Benny's Tybee Tavern

1517 Butler Ave, Tybee Island
(912) 786-0121

Recent Reviews

Jerah McDonald

Moose was the best ever!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

McKenna Erickson

New owners. No longer Benny’s. It’s called King Neptune’s now.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Aldana

One of the best night places to enjoy.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Cathy Wright

If we lived here it would be our go to tavern. The staff was awesome, friendly and excelled at their position. And the band Earthtonez was the BEST band we have heard in ages. The variety of music, people

Vicki Wilson

First time here and glad we stopped in! Had a great time. Friendly locals and the staff just as great.

iphonet518

Simple low key joint. Inland from the drink. Tables or sit at the bar … TV was airing NCAA … bowling championship. We atually watched it! Anyway. Service was/is Tybee-friendly locals. Oyster po’ boys out-standing! Cole slaw laced w/ horseradish n garlic! Wow x 3. Texas Pete in the basket . Breaded oysters sweet n crunchy. On our to-repeat list.

Candice C

Looked like a dump when we walked in, but the food was great and nice waitress. Oysters were fabulous and cole slaw was delicious, the shrimp taco was good. Recommend it!

Glider RS

Bar had a good vibe, karaoke station was open and people were very friendly

David Powell

Just a wonderful little place...and the boom boom shrimp is a must try...

Chrissy Mobley

Stopped for a couple drinks. Most of the folks that dropped in were locals, there wasn't anything special going on, no bands, no karaoke or anything, so it was pretty dead.

hkines585

Hunter is a great bar tender. Always attentive to the customers.

speak54

Food was just okay, I would not recommend this dark hole in the wall. I had oysters and they were just okay, go to Sorry Charlies in Savannah for the best Oysters aroundl

william henley

Great place, enjoyable very unique

Sharon Godwin

This place is awesome!! I e never had an issue here any time that I’ve visited! I will see y’all August 21st!!

Michael Hunt

Fun mix of dive and beach bar with drink priced very reasonable!

Load More