I absolutely adore Pop In! Super surprised to read they were open on Easter Sunday, so my husband and I made a quick visit. This is a true hidden Middletown gem. The ice cream pops are just incredible. My fave is a make your own with an Oreo pop dipped in cookie butter, covered in fluff that is torched to perfection, and dredged in sprinkles. We don’t indulge often, but when my husband and I want something sweet, this is the answer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Pop, Cookies & Cream Pop, Golden Oreo Cookie, Cookies and Creme
Rekha Vijayakumar
We tried cookies n cream, dulce de leches, almond pistachio and strawberry flavor pops today and they were so amazing. Would definitely come again. They’re using all naturalFlavors and are better choice for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Giovanna Morini
Love these artisan pops. Delicious flavor combinations, nice and clean atmosphere, and the owner is super nice. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheryl Bachmann
The popsicles were delicious, and the owner was so patient with my three kiddos who were very indecisive. We had great conversation. We can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Meyer
Amazing experience a great variety of options and toppings, a very unique experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies and Creme
mckinley lingham
Just an amazing experience and we'll be back. We have never been here before and the young lady took her time to explain everything. We made various choices and everyone was perfect, thanks again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathalie Weader
I went there for the first time and I absolutely love it! They have a large variety of flavors to choose from and you can customize your popsicle however you want. I had the cookies and cream popsicle and it was amazing! Another amazing thing is you know they are fresh because you can see the fruit inside the popsicle. I will definitely be back and I am looking forward to it.
Linda S
Cute, quaint, and definitely an NYC artisan vibe!! Many cool selections are available for you to choose from.Pros: Mango was absolutely delectable and had me wanting another one.Con: Pink Lemonade was the least of my favorite.The gentleman at the counter was extremely helpful and professional! His parents did an awesome job nurturing this young man. He knew everything about the business and with confidence.Go get these deliciously ? unique flavored Popsicles!
angela lopez
i love this place but today i ordered 2 popsicles with hazelnut chocolate, and she gave me 2 with the regular chocolate. i offered to pay for them because i didn’t want her to get in trouble payed $26… i didn’t hear an apology and she didn’t offer me some sort of 5% off for a mistake. i used my free dip to avoid paying $30?, i just saw she still charged me for the chocolate dip on both ???
Mary Jo H
Our visit to Middletown Delaware we discovered "Pop In Artisan Pops" store for a refreshing treat. Our first visit was wonderful the atmosphere was inviting, and friendly. We had the honor to have been served by the owner. She was working to make amazing, handcrafted Ice Pops, and shared her passionate story. The pops were delicious, 100% natural ingredients, and a healthy treat. We would definitely come back for another visit and recommend our family and friends to taste the amazing Artisan Pops. MJH.
So good get the s'mores one they put graham crackers fluff chocolate sauce and it's a nice place The service is great! Love it!
adrienne stichberry
Such a fun little shop ! So many flavors and toppings to choose from, a real treat !!I ordered a popular combination, key lime pie. It was fabulous ! They coated the pop in marshmallow then hit it with a flame for that roasty toasty mallow feel. Super sweet and delish!We also got the peanut butter pop and topped with with strawberry, along with a raspberry pop.Special place, a flavor for everyone including "boozy" pops !! There are even waffles you can choose from.. um, how cool ! Will absolutely return for a waffle pop and maaaaaybe a boozy pop to go !
Anna CG. DG.
They're almost too pretty to eat, and they're so creamy. Absolutely delicious!
Jessica Hiller
My parents took us here for dessert and it was so good. The ice cream pops and drizzles, and waffle pops, are not only creative but also super delicious. And the toppings are generous. Highly recommend! There’s GF,DF, and nut free options.
Tanerra W.
Great cool treats in quiet location. Small woman owned business. Also great for corporate events & parties
I absolutely adore Pop In! Super surprised to read they were open on Easter Sunday, so my husband and I made a quick visit. This is a true hidden Middletown gem. The ice cream pops are just incredible. My fave is a make your own with an Oreo pop dipped in cookie butter, covered in fluff that is torched to perfection, and dredged in sprinkles. We don’t indulge often, but when my husband and I want something sweet, this is the answer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Pop, Cookies & Cream Pop, Golden Oreo Cookie, Cookies and Creme
We tried cookies n cream, dulce de leches, almond pistachio and strawberry flavor pops today and they were so amazing. Would definitely come again. They’re using all naturalFlavors and are better choice for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love these artisan pops. Delicious flavor combinations, nice and clean atmosphere, and the owner is super nice. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The popsicles were delicious, and the owner was so patient with my three kiddos who were very indecisive. We had great conversation. We can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing experience a great variety of options and toppings, a very unique experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies and Creme
Just an amazing experience and we'll be back. We have never been here before and the young lady took her time to explain everything. We made various choices and everyone was perfect, thanks again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went there for the first time and I absolutely love it! They have a large variety of flavors to choose from and you can customize your popsicle however you want. I had the cookies and cream popsicle and it was amazing! Another amazing thing is you know they are fresh because you can see the fruit inside the popsicle. I will definitely be back and I am looking forward to it.
Cute, quaint, and definitely an NYC artisan vibe!! Many cool selections are available for you to choose from.Pros: Mango was absolutely delectable and had me wanting another one.Con: Pink Lemonade was the least of my favorite.The gentleman at the counter was extremely helpful and professional! His parents did an awesome job nurturing this young man. He knew everything about the business and with confidence.Go get these deliciously ? unique flavored Popsicles!
i love this place but today i ordered 2 popsicles with hazelnut chocolate, and she gave me 2 with the regular chocolate. i offered to pay for them because i didn’t want her to get in trouble payed $26… i didn’t hear an apology and she didn’t offer me some sort of 5% off for a mistake. i used my free dip to avoid paying $30?, i just saw she still charged me for the chocolate dip on both ???
Our visit to Middletown Delaware we discovered "Pop In Artisan Pops" store for a refreshing treat. Our first visit was wonderful the atmosphere was inviting, and friendly. We had the honor to have been served by the owner. She was working to make amazing, handcrafted Ice Pops, and shared her passionate story. The pops were delicious, 100% natural ingredients, and a healthy treat. We would definitely come back for another visit and recommend our family and friends to taste the amazing Artisan Pops. MJH.
Restaurantji Recommends
So good get the s'mores one they put graham crackers fluff chocolate sauce and it's a nice place The service is great! Love it!
Such a fun little shop ! So many flavors and toppings to choose from, a real treat !!I ordered a popular combination, key lime pie. It was fabulous ! They coated the pop in marshmallow then hit it with a flame for that roasty toasty mallow feel. Super sweet and delish!We also got the peanut butter pop and topped with with strawberry, along with a raspberry pop.Special place, a flavor for everyone including "boozy" pops !! There are even waffles you can choose from.. um, how cool ! Will absolutely return for a waffle pop and maaaaaybe a boozy pop to go !
They're almost too pretty to eat, and they're so creamy. Absolutely delicious!
My parents took us here for dessert and it was so good. The ice cream pops and drizzles, and waffle pops, are not only creative but also super delicious. And the toppings are generous. Highly recommend! There’s GF,DF, and nut free options.
Great cool treats in quiet location. Small woman owned business. Also great for corporate events & parties