Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Tuscan Grill

475 New Haven Ave, Milford
(203) 877-1370

Recent Reviews

John Avellani

I called looking for a sit down lower for my son-in-law. I left a message and they were very prompt getting back to me. They have a large selection of mowers and appliances I even see motor scooters once in a Whit wants an oil as I drive by.

Patricia DeLora Podkul

We loved this restaurant! From apps to dessert everything was perfect! Great atmosphere and lovely staff. We will be back!

Lauren DeBenedictis

Terrible Terrible service. Actually the worst i have ever encountered. Over two hours for our meal , only for them to tell me they had no steak. Over two hours for a large pizza. It’s unfortunate because the food is actually very good. So disappointed. Will never go back!!!

Kathi Glazier Ducharme

Wow. We just LOVE everything about this restaurant. The food was perfectly prepared. The best part of the evening had to be the impeccable service from Tony, the most attentive waiter we have ever had. Great great night out. We will be making it a regular weekly stop.

Richie Morissette

Absolutely horrible!!! Don’t bother making a reservation because they will just give your reservation to another party. Me and my party show up and they tell us they gave our reservation to another party.. and they looked like they didn’t even care... so definitely don’t recommend

Donna Brainard

A soft opening. No one greeted us to seat us.Bread was underbaked and bottom burned. Menus were printed missing some food items. My daughter's had food ours didn't. Not very organized. Bus boy was doing waiters work and doing it better than waiter. Had pizza and chicken parm. Nothing special. I hope they get it together because I like to see private instead of chains.

Dylan Seele

My food took an additional hour after the 40 minute call ahead. My pasta was missing and there was just chicken in the container. No bread or anything else in the bag. Nobody was wearing masks and the two boys at the counter were super rude and literally just standing around on their phones when there was a whole lobby of people waiting to be helped. The man at the bar was very nice though and offered us a drink. However, I see in these reviews that takeout is a common problem.

Donna Patterson

We had such a great time tonight. Paula Patinella was singing, which was our main draw but the food was delicious and the server TONY made it an enjoyable evening. Made a lot of new friends!! GREAT EVENING!

Lauren M.

horrible they delivered my food to the wrong house and then made me go pick it up once the realized it was the wrong adress or they were canceling my order. should have gotten a discount for this. very upset.

Lisa Pohl

We had a fabulous night, the food was delicious the bartender Joe was very entertaining, made great martini, live entertainment in the dining room. Its a must enjoy, you won't be disappointed.

Fred Fallanca

great food and entettainment.

Robert Forchetti

Our first time here and everything could not have been better. The food was amazing, from the cold seafood salad to the linguini and white clam sauce to the chocolate mousse cake. Frenchi, our waiter was very attentive and made an excellent wine selection for us. My family thoroughly enjoyed our experience here. We will be back soon.

Don C.

Love this place. The food is excellent & consistent. Bartender, Joe - is friendly and mixes up a nice cocktail. The host Peter is a great Guy definitely 1 of a kind. Been a 1/2 dozen times and have NEVER had a bad meal or poor service. Wood fired pizza is excellent. I'll be returning soon.

Debra Loverci

I had no idea they changed owners and I am upset that it was not announced, because if it was, than I would have expected things to be “different”.I ordered bread and Chicken Parm for a last minute get together. I do not want to get into every detail about what went wrong, But I will say that the chicken parm did not look or taste the same and the bread was still doughy inside when I went to serve it.I called to complain, and no one called me back. I then called the next day, and a young person (Who I believe is the owners son), of whom I expressed my disappointments to, seemed to get upset and said “look mam, we were really busy last night, so when u come back in we will give you a free bread or something!”I placed my order two days in advanced. I was going to ask to speak to someone in charge, but I will not be going back, so it does not matter....

sheri burghart

My Eggplant Parm was sooooo delicious. The best I have ever had. Great service with a lovely atmosphere. Will be back with friends

Load More

Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Tuscan Grill

475 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT 06460
(203) 877-1370