Mamma Mia Pizza

67 Howe Ave, Shelton
(203) 513-8844

Recent Reviews

Sort by
melanie t

Not bad. Excellent crispy crust all the way through. Garlic knots are pretty good. Margherita pizza was decent, not saucy enough for me though. Fig & prosciutto pizza was also good, but the fig was more like a sauce rather than a spread & made a messy pie. My fave was the Calabrese pizza - unique & tasty with a little kick! Delivery through DoorDash was fast & the food was fresh/hot.

J Quiñones

I’ve driven by this place many times. Easy to miss since it’s where the road curves. But the pizza is delicious! You should give it a try. Friendly service too.

Justin Germak

Great pizza!! They always have slices too with great, delicious toppings. Always will come here.

Pseudo’s Toxicity

quite easily the best pizza ive had in a long time and could very easily give artans a run for there money

Zak Goldin

Ordered two of their specialty pies, both arrived without tomato sauce. Ordered the Hawaiian and Italian Farmer pizza, nowhere on the website or the Slice app does it show that these are 'white' pizzas that would arrive without sauce. The restaurant claims this is how they always make their pizza. Very disappointing, the pizza was tasty but this was not what we orderedEdit 2/12: Restaurant contacted me to apologize, they were very nice and are looking to update their listing. Their pizza could be very good, I just don't order 'white pizza'.

Davey Joe Minar

Delicious food, fast and friendly service. Best kept secret, best pizza around. People are beyond nice. Great lunch spot (tables inside), nice atmosphere. If you like pizza and you like people you will love Mamma Mia's.

Dorothy

Very, very good Italian pizza. I prefer greek pizza but this pizza is not dry and the sauce/cheese is delicious. Also the meatball grinder is as good as mine, LOL... Give it a try, you will not be disappointed!!! Owner very nice!

OmY bOoGiE dOwN bRoNx

This place is very fast and friendly. Pizza is very good crust is just rite ? and there zeppolis are excellent ??? reminds me of New York would recommend to anyone Great Job guys !!

Lianne Rasmussen

Placed my first order from here today through Slicelife.com. The pizza was very good as was the broccoli and an eggplant parm sub. Definitely give them a try!

Jose Aguilar

Lovely food and very friendly environment !Delicious pizza highly recommendedHad a chicken Frances and a mozzarella with basil pie !New owner tries to be accommodating even tough its a bit far for me its worth the drive for me!

Amber Reda

Great pizza and even better Greek salad.

Kerry A

Update: we ordered a pizza from here a second time and it was raining the guy asked me if we wanted anything else, I asked “you don’t have soup right?” He asked what kind do you want? And then made me some soup (not on their menu)… that is above and beyond customer service!!! Love this new local place!Original post: Ordered a meatball pizza tonight - fast delivery, hot and delicious pizza. Will definitely order from here again.

Panda Destroyer

Sucks that supremos isn’t the name anymore but there pizza was really good and was done in 15 minutes

Chris Garza

very good pizza. also got a buffalo chicken wrap that was huge. the owners are real nice , highly recommended.

Loading...