Santa Lucia Pizzeria & Restaurant

This is a small restaurant but the food is excellent! Order at the counter and seat yourself. Staff are nice and obviously work together very well. It is not fancy but its a nice place for a mini strip mall. Prices are reasonable.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great people and great food! The service was excellent and the food was super fresh with top notch ingredients. I definitely recommend this place to anyone in the area looking for authentic Italian food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Pizza

The food was excellent, although the customer service was awful. The lady at the front counter brought our food to our table, gave my boyfriend silverware to eat with, but gave me a dirty look and didn’t give me any silverware. I asked for silverware so I can eat too, and she gave me a snotty crappy grin. I have been here before and she’s always been very rude to do anything wrong to this person.. I will never step foot in this restaurant again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recently moved to the Punta Gora area for work and found this hidden Gem. Fantastic wings and salad, friendly and close by. 10 STARS!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered take out since we were kinda close to closing time by the time my husband and I decided on what to have for dinner. Not used to places closing by 7pm on a Friday night but we figured we would give this place a try, I read good reviews. Greeted warmly and friendly owners chatted while I waited a couple minutes until my order was ready. Noticed the cannoli in the display case and figured I would put that on my list to try another time.
Ordered the house special pizza and it did not disappoint. I usually can't eat the crust of any pizza here in Florida, but these New Yorkers know how to do pizza! Yummy. Really nice menu with typical Italian dishes so we will be back! Its just past the blinking light at Disston Ave in the plaza with a Florist/event business if you're coming from PG. Its worth the trip from Arcadia! Mangia! Bravo.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you're in search of the best, most authentic Italian food, look no further than Santa Lucia Pizzeria in Punta Gorda!! 🍕My husband and I make several trips a year for doctor’s appointments and always carve out time for a meal with the lovely owners, Sal and Maria. From the moment you walk in, they make you feel like family—it's truly a home away from home. Sal, originally from Italy, puts so much love into every dish he creates, and it shows! The pizza is simply out of this world—definitely the best we’ve ever had! We can't wait for our next visit to try even more of their incredible food and fellowship. Thank you, Sal and Maria, for always providing such an amazing experience! 110% RECOMMEND!!! 🍕❤️

Closed on a Wednesday. They need to update their business hours.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Best pizza for 40 miles anyway around here!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Love this pizza

Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in SW Florida- so much flavor! The Santa Lucia pizza add ricotta is delicious!

Excellent food...highly recommend...food and desserts are delicious 😋

I've gone by twice now they're never open

Small place limited seating.A mom and pop operation. Food is very good, good pizza. The meat Stromboli is delicious.

Wow! First time trying the pizza here and it was absolutely delicious! We got the everything pizza and the meatballs and the sauce were top tier. The owners were super nice and so friendly. I'm so glad I found this place. It's now my go to for pizza nights! Highly recommend this place

The best pizza, pasta, and garlic bread I have ever had.