Great staff, great food, quick service and an amazing ambiance. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza D O P
Morgan Benson
my pasta was uncooked, the music was way too loud, and our service was terrible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jane Smith
The atmosphere, music reminded me of Sorento, very relaxing. Choosing a dish was difficult as it all sounded enticing, but the Veal Piccata became our choice. Phenomenal! The tiramasu, heavenly! What a lovely treat. Alexandria was very efficient as she was personable. Next time we're in the area, Amalfi will be our destination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrie D
I won't go again. I am in the hospitality business and stay in the Hotel next to the Restaurant. It's my job to recommend restaurants to my guests. I thought I would try this restaurant before recommending to guests. Glad I did. I won't recommend nor will I go there again. I had Mussels and salad. The mussels, $16, and I got 14 mussels. Extremely salty and three of them were not open which means they are dead and can't be eaten. six of them were so tough I tried to chew them but ended up spitting them out. The sauce was nothing but water with minced garlic, no flavor. The house salad, nothing but chopped romaine lettuce with two cherry tomatoes cut in half and maybe six walnuts, cost $10. I will not tell any of my guests who stay at the hotel to go there. I don't want them to have the experience I did. Find another place. Go here only if you are desperate and to tired to go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jayna Patel
I’ve come to this restaurant a couple of times and each time I left feeling full and happy. I’ve tried so many of this dishes here and almost all of them were great! I would recommend the Lobster Ravioli, the Chicken Rigatoni, the Peppadew Peppers, the Cesar Salad, the Zucchini Flowers and the spaghetti pasta! A secret if you’re the kind of person who enjoys spicy food, ask for the Calabrian hot honey sauce. It sounds like it’s sweet but it’s actually spicy and so good! I would come here over and over for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Zucchini Fritti, Rigatoni Di Napoli, Lobster Ravioli, Margherita Pizza D O P, Bruschetta, Eggplant Parmigiana Melanzane, Espresso'Tini
Clarence Jordan
New server so he struggled but he gave a great effort. Went for opportunity to see red phone booth. Busy night I guess. Will be back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
SydneyN
The food was good for the price, as the pricing is pretty cheap for an Italian restaurant in Buckhead. The only major complaint was the pizza was literally barely cooked. The crust was fully limp and had absolutely no crunch when biting into it.
Dana Sloane
Pizza is very good, but service was not great. One server was alternating checking her phone with shaping dough - gloveless, which was a little gross.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Very lovely restaurant with delicious food, but the service was subpar. It seemed like our waitress had to ration water to the whole restaurant as we didn't get a single top off or refill. I would also recommend bringing your own silverware as they don't bring out silverware with their dishes after they cleared your first meal...? And I always have a pet-peeve when I make a reservation, show up on time, and the table is not ready for another 15-20 minutes. I think it defeats the whole purpose of a reservation, and makes the restaurant feel tacky rather than professional. All of that being said, the food is outstanding! Bad service can be fixed so I will be coming back again.
Brian Lawson
Atlanta Eats was spot on again. Great atmosphere,1 really great food. The mussels are some of the best in Atlanta. The fried calamari was delicious. We had pizza, The Eggplant and Chicken parmigianoreat choices. Make sure you come hungry. Great prices. Free valet parking. Military discount off the food. Ask for Morgan she's a great hostess.Parking: Make sure to get your ticket stamped
We had a party of 4 for dinner on Saturday, 1/20/24, at 5:30 pm. The restaurant is really cute. Good date-like atmosphere.We split 2 appetizers between the 4 of us and each got our own entree. My friend and I shared our 2 entrees. Here’s what I had:- Mozzarella en Carrozza ($12): Perfectly crispy. Very good.- Eggplant Parmigiana Melanzane ($15): A little cold. The eggplant wasn’t fried to our liking. Definitely not worth $15. Pass.- Spicy Sicilian Pizza with ricotta-filled crust ($17 + $5): We were told we could do any pizza and make the crust ricotta-filled. The amount of ricotta in each slice was the miniature-est dollop. We felt like it was a ripoff. The actual pizza was decent though!- Rigatoni di Napoli ($22): This was heavy, but I enjoyed it. Others in my party weren’t as keen on it though.My friend got the Chicken Alfredo ($26) and didn’t like it at all.Overall, we had high hopes, but were a little disappointed. We wouldn’t go back.Parking: Parking garage free up to 2 hours!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
My daughter enjoyed having her birthday luncheon at Amalfi. The food was fresh and made to order. Our server was courteous, professional, and friendly. The overall experience was outstanding.
Girlgotanappetite
Lunchtime was great at Amalfi! Service was excellent and friendly. The food came out quickly which was great since we were on our lunch break! I'm never disappointed with the food either. Delicious authentic tastes!
MarilynB
I love this restaurant. It's our second time here and now it's our new favorite place. The pizzas are amazing. So are the salads and the pasta. The service is great and the atmosphere wonderful. They play our favorite music. Our favorite pizza is the Sicilian with Calabrian honey. Marilyn
jessica namaste
We were there when it was not very busy at all and our service was extremely slow and our server was inattentive. In fact, they never even acknowledged how slow the service was.Overall, our table had mixed reactions on the food. Two of us really enjoyed our pizzas, the others were underwhelmed with their choices (chicken parm, one of the salads and I don't remember the other one). They all said they were fine dishes, but not great.Vegetarian options: Typical choices, the same as other Italian menus.
