Regarding the chicken pot pie, there are far too many peas, no potatoes and a nominal amount of chicken.
Food: 3
Chikaome Imediegwu
The pies are not ready to eat. You'll have to take them home and cook in the oven for at least an hour and a half. There are a variety of dishes to try out and you can pick from the options. I took the classic chicken pie, though I wasn't entirely impressed. It had a lot of mayo, green peas and sweet corn. No is no dine-in and parking in limited in the square. Generally the service is great and friendly.Parking: It's free for the first two hours.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Curry Pie
Emily Waters
Cute little shop with the menu posted really big on your right when you walk in. Not a whole lot in there since all they really sell are pot pies. There is a ramp to walk up when you come through the door. The lady who helped me explained each pie, pricing, and how to cook it. The pies ARE NOT cooked! You have to do that. But it's so super easy and they come out amazing! I got the Shepherd's pie. It was so so good. The crust is perfectly flaky. My husband and son really enjoyed it too. I will definitely be coming back to try more pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay Wolfberg
Great experience with my first order from them. Easy to order in advance, great food! So far have tried the chicken and beef stroganoff!
Jane Cera
I haven’t had a pot pie from Paul’s that I didn’t like. Although, my all time favorite is the curry pot pie. At first, I thought this would just be fair, so I got a smaller pie, but what a surprise. It was delicious.
janehQ1904XD
I was very disappointed after reading the reviews. I bought the chicken, jambalaya, and shepherds pie. All 3 were tasteless and dry. There was not any sauce/gravy inside the pie. I literally felt like I was eating chicken and vegetables and then a side of puff pastry. I added salt and pepper to help the taste. My friend added a combination of hot sauces and seasonings to the jambalaya pie to give it some flavor. My mother said the Shepherds pie was also very dry and no flavor. Maybe our pot pie expectation is different or maybe it was an off day for the baker. I’ve never had a pot pie without gravy sauce in the pie. I gave 3 stars because it was a lot of food in the pie and it was filling. We ate all 3 but we had to spruce up the flavors.
Nancy Wheeler
Excellent pies. Great flaky crust. Friendly person working there last week. We picked out 2 pies and both were very, very good. Will go again next time we are in the area.
Amie Burke
We love these pot pies. Lots of variety & super delicious. Have been enjoying them for several years now. Two sizes great for both small servings & large family size.Would love to see gluten free & additional veggie pie options added to the menu. (They have 1 veggie pie).They also have a Kennesaw location. We love supporting our local small businesses. Paul's Pot Pies has always been friendly, consistent on hours & make super delicious pot pies!
Susan Mangina
Classic Chicken and Taco pot pie’s. Good meal. Good fast healthy dinner for my family. I served it with a nice hearty salad.The taco pie was a hit with my kids. Served it with guacamole and sour cream.I like to make my own pot pies. This was definitely the next best thing!
Nick Stone
Love Paul's! Awesome guy and even better pies. Various pies all very much so delicious. My favorite is the seafood chowder. If you need a meal or a dish to take, Paul's is the place!
I am so glad this place exists, and the pies are reasonably priced.There are many varieties to choose from. You will love your decision to stop it. The pies don't take too long to cook either.
Am Y
Great place to stock your freezer with oven-ready meals!!! We first tried these when they were given to us as a gift during a family emergency. It’s a great way to bless someone with some different flavors they can try! Shepherd’s pie is our favorite, and our go-to, but you definitely need to add a good amount of salt and pepper.
John Cloutier
We live in Alpharetta but will drive back to Marietta after trying these great pies! Highly recommend.
J K
Delicious and convenient as they come frozen. Pop in the oven anytime for a quick and filling meal. Many different kinds to choose from. Flaky crust on top and plenty of filling inside. 3 small pies cost around $30. They have two sizes 6 and 10 inch.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jody M.
Have wanted to try the place for years. Hoped to drop in and have a quick bite while hanging out at Marietta Square. We'll, it doesn't work like that. You can pick up a frozen pot pie and take it home, though, as that's how it ACTUALLY works. I bought two small pot pies (traditional chicken and a beef stroganoff). Both were delicious and it really was like eating a homemade pot pie. Well, I deserve SOME of the credit, but it's not really about me. Lol. Recommended!!
