Will order the wrangler every time!!!! Also wonderful customer service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub Sandwich
Helen S.
Stopped in Buhl on Sunday evening for a quick bite. Found Papa Kelsey's and was impressed with the menu options. Ordered a Firehouse sub and a French dip with fries. Sat for 39 minutes watching and listening to the young girls discussing their personal lives instead of getting orders out. I finally went up and asked what the issue was with our order and was told they had a lot of phone orders. Fifteen minutes later we get our sandwiches. No Au Jus with the French dip and no fries. Went back to the counter and two girls were still talking about their personal lives. Fries were not done yet. Got them as we finished our sandwiches. The food was good but someone mature needs to be managing this business. Three young girls were more concerned about themselves than their customers.
Debbora Bergeron
Oh my! Size matters ??I ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich. ?Got home, opened the bag, and -Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm ?I could only eat half ? - but now I have another meal ?Atmosphere - it's cute inside. I love the cow art. ?Service - I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.The young lady that took our order rushed us to order. ??The young man brought our 'Togo' order out to us - that was very kind ?The food is worth a return visit.Thank you Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs!Dietary restrictions: I asked for no cheese ?Parking: Easy in and out ?Kid-friendliness: There's room and multiple tables.Wheelchair accessibility: Someone would need to be kind and open the doors for wheelchair access. Plenty of room inside to maneuver ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sub Sandwich
McKayla Porter
amazing owners and amazing food! much love for my first time going, I’ll definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub
Joseph D.
My daughter works for this company and has been given a wage approximating $9 an hour. She works a five hour shift Monday through Thursday and has duties that I would consider managerial. She's a high school student who works hard to maintain excellent grades. For the last two months her biweekly paychecks have been $100 or less. A fact that she has kept from her parents because she's afraid of being fired. I'm beyond angered at this moment. You need to look into how your restaurants and employees are being managed because there is someone who's pulling everything down. I'm paying my daughter to quit and she's pretty torn, this was the first job she's ever had. I'm blasting this on here because I know talking with the manager directly about this will not end well. This is as civil as I can be right now.
Liz Rojas
Delicious ?, I love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Pizza, Italian Combo Sandwich
Kenpo Kid
Really good pizza,perfectly cook crust.Highly recommended for an amazing pizza!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ms Morgan
I love the pizza and the Italian Sub. I recommend you give them a try. Yummiest
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Sub, Italian Combo Sandwich
Jennifer C
Always yummy. We love their sandwiches and pizza. The large sandwich is big enough to feed 2 adults. They cut it into 4 squares. The employees are also very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
randall apgood
This is a great place to eat. We love the steak and everything sandwich. We always get great service. It is very clean every time we go there. Best place in Buhl.
Papa Kelseys never disappoints. We have gone to 4. Always very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roy A.
A while back ordered a Hawaiian pizza.. It was the worst I have ever had.. There was 3 pieces of pinapple and 2 Canadian bacon pieces.. Never been back and will never again... The buhl place..
Jacqueline Sharron
Best pizza in Hagerman! They ever dissapoint ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Tim W.
This is the best place for a sandwich in Buhl. It's easy to miss because it doesn't look like much from the outside! I was surprised to find out they have some breakfast options like a breakfast sandwich, breakfast pizza, breakfast burrito and biscuits and gravy. I tried the bacon, egg sand cheese breakfast sandwich and it was very good. The fresh made bread is a winner. Lots of tables inside to eat your sandwich or pizza. I will definitely go back when I'm town.
Nancy Bailey
The bread on the subs was soggy and the service was very slow. Papa Kelsey's used to be exceptional I don't know what happened.
Will order the wrangler every time!!!! Also wonderful customer service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub Sandwich
Stopped in Buhl on Sunday evening for a quick bite. Found Papa Kelsey's and was impressed with the menu options. Ordered a Firehouse sub and a French dip with fries. Sat for 39 minutes watching and listening to the young girls discussing their personal lives instead of getting orders out. I finally went up and asked what the issue was with our order and was told they had a lot of phone orders. Fifteen minutes later we get our sandwiches. No Au Jus with the French dip and no fries. Went back to the counter and two girls were still talking about their personal lives. Fries were not done yet. Got them as we finished our sandwiches. The food was good but someone mature needs to be managing this business. Three young girls were more concerned about themselves than their customers.
Oh my! Size matters ??I ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich. ?Got home, opened the bag, and -Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm ?I could only eat half ? - but now I have another meal ?Atmosphere - it's cute inside. I love the cow art. ?Service - I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.The young lady that took our order rushed us to order. ??The young man brought our 'Togo' order out to us - that was very kind ?The food is worth a return visit.Thank you Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs!Dietary restrictions: I asked for no cheese ?Parking: Easy in and out ?Kid-friendliness: There's room and multiple tables.Wheelchair accessibility: Someone would need to be kind and open the doors for wheelchair access. Plenty of room inside to maneuver ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sub Sandwich
amazing owners and amazing food! much love for my first time going, I’ll definitely come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub
My daughter works for this company and has been given a wage approximating $9 an hour. She works a five hour shift Monday through Thursday and has duties that I would consider managerial. She's a high school student who works hard to maintain excellent grades. For the last two months her biweekly paychecks have been $100 or less. A fact that she has kept from her parents because she's afraid of being fired. I'm beyond angered at this moment. You need to look into how your restaurants and employees are being managed because there is someone who's pulling everything down. I'm paying my daughter to quit and she's pretty torn, this was the first job she's ever had. I'm blasting this on here because I know talking with the manager directly about this will not end well. This is as civil as I can be right now.
Delicious ?, I love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Pizza, Italian Combo Sandwich
Really good pizza,perfectly cook crust.Highly recommended for an amazing pizza!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
I love the pizza and the Italian Sub. I recommend you give them a try. Yummiest
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Sub, Italian Combo Sandwich
Always yummy. We love their sandwiches and pizza. The large sandwich is big enough to feed 2 adults. They cut it into 4 squares. The employees are also very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a great place to eat. We love the steak and everything sandwich. We always get great service. It is very clean every time we go there. Best place in Buhl.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheese Bread, Sub
Restaurantji Recommends
Papa Kelseys never disappoints. We have gone to 4. Always very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A while back ordered a Hawaiian pizza.. It was the worst I have ever had.. There was 3 pieces of pinapple and 2 Canadian bacon pieces.. Never been back and will never again... The buhl place..
Best pizza in Hagerman! They ever dissapoint ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
This is the best place for a sandwich in Buhl. It's easy to miss because it doesn't look like much from the outside! I was surprised to find out they have some breakfast options like a breakfast sandwich, breakfast pizza, breakfast burrito and biscuits and gravy. I tried the bacon, egg sand cheese breakfast sandwich and it was very good. The fresh made bread is a winner. Lots of tables inside to eat your sandwich or pizza. I will definitely go back when I'm town.
The bread on the subs was soggy and the service was very slow. Papa Kelsey's used to be exceptional I don't know what happened.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3