Great staff, great food, quick service and an amazing ambiance. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza D O P
my pasta was uncooked, the music was way too loud, and our service was terrible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The atmosphere, music reminded me of Sorento, very relaxing. Choosing a dish was difficult as it all sounded enticing, but the Veal Piccata became our choice. Phenomenal! The tiramasu, heavenly! What a lovely treat. Alexandria was very efficient as she was personable. Next time we're in the area, Amalfi will be our destination.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I won't go again. I am in the hospitality business and stay in the Hotel next to the Restaurant. It's my job to recommend restaurants to my guests. I thought I would try this restaurant before recommending to guests. Glad I did. I won't recommend nor will I go there again. I had Mussels and salad. The mussels, $16, and I got 14 mussels. Extremely salty and three of them were not open which means they are dead and can't be eaten. six of them were so tough I tried to chew them but ended up spitting them out. The sauce was nothing but water with minced garlic, no flavor. The house salad, nothing but chopped romaine lettuce with two cherry tomatoes cut in half and maybe six walnuts, cost $10. I will not tell any of my guests who stay at the hotel to go there. I don't want them to have the experience I did. Find another place. Go here only if you are desperate and to tired to go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
I’ve come to this restaurant a couple of times and each time I left feeling full and happy. I’ve tried so many of this dishes here and almost all of them were great! I would recommend the Lobster Ravioli, the Chicken Rigatoni, the Peppadew Peppers, the Cesar Salad, the Zucchini Flowers and the spaghetti pasta! A secret if you’re the kind of person who enjoys spicy food, ask for the Calabrian hot honey sauce. It sounds like it’s sweet but it’s actually spicy and so good! I would come here over and over for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Zucchini Fritti, Rigatoni Di Napoli, Lobster Ravioli, Margherita Pizza D O P, Bruschetta, Eggplant Parmigiana Melanzane, Espresso'Tini
New server so he struggled but he gave a great effort. Went for opportunity to see red phone booth. Busy night I guess. Will be back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
The food was good for the price, as the pricing is pretty cheap for an Italian restaurant in Buckhead. The only major complaint was the pizza was literally barely cooked. The crust was fully limp and had absolutely no crunch when biting into it.
Pizza is very good, but service was not great. One server was alternating checking her phone with shaping dough - gloveless, which was a little gross.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Very lovely restaurant with delicious food, but the service was subpar. It seemed like our waitress had to ration water to the whole restaurant as we didn't get a single top off or refill. I would also recommend bringing your own silverware as they don't bring out silverware with their dishes after they cleared your first meal...? And I always have a pet-peeve when I make a reservation, show up on time, and the table is not ready for another 15-20 minutes. I think it defeats the whole purpose of a reservation, and makes the restaurant feel tacky rather than professional. All of that being said, the food is outstanding! Bad service can be fixed so I will be coming back again.
Atlanta Eats was spot on again. Great atmosphere,1 really great food. The mussels are some of the best in Atlanta. The fried calamari was delicious. We had pizza, The Eggplant and Chicken parmigianoreat choices. Make sure you come hungry. Great prices. Free valet parking. Military discount off the food. Ask for Morgan she's a great hostess.Parking: Make sure to get your ticket stamped
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiano, Calamari
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a party of 4 for dinner on Saturday, 1/20/24, at 5:30 pm. The restaurant is really cute. Good date-like atmosphere.We split 2 appetizers between the 4 of us and each got our own entree. My friend and I shared our 2 entrees. Here’s what I had:- Mozzarella en Carrozza ($12): Perfectly crispy. Very good.- Eggplant Parmigiana Melanzane ($15): A little cold. The eggplant wasn’t fried to our liking. Definitely not worth $15. Pass.- Spicy Sicilian Pizza with ricotta-filled crust ($17 + $5): We were told we could do any pizza and make the crust ricotta-filled. The amount of ricotta in each slice was the miniature-est dollop. We felt like it was a ripoff. The actual pizza was decent though!- Rigatoni di Napoli ($22): This was heavy, but I enjoyed it. Others in my party weren’t as keen on it though.My friend got the Chicken Alfredo ($26) and didn’t like it at all.Overall, we had high hopes, but were a little disappointed. We wouldn’t go back.Parking: Parking garage free up to 2 hours!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
My daughter enjoyed having her birthday luncheon at Amalfi. The food was fresh and made to order. Our server was courteous, professional, and friendly. The overall experience was outstanding.
Lunchtime was great at Amalfi! Service was excellent and friendly. The food came out quickly which was great since we were on our lunch break! I'm never disappointed with the food either. Delicious authentic tastes!
I love this restaurant. It's our second time here and now it's our new favorite place. The pizzas are amazing. So are the salads and the pasta. The service is great and the atmosphere wonderful. They play our favorite music. Our favorite pizza is the Sicilian with Calabrian honey. Marilyn
We were there when it was not very busy at all and our service was extremely slow and our server was inattentive. In fact, they never even acknowledged how slow the service was.Overall, our table had mixed reactions on the food. Two of us really enjoyed our pizzas, the others were underwhelmed with their choices (chicken parm, one of the salads and I don't remember the other one). They all said they were fine dishes, but not great.Vegetarian options: Typical choices, the same as other Italian menus.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza D O P