I just had the best pizza ever! And there cheese knots were awesome!!! They come with pepperoni and sauage and peppers and cheese and side of sauce and they were delicious!!! Our pizza was delivered very quickly and was very hot. I will definitely be ordering from here again. I want to try there boneless wings. Can't wait to order again!!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: John's Favorite Pizza
kevin garber
Ordered at 4:44 shows up at 6:15 orders mostly wrong orders barely warm. Garlic breadsticks had absolutely nothing on them pathetic. Pizza was barely warm boneless wings had the wrong sauce never got the spicy garlic never got the Buffalo sauce. What a joke and you people want $20 an hour? lmfao ain't worth $10.
Food: 2
Service: 1
John B Good
They did not have offer in their system that u sent me by e-mail. Had 2 leave without product.
Alok Nanda
Was a fan of PJ's pizzas back in India. Not disappointed here either.Pizzas - delish.Chicken nuggets - good. Especially with that dipping sauce.Bread sticks - not so much. Chewy and flavorless.But I will go back for their pizzas for sure.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
G Grow
ordered two large pizzas "WEEL DONE" got doughy bottom, had to put in toaster over. Asked corporate to compensate. silence... well, never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kyllie Gibson
I usually have a good experience with this location. But it has taken over an hour and I’m still currently waiting for my food to arrive. The app said they were here 30 minutes ago and I called 20 mins ago called again a few mins and got put on hold for almost 10 minutes to only be told they one have one driver and lost my order. This is completely unacceptable. Update: I got my food at it was completely cold and my food looked horrible. I got the pepperoni roll ups and they were inedible pictures below. I called back and the person who answered said they have been having Issues all day. He said they would remake the pepperoni roll ups and I called at 9:52 it’s currently 10:33 so 40 minutes and still waiting. If it doesn’t show up tonight I will call and ask for a refund for that item. This was a terrible experience and I don’t think I will be ordering from this location again
Food: 1
Service: 1
Max Yealey
Placed an order at the Middletown store at about the 2 hour mark called up to inquire about my order. The 1st girl put me on hold for 5 minutes and then hung up. Second call to the store I got a young man named Ethan who was absolutely no help couldn't tell me anything about the order. Asked for a manager. None available.We won't be using the middletown store ever again.If I could give zero stars I would.
Service: 1
Melody Khaing
My fifth grader was given a 40% off coupon by his teacher and he was excited and asked me to go to Papa Johns. I was told a medium pizza after using the coupon was $16.57 with a soda so the original price of a medium stuffed crust pepperoni pizza's original prize would have been >$30. The signed above said $15 she said that is the sale price and online was listed $13.99. I was given a non-itemized receipt which just said Batch ID 775 $16.57. Did not know what I was charged for if the coupon was taken off. When I talked to the lady, Christina??, she was rude. Even though she had no control over the price, she needs to ring up with items showing clearly and not quoting the wrong price. She should not tell me the prices that are different from the sign and internet. When I told her it cause the inconvenience of checking my bank account to get the refund in a few days, she was rude and told me that I caused the inconvenience for them instead of an apology for making up a receipt. Rude!!! There are a lot of pizza places on earth, you know...
Melody K.
My fifth grader was given a 40% off coupon by his teacher and he was excited and asked me to go to Papa Johns. I was told a medium pizza after using the coupon was $16.57 with a soda so the original price of a medium stuffed crust pepperoni pizza's original prize would have been more than $30. The signed above said $15 she said that is the sale price and online was listed $13.99. I was given a non-itemized receipt which just said Batch ID 775 $16.57. Did not know what I was charged for if the coupon was taken off. When I talked to the lady, Christina??, she was rude. Even though she had no control over the price, she needs to ring up with items showing clearly and not quoting the wrong price. She should not tell me the prices that are different from the sign and internet. When I told her it cause the inconvenience of checking my bank account to get the refund in a few days, she was rude and told me that I caused the inconvenience for them instead of an apology for making up a receipt. Incompetent and Rude!!! There are a lot of pizza places on earth. I don't need to deal with people like that. We went in happy and left unhappy. Papa Johns need to make sure people don't get rung up for a fake receipt and are told of the wrong prices. I am sure the company doesn't appreciate employees quoting the wrong prices.
