Citrola's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Tonight we were talking amongst ourselves about a good place to go get a bite to eat for dinner, and wanted to try a new place that we've never been to before. We decided to try this place out and I am very happy that we did! Being greeted at the door made us feel welcome and we ordered a large pizza and split a large salad. Everything was excellent and I definitely will be returning to this restaurant in the future! I strongly recommend they try this place out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a large group of 14 with reservations. They had an outside area set up for us. The service was fabulous..the food amazing. I ordered the Brushetta for an appetizer, best I ever had and the Fettuccini Already. Huge portion..had to get a to go box! They also make their own bread which was delicious! Would definitely recommend and go back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bruschetta

Craving some good Italian food, here's the spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I got chicken with taco sauce. Chicken was grilled and dried out like it was just reheated. Pasta was OK sauce was OK. Nothing to jump up and down place was empty. My head had gotten there around 6:00 PM.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We live close by and this has been our go to place for everything Italian to pick up and bring home to enjoy. Tonight, for the third time in a row, pizza was over cooked. Cheese was black on top. Mistakes and bad nights happen, but not three consecutive times. I’m looking for another pizza joint. 3 strikes. Out.

Food: 1

This place is awesome! Food is always hot, feels like home. Jamie is a wonderful server!

Atmosphere: 5

EXIT TO ADD: Went last night for dinner to see if it was as good as the lunch was on a proceeding day. My husband is a red sauce snob, and he said they have one of the best Red sauces he has had.
Hubs had a pasta dish, I had chicken parm. Plentiful portions, and both dishes were to die for. Had bruschetta as an appetizer, and it was light, airy, and fabulous.
DeLacy was our waitress, she did a fabulous job, keeping our waters filled, and the drinks flowing.
Cannot recommend this restaurant more highly. Though it’s a 40 minute drive for us, it is absolutely worth it!

Original review:
Holy smokes, we have found the best Italian in Southwest Florida!
My mom and I stopped at Citrolas on College for a very early dinner tonight. After a day of appointments, all I wanted was decent food. We have yet to find decent Italian in Fort Myers, but that certainly changed this evening!

We had the most wonderful and cheerful waitress, I did not get her name in the chaos of today. She shared favorite things on the menu, Her personal favorites, plus specials for the evening. Hearing about their sauces, being homemade and tailored to order made me realize this is true cooking to order.

My mom had the chicken Parmesan, and I will say it was probably the best we have had. The chicken was done perfectly, it was moist and juicy, and crispy on the exterior. The red sauce is so flavorful!

I had gnocchi Bolognese, and it was fabulous and filling. The Bolognese was extremely authentic.

If you’re in the mood for some fabulous Italian, this place is a must do. Knowing they take reservations, we will definitely be back… And soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lasagna is the BEST.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was beyond exceptional and the service was even better Maisly is excellent
I highly recommend this place you will not regret it. Thank you for the great experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Listen I’m born and raised from Brooklyn NY after checking reviews and other restaurants reviews I chose this restaurant it’s definitely New York Style pizza. You must stop here or order to go you won’t regret!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Take out. It said it came with a salad but no salad was in the bags. The food was good and plenty.

Visited this Italian restaurant with my family and had an excellent experience. The food quality was outstanding, and the service was just as impressive. The garlic knots were delicious, and they also served complimentary fresh-baked bread with butter — it arrived steaming hot and was a great start to the meal.

We ordered the Caesar salad, penne alla vodka, and Alfredo pasta — all three dishes were flavorful and perfectly prepared. For dessert, we had their chocolate cake, which was absolutely worth it!

If we’re ever back in the area, we’ll definitely be returning. Highly recommend this spot for anyone craving authentic Italian comfort food with great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Cake, Garlic Knots 6

I can’t say enough good things about this place, I don’t think I’ve ever eaten anywhere and have enjoyed a meal so much. Last week I ate lunch here to go 3 times and then dinner Friday night. It’s now become my Friday night ritual. The staff is so nice and friendly and the bread is just so die for! Just overall a fantastic restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Citrola’s Italian Restaurant in Fort Myers completely blew me away! From the moment we walked in, the warm, welcoming atmosphere made us feel right at home. The food was nothing short of unbelievable — every bite packed with authentic Italian flavor and made with obvious care and passion. Don't miss out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5