MooMcGinn's Magic Creamery

6014 GA-21 ste j, Rincon
(912) 394-4469

Recent Reviews

Kimmie S

I have visited this establishment twice and on both occasions, I received about half the amount of ice cream as I saw everyone else did. On the second occasion, one girl told the other she had to use a certain amount of pumps for a double serving and the girl stated no she didn’t and thus yet again I ended up paying for half of what I should have received again. Although the profit is good, I don’t feel as though I received my moneys worth. My total was $55 the first visit and $31 the second. That’s too much to not get what I paid for.Update from experience:It just wows me that the owner, I’m assuming, is the one that reached out because of my post asking if I would send a private message so that they could get a better understanding of what my experience was. I did as asked just to be messaged back that they were busy with work and would get back in touch with me but surprisingly never did. Not only is that bad business but horrible ethics. I have in a nut shell been led to believe that I clearly don’t matter. It’s not often I leave reviews but this has really taken the cake for me. I guess if I was rude or irate more would have been done. Sadly this is how people really are. I would give zero stars if possible.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Troy Rush

First of all the ice cream was different, in a good way, and the flavors list was impressive. Atmosphere was nice and the young ladies working were very nice and helpful. We really enjoyed everything we got. My only complaint was there is only one size option, which was a large cup. I took my two young daughters and they wouldn’t allow us to put 2 flavors in one cup so the girls could split the large cup. Would definitely like to see some size options.Kid-friendliness: Don’t have small kid size options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Paul Tornay

Interesting - first time I’ve ever tried nitrogen ice cream. Sort of an odd texture, and average quality ingredients. The strangest part of the experience was the weird film that developed on our teeth after eating our ice cream (three of us; everyone had the same experience). The people working there were very nice.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Mitchell Hanson

Very affordable price for the amount of ice cream. Pick a base then add toppings. It has a mix between a dip n dots and ice cream texture and was super yummy. I did coffee Nutella with coconut, caramel, and hot fudge. Worker was kind enough to dye the caramel green for st. Patty’s. Lovely place!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Swapna Radha

Love the ambience. Hot chocolate was really tasty. Staff is really friendly with kids.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry, Red Velvet Cheesecake

Purple Mayo

Very good, highly recommended.Decided to have ice cream for the first time this decade on my birthday today. I got in late and the staff was very friendly! The menu was massive so I was a bit confused as to what to order - I told the worker that I like peanut butter and she knew exactly what to recommend. IDK what it was, but it was awesome! Real peanut butter, chunky stuff, chewy things ... solid 10/10.The furniture here is also quite nice, I do carpentry as a hobby and most of the stuff in there seems handmade!Overall this place is worth a visit, if not many visits.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Elvis

S Hayes

Quaint Adorable unique tasty spot with friendly service and a great atmosphere in beautiful Rincon GA. Well worth the money and an over all lovely experience. So many flavors to choose from as well as lactose free options. Nice place to sit and enjoy the country eclectic decor with lived one or friends or take ot to go. A must stop and try place when you want a taste of creamy flavor filled icecream!Kid-friendliness: Kids will love the fun environment and to see ice cream be made in front of them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cotton Candy, Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Birthday Cake with Added Sprinkles

Nanette Parrett

Ice cream is great. Just a little pricey.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melina B.

This ice cream shop offers so many flavors and options to add to your ice cream! The workers were all kind and trying to move as fast as they could with how busy it was. My mom wanted to try there season flavor pumpkin spice latte and she loved it! I decided to get chocolate ice cream filled with brownies and fudge and it was a chocolate delicious combo! The inside is cute and they have a lot of tables for small and bigger groups. I can't wait to try other flavors!

Cyn Gardner

First time trying nitrogen ice cream! First... employees were very nice and helpful. SO many flavors to choose from. Different texture. A bit chewy but good. Large portion but...$7 a cup! I went with vanilla with brownie add in. I would say be more daring. The salted caramel was wonderful.

Elinor Horton

What a nice place! I loved my nitrogen ice cream ????Loved the music ???????

Erica Atherton

Love the ice cream! The staff is just as sweet!

Anonymous A.

As a first time customer I had a bad experience. Ice cream decent. Bathroom dirty. Went there and a teenage boy behind counter. Who was rude and stated he didn't know how it worked because he didn't work there. Stated they let him behind the counter. Took forever for teenage staff to acknowledge me. Teenage staff took forever to serve me. Other rude teens who were not staff but behind counter started acting inappropriately and wrote on a sticky note on their front door "for a good time call ... (with a phone number)" may not go back due to lack of cleanliness and professionalism. Too much money for such poor service.

Marie Toma

It's such a neat ice cream shop. They make the ice cream right in front of you. I like the fact they have lactose free ice cream! It wasn't as sweet as the ice cream with lactose, but good for me. I spent about $33 for 5 people, so about $ 7 or so bucks per one. We went to the park behind the store to eat. So fun!

DeAndrea Brown

We love this place. Options are plentiful! The staff is always friendly and service is always fast? You get a ton of ice cream. My kiddos never complain of not having enough & they'll actually share because they get so much!

Load More