Kavan Temple
40 dollars down the drain. Idk how hard it is to make a pizza but this location can never get it right. Then take more than an hour and a half to deliver a replacement and will not answer the phone.
I never ever do reviews ever!!! But I just downloaded the Yelp app to write a honest review!!! I placed a order at 5:12 and my 2 pizzas didn't get here till 6:44. I called to check on the status and a automated voice kept telling me it would be here in 10 minutes!! Once the pizza finally arrived I had to call back to let them know they put anchovies on my pizza which is disgusting!!! Even after the pizza was delivered the automated voice still said 10 minutes for my delivery which was a lie cause I already received it!! So No response, nobody picked up the phone, no manager to contact!!!! Call center kept trying to to transfer us but kept getting disconnected!!! Pizza was ice cold and I still can't get a hold of the store!! Papa Johns in Middletown Delaware should be Embarrassed to even have a business!!! I will be calling corporate and going to the store to complain!!! Absolutely horrible experience and they should be shutdown!!! They only take orders and you have now way of contacting them if your order is wrong or terrible!!!! Honest legit review!!!
Leon Jackson
The food was fine, but this location was playing loud rap music with explicit lyrics, including the use of the “N” word. Completely unprofessional, this area is not the hood. I’m glad I left my son waiting in the car.
Daniel Oluwatoba
Within 10 minutes, my delicious and tasty Pizza was ready! The lady who took my order was really pleasant. I thoroughly enjoyed this meal, will definitely stop by again soon...
Marcus Beevfe
Believe it or not the football pizza comes uncut!? On top of that the driver achieved some g force while driving here, so pizza looked very discombobulated. This caused us to use our hand like animals!??. Overall good experience but would not recommend.
Donald Lee
I’m tired of people making fun of me I’m tired of people give me dirty funny looks when I pick up orders for DoorDash making me feel uncomfortable I don’t care if people don’t like me but I’m not gonna be treated with disrespect and people being ignorant towards me I’m not gonna stand for that.
I just had the best pizza ever! And there cheese knots were awesome!!! They come with pepperoni and sauage and peppers and cheese and side of sauce and they were delicious!!! Our pizza was delivered very quickly and was very hot. I will definitely be ordering from here again. I want to try there boneless wings. Can't wait to order again!!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: John's Favorite Pizza
Ordered at 4:44 shows up at 6:15 orders mostly wrong orders barely warm. Garlic breadsticks had absolutely nothing on them pathetic. Pizza was barely warm boneless wings had the wrong sauce never got the spicy garlic never got the Buffalo sauce. What a joke and you people want $20 an hour? lmfao ain't worth $10.
Food: 2
Service: 1
They did not have offer in their system that u sent me by e-mail. Had 2 leave without product.
Was a fan of PJ's pizzas back in India. Not disappointed here either.Pizzas - delish.Chicken nuggets - good. Especially with that dipping sauce.Bread sticks - not so much. Chewy and flavorless.But I will go back for their pizzas for sure.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
ordered two large pizzas "WEEL DONE" got doughy bottom, had to put in toaster over. Asked corporate to compensate. silence... well, never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I usually have a good experience with this location. But it has taken over an hour and I’m still currently waiting for my food to arrive. The app said they were here 30 minutes ago and I called 20 mins ago called again a few mins and got put on hold for almost 10 minutes to only be told they one have one driver and lost my order. This is completely unacceptable. Update: I got my food at it was completely cold and my food looked horrible. I got the pepperoni roll ups and they were inedible pictures below. I called back and the person who answered said they have been having Issues all day. He said they would remake the pepperoni roll ups and I called at 9:52 it’s currently 10:33 so 40 minutes and still waiting. If it doesn’t show up tonight I will call and ask for a refund for that item. This was a terrible experience and I don’t think I will be ordering from this location again
Food: 1
Service: 1
Placed an order at the Middletown store at about the 2 hour mark called up to inquire about my order. The 1st girl put me on hold for 5 minutes and then hung up. Second call to the store I got a young man named Ethan who was absolutely no help couldn't tell me anything about the order. Asked for a manager. None available.We won't be using the middletown store ever again.If I could give zero stars I would.
