Another top 5 pizza in my life. Made it a point to stop here on my trip and it did not disappoint. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
DB
I have to say after trying all the New Haven pizza places this was my favorite. Not my style pizza (i don’t get the hype).Is it worth trying? YesWorth a long wait in line? NoValue? No, way over priced out
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
Allison Bailey
Drove 3 hours down from New Hampshire just to get pizza. Met a friend for lunch and drove home. Original tomato pie and one with mozzarella, totally worth the drive!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam R
Pepe's is dialed-in and on-point! Not much to say here; the pics should suffice. Everything fresh, delicious; service was great too. Overall 5-star experience,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Benoit
Best pizza in the area hands down!Crispy and fluffy. Tasty but not greasy. Honestly I think they are all great but my fav is large cheese. And the salad is fresh, green, and dressing is delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Salatto
What is wrong with these other reviewers? LOL!!! They don’t know what real Connecticut pizza is and is supposed to be. It’s not BURNED. It’s a coal fired oven and it’s supposed to look burned, but it isn’t. Come to Wisconsin and eat out pizza and then try to complain about Pepe’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Martini
All the way from Arizona! This was an amazing experience. Staff was friendly and the pizza is amazing!Kid-friendliness: TotallyWheelchair accessibility: Uws they do
Ordered online for pick-up. One hour wait for the order to be ready due to crowd but I ordered at the most populated time so be mindful of that. Pizza was good but not amazing as sauce lacked taste of basil and oregano. Crust though was delicious and cooked perfectly. Pricey.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fresh Tomato Pie
Sarah Lu
Solid pizza place. The waitress recommend the PERFECT pizza portions for our hungry group of 10 people. The pizzas were all delicious—highly recommend the sausage ricotta pizza. Price came out to be about 13 dollars per person including TIP which is honestly a really good deal. Everyone left feeling very full and happy :))
Danielle Livorsi
Please stop giving these overrated pizza places 5 star reviews. This is the worst pizza around. Burnt crust every time. The cheese doesn't even stay on the dough. I travel for good pizza, and this place is definitely not one of them.
My pizza was overcooked and burnt. The place is so crowded that they can’t take care of all customers. Long wait time, which is frustrating. Not recommended.
Food: 2
Cassandra G.
Serving was kinda rude. Clearly did not wanna be there. Pepe's has really gone down in quality since they started franchising.
David Windmueller
Eh - I'm disappointed that this was actually served. It is a burnt pie. We aren't talking burnt crust bubbles, rather burnt cheese. I think they have gotten lax on quality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Hanieh Shabanian
Look at the photo of my pizza! Its almost burned, you cannot even get a bite out of it. So disappointing. Look at the oil all over it, is this a high quality pizza?! Waste of money and time. Be honest with your reviews to help others, dont understand the high rate of this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jordan Perry
I’m on an iPhone 13 latest iOS. I’m on there website and switch location to New Haven. It kept it on Waterbury and placed my order there. Now I’m sitting here for 25-30 minutes waiting for a pizza when I should be leaving. I just tried different times going and switching it to New Haven for it not to work. Staying at a hotel and my wife wants to go to the pool before it closes. It’s 8:30 now and the pool closes at 10 and it’s 30 min away. How are we not waking up the guy who sold you this website at home? Using this website constantly mentions different errors in the dialog box on the bottom that’s popping up.
Another top 5 pizza in my life. Made it a point to stop here on my trip and it did not disappoint. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I have to say after trying all the New Haven pizza places this was my favorite. Not my style pizza (i don’t get the hype).Is it worth trying? YesWorth a long wait in line? NoValue? No, way over priced out
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
Drove 3 hours down from New Hampshire just to get pizza. Met a friend for lunch and drove home. Original tomato pie and one with mozzarella, totally worth the drive!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pepe's is dialed-in and on-point! Not much to say here; the pics should suffice. Everything fresh, delicious; service was great too. Overall 5-star experience,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in the area hands down!Crispy and fluffy. Tasty but not greasy. Honestly I think they are all great but my fav is large cheese. And the salad is fresh, green, and dressing is delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
What is wrong with these other reviewers? LOL!!! They don’t know what real Connecticut pizza is and is supposed to be. It’s not BURNED. It’s a coal fired oven and it’s supposed to look burned, but it isn’t. Come to Wisconsin and eat out pizza and then try to complain about Pepe’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
All the way from Arizona! This was an amazing experience. Staff was friendly and the pizza is amazing!Kid-friendliness: TotallyWheelchair accessibility: Uws they do
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepe, Fresh Tomato Pie, Sausage
Ordered online for pick-up. One hour wait for the order to be ready due to crowd but I ordered at the most populated time so be mindful of that. Pizza was good but not amazing as sauce lacked taste of basil and oregano. Crust though was delicious and cooked perfectly. Pricey.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fresh Tomato Pie
Solid pizza place. The waitress recommend the PERFECT pizza portions for our hungry group of 10 people. The pizzas were all delicious—highly recommend the sausage ricotta pizza. Price came out to be about 13 dollars per person including TIP which is honestly a really good deal. Everyone left feeling very full and happy :))
Please stop giving these overrated pizza places 5 star reviews. This is the worst pizza around. Burnt crust every time. The cheese doesn't even stay on the dough. I travel for good pizza, and this place is definitely not one of them.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
My pizza was overcooked and burnt. The place is so crowded that they can’t take care of all customers. Long wait time, which is frustrating. Not recommended.
Food: 2
Serving was kinda rude. Clearly did not wanna be there. Pepe's has really gone down in quality since they started franchising.
Eh - I'm disappointed that this was actually served. It is a burnt pie. We aren't talking burnt crust bubbles, rather burnt cheese. I think they have gotten lax on quality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Look at the photo of my pizza! Its almost burned, you cannot even get a bite out of it. So disappointing. Look at the oil all over it, is this a high quality pizza?! Waste of money and time. Be honest with your reviews to help others, dont understand the high rate of this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I’m on an iPhone 13 latest iOS. I’m on there website and switch location to New Haven. It kept it on Waterbury and placed my order there. Now I’m sitting here for 25-30 minutes waiting for a pizza when I should be leaving. I just tried different times going and switching it to New Haven for it not to work. Staying at a hotel and my wife wants to go to the pool before it closes. It’s 8:30 now and the pool closes at 10 and it’s 30 min away. How are we not waking up the guy who sold you this website at home? Using this website constantly mentions different errors in the dialog box on the bottom that’s popping up.