Mario's Pizzeria

123 Cherry St #2, Naugatuck
(203) 723-5850

Recent Reviews

leonard hilado

Ordered a large bacon and onion.....did not disappoint it was very good.toppings were evenly placed perfectly cooked and not burnt....would consider ordering from here again .

Matthew Bolduc

This is the only place I get pizza from. I have a very unsophisticated palate so that doesn't mean much, but other nearby places don't compare.

W Monsky

Good pizza but I miss the days when they used to give you a free soda if you bought a lot of stuff.

Richard Jeannin

I have to say Mario's had been my family go to place for a long time but I'm going to have to rethink this. Last night I had one of the worst take out experiences, it started with the time they gave us staying 40 to 45 minutes. I arrived around the 40 minute mark and waited another 20 minutes and still hasn't received my order. After asking how much longer and getting the standard in sorry we're very busy tonight a couple of times I finally told them to give my order away and started to drive away. I was spotted by an employee who said the pizza had just come out of the oven and they were waiting on my wings. Well come to find out this was a lie. They may have been waiting on the wings as they were nice and warm, the pizza had clearly been sitting on top of the oven for quite some time as it has substantially cooled off. Over all really disappointed. Only reason not a 1 star was the wind tasted good.

Garrett Maniscalco

Their food is always good I'm never disappointed. They have great Customer service. I would definitely recommend Eating there.

Jae workout

Smallest pizza ? shop that packs a big punch. Pizza and food is good and the staff is wonderful young talent. Don't miss out on some of the best!!!

Dena Zegzdryn

Ordered Buffalo Chicken pizza and very burnt on the bottom. Ordered a pizza with sausage, onions and mushrooms. Onions were carmelized and the pizza was complete mush. The sauce was tasteless. Gross.


I love Mario's! I've been going here since they opened. I am gluten intolerant and love that I can get any of the delicious specialty pizzas on a gluten free crust! Service is always friendly, fast, fresh & hot! They are pick-up but do deliver through Doordash. They have a good size menu with pasta dishes, grinders, salads and more. They offer special pizza deals as well!

Tasha S

Some of the food that I ordered was good one of the thing that I ordered was wrong. I ordered online went to pick it up after 25 minutes, I had to wait for another 25 minutes. It turned out he started cooking the food when I got there. Overall, don't waste your time order online.

Konstantin Posehn

Firanca Pizza/RedWhole Ingredients: Mushrooms, Onions, Artichokes Hearts, Straight Mozzarella Cheese, Sliced Fresh Mozzarella,Added Ingredients: Fresh Garlic, Salami, Marinara Sauce, Black OlivesYammy!!!

Hank R.

I'm sad to report that this place doesn't taste that good after trying several times. I've given ample chances at going back but none any better than the first time which was also dismal . It's bare bones basic so so pizza. The meatball parm isn't that good either. The service upon picking up is always pleasant and upbeat but it ends there. The food unfortunately doesn't measure up to the nice demeanor that you receive. Smaller right parking lot. Sorry to rain on those who feel this is very good in their standards. It is ok for a last minute filler if that's all that's available to you. Just giving our views on the handful of times we've tried them. You can only give a business so many chances when you finally decide it's not too your liking no matter what they do to try to make it better.


I have tried many things on their menu and just love the italian grinder or the wrap. Try it with hot peppers.


Easily one of the best pizza places in the area. The pizza is always perfect, the BBQ wings are a favorite every time we order, and they even have some really good gluten free options.

Pattyanne Langston

Owner always greets you when you come in and thanks you when you leave. Pizza, calzones, Stromboli, salads you name they got it and its so delicious!!!Highly recommend their salad pizza!!!

nicole cerretani

Best pizza & garlic knots in town, worth the drive to pick up.

Load More