refill water and box your plate but it just wasn’t worth $100+. Save yourself and go somewhere else.

Jen G.

My bf and I looove this place...ambiance so relaxing..very is phenomenal..service on point..we love the waiter, Harrison.. hes great! This is one spot I always want to go to!

Load More