I want to like this place, I really do. We've ordered several times, delivery, and the orders have been hot and correct. But the taste! The Alfredo is bland. I was so looking forward to some good Italian pasta and what I got made me wish I had just opened a can of Prego and saved the money. I feel the same about the garlic knots, soaked in butter, but no flavor. I really want this restaurant to succeed, but for right now, the food just isn't great. We'll try again if we hear improvements are made, but we won't waste the money again otherwise.
Jillian H.
I want to like this place, I really do. We've ordered several times, delivery, and the orders have been hot and correct. But the taste! The Alfredo is so bland. I was so looking forward to some good Italian pasta and what I got made me wish I had just opened a can of Prego and saved the money. I feel the same about the garlic knots, soaked in butter, but no flavor. I really want this restaurant to succeed, but for right now, the food just isn't great. We'll try again if we hear improvements are made, but we won't waste the money again.
Tanya DeBauch
I have Celiac, but went with friends because they wanted to go. The only gluten free options are a choice between 2 salads on the menu. I realize this is an Italian/ Pizza place but, most places at least carry a gluten free crust option. Other than that, the service was great and the staff is friendly.
S. A. S.
They aren't open on Sunday when they claim they are.....at least update the hours. Poor customer service!
Bert G
We called in a take-out order here by mistake. Went to pick it up and thought, this is the wrong place. But we ordered it, so we picked it up. We are so glad we did. The pizza is very good, the best I've eaten in this area. Crust was perfect. I will be back, many times.
Plenchy
Had the Pizza yesterday, large pepperoni.....not bad. NYPD Pizza in Navarre and Boomerang Pizza in Milton have them beat hands down. The Cannoli was good but they only filled the ends with cream. The center was hollow.
rjmelend
I grew up in West New York, NJ (yea in jersey) and I have a taste for NY pizza, I rarely find good places in Florida that can give me that NY pizza taste/feel. This place knocked it out of the park. I felt right back at home eating that pizza. My kids loved it and the staff was very friendly. If your looking for a slice of Ny Pizza this is the place! I drove almost an hour from Freeport because I was looking for a Ny Pizza place. I have a feeling I will be doing that drive a lot more often.
matt mccauley
Food was good. Server had no idea what what he was doing but whatever food made up for it.
- Fumante
Born and raised in nyc and to be honest the sauce is NOT GOOD. Nowhere in New York is the sauce on a pie sweet. The Sicilian pie was awful, you could just tell the cheese wasn’t fresh or anything. I was actually really disappointed.
The pizza is getting thicker by the year. I just got a cheese pizza that was as think as a Sicilian. What’s the deal ? I see they are always looking for people. Maybe staff issue idk.
missy DuPree
First time there and it was Great service and Great Pizza, Will be back of we are ever in Crestview again. My Son Loved Watching them make the pizzas.
Stevanna Allen
Food is EXCELLENT, BUT the service is garbage. Teenagers at the front counter are rude and aloof like I’m inconveniencing them every time I show up. I say this because it’s happened three times now. Asked for a pizza and knots, got a sub instead. They didn’t want to rectify it or anything so I paid for a sub and knots and had to wait another twenty minutes to get the pizza I ordered and pay for that too. The owner needs to take action: I see all of the other reviews complaining about the same thing. The bad service has me one inch from never wanting to here again.
Aaron Heller
I'm not usually one to take time out of my day to leave a review, but here we are. Their pizza is great, best pizza I've had in awhile. I will say however the mozzarella sticks I can tell are frozen, then thrown into a fryer, which most places are the same however they over cooked mine to where there was barely any cheese in them and it was watery when I bit down into them. I also had the chicken parm dinner. Very disappointing. The chicken was overcooked and chewy. I struggle to even cut it. Then all the breading fell out. I just threw the chicken away. I also asked for extra sauce on the pasta, and there was barely any in there. I hope this business sees this and doesn't take it as an insult, but more as something to improve on. Sorry for the long review.
Joyzinha
After a horrible experience at nearby Pizza Hut where we left without eating, we found this little place by searching for nearby restaurants. It was a wonderful experience for our two grandsons who loved their pizza by the slice the way they each wanted, and we had the New Yorker pizza. We ordered a medium and it was HUGE! Service was fantastic too. And they have a few TVS, and a small selection of bottled beer. We will return.