Regarding the chicken pot pie, there are far too many peas, no potatoes and a nominal amount of chicken.
Food: 3
The pies are not ready to eat. You'll have to take them home and cook in the oven for at least an hour and a half. There are a variety of dishes to try out and you can pick from the options. I took the classic chicken pie, though I wasn't entirely impressed. It had a lot of mayo, green peas and sweet corn. No is no dine-in and parking in limited in the square. Generally the service is great and friendly.Parking: It's free for the first two hours.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Curry Pie
Cute little shop with the menu posted really big on your right when you walk in. Not a whole lot in there since all they really sell are pot pies. There is a ramp to walk up when you come through the door. The lady who helped me explained each pie, pricing, and how to cook it. The pies ARE NOT cooked! You have to do that. But it's so super easy and they come out amazing! I got the Shepherd's pie. It was so so good. The crust is perfectly flaky. My husband and son really enjoyed it too. I will definitely be coming back to try more pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great experience with my first order from them. Easy to order in advance, great food! So far have tried the chicken and beef stroganoff!
I haven’t had a pot pie from Paul’s that I didn’t like. Although, my all time favorite is the curry pot pie. At first, I thought this would just be fair, so I got a smaller pie, but what a surprise. It was delicious.
I was very disappointed after reading the reviews. I bought the chicken, jambalaya, and shepherds pie. All 3 were tasteless and dry. There was not any sauce/gravy inside the pie. I literally felt like I was eating chicken and vegetables and then a side of puff pastry. I added salt and pepper to help the taste. My friend added a combination of hot sauces and seasonings to the jambalaya pie to give it some flavor. My mother said the Shepherds pie was also very dry and no flavor. Maybe our pot pie expectation is different or maybe it was an off day for the baker. I’ve never had a pot pie without gravy sauce in the pie. I gave 3 stars because it was a lot of food in the pie and it was filling. We ate all 3 but we had to spruce up the flavors.
Excellent pies. Great flaky crust. Friendly person working there last week. We picked out 2 pies and both were very, very good. Will go again next time we are in the area.
We love these pot pies. Lots of variety & super delicious. Have been enjoying them for several years now. Two sizes great for both small servings & large family size.Would love to see gluten free & additional veggie pie options added to the menu. (They have 1 veggie pie).They also have a Kennesaw location. We love supporting our local small businesses. Paul's Pot Pies has always been friendly, consistent on hours & make super delicious pot pies!
Classic Chicken and Taco pot pie’s. Good meal. Good fast healthy dinner for my family. I served it with a nice hearty salad.The taco pie was a hit with my kids. Served it with guacamole and sour cream.I like to make my own pot pies. This was definitely the next best thing!
Love Paul's! Awesome guy and even better pies. Various pies all very much so delicious. My favorite is the seafood chowder. If you need a meal or a dish to take, Paul's is the place!
Restaurantji Recommends
I am so glad this place exists, and the pies are reasonably priced.There are many varieties to choose from. You will love your decision to stop it. The pies don't take too long to cook either.
Great place to stock your freezer with oven-ready meals!!! We first tried these when they were given to us as a gift during a family emergency. It’s a great way to bless someone with some different flavors they can try! Shepherd’s pie is our favorite, and our go-to, but you definitely need to add a good amount of salt and pepper.
We live in Alpharetta but will drive back to Marietta after trying these great pies! Highly recommend.
Delicious and convenient as they come frozen. Pop in the oven anytime for a quick and filling meal. Many different kinds to choose from. Flaky crust on top and plenty of filling inside. 3 small pies cost around $30. They have two sizes 6 and 10 inch.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Have wanted to try the place for years. Hoped to drop in and have a quick bite while hanging out at Marietta Square. We'll, it doesn't work like that. You can pick up a frozen pot pie and take it home, though, as that's how it ACTUALLY works. I bought two small pot pies (traditional chicken and a beef stroganoff). Both were delicious and it really was like eating a homemade pot pie. Well, I deserve SOME of the credit, but it's not really about me. Lol. Recommended!!