Service: 1
My fifth grader was given a 40% off coupon by his teacher and he was excited and asked me to go to Papa Johns. I was told a medium pizza after using the coupon was $16.57 with a soda so the original price of a medium stuffed crust pepperoni pizza's original prize would have been >$30. The signed above said $15 she said that is the sale price and online was listed $13.99. I was given a non-itemized receipt which just said Batch ID 775 $16.57. Did not know what I was charged for if the coupon was taken off. When I talked to the lady, Christina??, she was rude. Even though she had no control over the price, she needs to ring up with items showing clearly and not quoting the wrong price. She should not tell me the prices that are different from the sign and internet. When I told her it cause the inconvenience of checking my bank account to get the refund in a few days, she was rude and told me that I caused the inconvenience for them instead of an apology for making up a receipt. Rude!!! There are a lot of pizza places on earth, you know...
My fifth grader was given a 40% off coupon by his teacher and he was excited and asked me to go to Papa Johns. I was told a medium pizza after using the coupon was $16.57 with a soda so the original price of a medium stuffed crust pepperoni pizza's original prize would have been more than $30. The signed above said $15 she said that is the sale price and online was listed $13.99. I was given a non-itemized receipt which just said Batch ID 775 $16.57. Did not know what I was charged for if the coupon was taken off. When I talked to the lady, Christina??, she was rude. Even though she had no control over the price, she needs to ring up with items showing clearly and not quoting the wrong price. She should not tell me the prices that are different from the sign and internet. When I told her it cause the inconvenience of checking my bank account to get the refund in a few days, she was rude and told me that I caused the inconvenience for them instead of an apology for making up a receipt. Incompetent and Rude!!! There are a lot of pizza places on earth. I don't need to deal with people like that. We went in happy and left unhappy. Papa Johns need to make sure people don't get rung up for a fake receipt and are told of the wrong prices. I am sure the company doesn't appreciate employees quoting the wrong prices.
40 dollars down the drain. Idk how hard it is to make a pizza but this location can never get it right. Then take more than an hour and a half to deliver a replacement and will not answer the phone.
Restaurantji Recommends
I never ever do reviews ever!!! But I just downloaded the Yelp app to write a honest review!!! I placed a order at 5:12 and my 2 pizzas didn't get here till 6:44. I called to check on the status and a automated voice kept telling me it would be here in 10 minutes!! Once the pizza finally arrived I had to call back to let them know they put anchovies on my pizza which is disgusting!!! Even after the pizza was delivered the automated voice still said 10 minutes for my delivery which was a lie cause I already received it!! So No response, nobody picked up the phone, no manager to contact!!!! Call center kept trying to to transfer us but kept getting disconnected!!! Pizza was ice cold and I still can't get a hold of the store!! Papa Johns in Middletown Delaware should be Embarrassed to even have a business!!! I will be calling corporate and going to the store to complain!!! Absolutely horrible experience and they should be shutdown!!! They only take orders and you have now way of contacting them if your order is wrong or terrible!!!! Honest legit review!!!
The food was fine, but this location was playing loud rap music with explicit lyrics, including the use of the “N” word. Completely unprofessional, this area is not the hood. I’m glad I left my son waiting in the car.
Within 10 minutes, my delicious and tasty Pizza was ready! The lady who took my order was really pleasant. I thoroughly enjoyed this meal, will definitely stop by again soon...
Believe it or not the football pizza comes uncut!? On top of that the driver achieved some g force while driving here, so pizza looked very discombobulated. This caused us to use our hand like animals!??. Overall good experience but would not recommend.
I’m tired of people making fun of me I’m tired of people give me dirty funny looks when I pick up orders for DoorDash making me feel uncomfortable I don’t care if people don’t like me but I’m not gonna be treated with disrespect and people being ignorant towards me I’m not gonna stand for that.