I want to like this place, I really do. We've ordered several times, delivery, and the orders have been hot and correct. But the taste! The Alfredo is bland. I was so looking forward to some good Italian pasta and what I got made me wish I had just opened a can of Prego and saved the money. I feel the same about the garlic knots, soaked in butter, but no flavor. I really want this restaurant to succeed, but for right now, the food just isn't great. We'll try again if we hear improvements are made, but we won't waste the money again otherwise.
I want to like this place, I really do. We've ordered several times, delivery, and the orders have been hot and correct. But the taste! The Alfredo is so bland. I was so looking forward to some good Italian pasta and what I got made me wish I had just opened a can of Prego and saved the money. I feel the same about the garlic knots, soaked in butter, but no flavor. I really want this restaurant to succeed, but for right now, the food just isn't great. We'll try again if we hear improvements are made, but we won't waste the money again.
I have Celiac, but went with friends because they wanted to go. The only gluten free options are a choice between 2 salads on the menu. I realize this is an Italian/ Pizza place but, most places at least carry a gluten free crust option. Other than that, the service was great and the staff is friendly.
They aren't open on Sunday when they claim they are.....at least update the hours. Poor customer service!
We called in a take-out order here by mistake. Went to pick it up and thought, this is the wrong place. But we ordered it, so we picked it up. We are so glad we did. The pizza is very good, the best I've eaten in this area. Crust was perfect. I will be back, many times.
Had the Pizza yesterday, large pepperoni.....not bad. NYPD Pizza in Navarre and Boomerang Pizza in Milton have them beat hands down. The Cannoli was good but they only filled the ends with cream. The center was hollow.
I grew up in West New York, NJ (yea in jersey) and I have a taste for NY pizza, I rarely find good places in Florida that can give me that NY pizza taste/feel. This place knocked it out of the park. I felt right back at home eating that pizza. My kids loved it and the staff was very friendly. If your looking for a slice of Ny Pizza this is the place! I drove almost an hour from Freeport because I was looking for a Ny Pizza place. I have a feeling I will be doing that drive a lot more often.
Food was good. Server had no idea what what he was doing but whatever food made up for it.
Born and raised in nyc and to be honest the sauce is NOT GOOD. Nowhere in New York is the sauce on a pie sweet. The Sicilian pie was awful, you could just tell the cheese wasn’t fresh or anything. I was actually really disappointed.
Hands down the best pizza in Crestview!!
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza is getting thicker by the year. I just got a cheese pizza that was as think as a Sicilian. What’s the deal ? I see they are always looking for people. Maybe staff issue idk.
First time there and it was Great service and Great Pizza, Will be back of we are ever in Crestview again. My Son Loved Watching them make the pizzas.
Food is EXCELLENT, BUT the service is garbage. Teenagers at the front counter are rude and aloof like I’m inconveniencing them every time I show up. I say this because it’s happened three times now. Asked for a pizza and knots, got a sub instead. They didn’t want to rectify it or anything so I paid for a sub and knots and had to wait another twenty minutes to get the pizza I ordered and pay for that too. The owner needs to take action: I see all of the other reviews complaining about the same thing. The bad service has me one inch from never wanting to here again.
I'm not usually one to take time out of my day to leave a review, but here we are. Their pizza is great, best pizza I've had in awhile. I will say however the mozzarella sticks I can tell are frozen, then thrown into a fryer, which most places are the same however they over cooked mine to where there was barely any cheese in them and it was watery when I bit down into them. I also had the chicken parm dinner. Very disappointing. The chicken was overcooked and chewy. I struggle to even cut it. Then all the breading fell out. I just threw the chicken away. I also asked for extra sauce on the pasta, and there was barely any in there. I hope this business sees this and doesn't take it as an insult, but more as something to improve on. Sorry for the long review.
After a horrible experience at nearby Pizza Hut where we left without eating, we found this little place by searching for nearby restaurants. It was a wonderful experience for our two grandsons who loved their pizza by the slice the way they each wanted, and we had the New Yorker pizza. We ordered a medium and it was HUGE! Service was fantastic too. And they have a few TVS, and a small selection of bottled beer. We will return.