I've got a teen, so if course he loves coming here and playing the retro video arcade games for free, and I've always liked their burgers. But I recently had they're fried chicken there and BAM!, as they say. It was REALLY good! So I already had them at 5 stars, but they still went up in my book.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brianna Harte
We frequently come to Replay for their Tuesday night BYOBeans Drag Loteria. The drinks are delicious and good quality food. All the staff is friendly and attentive. Super unique and fun night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
John S.
I like Replay, but some of the prices are out of control. Roughly $23 (pre-tip) for a Manhattan? Maybe understandable if this was top shelf liquor, but a bottle of Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon is currently $31.99 at Binny's.
Lace
I went on a date and we enjoyed ourselves. Nice Bartender and host. Some of the games were broken but the games are free soooo...it's all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Rodriguez
The food and drinks here was so delicious. The ceasar salad was a big portion size, and I liked that they massaged the dressing into the salad so it was evenly spread. The arcade area is small, but they have fun games! Great for a date night, and service was friendly.Vegetarian options: They have salads and veggie burger available.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lena Flavin
I just ate my Thanksgiving dinner from Replay. The menu on line sounded great, well, it was not great. The turkey was not roasted breast as you’d think, it was formed, pressed turkey breast. No Cranberry orange sauce, no green bean mushroom casserole. It was plain green beans. It was edible, but disappointing. Former chef here.
Food: 2
Julia G.
Great sports bar. Their Cuban sandwich reminds me of having one in Miami. Great place to watch games and have drinks
Ari Avi
Just stopped in Monday for a quick bite! Blake was friendly and attentive, I had the chicken tenders which I highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rose Wine
Dani Delonge
Food was okay. I got the burger and it was really salty. Cheese curds were good tho although, $12 for that small of a portion is a little crazy. They give you like 12 cheese curds, sad they had no marinara for them, only ranch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Elizabeth G.
Halloween night a friend and I decided to choose Replay for a quick bite to eat before a show. We had a server named Sam who was out of this world. Sam was by far one of the most personable, kind and attentive servers I've had at Replay, and dare I say, one of the best service experiences I've had while dining in Andersonville. Thank you Sam, for making my night one to remember.
Went here for a quick bite and some drinks, and it was great! The drinks are delicious, the staff is friendly, and the tater tots and chicken fingers are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I've never gone on a super crowded night, but it does get busy! Lots of fun events and activities to do!
Jeffrey Gavin
They have downsized their tap beer to 11 oz. but charge pint prices. A little insulting.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Chris MacGregor
Great food. Reuben needed more sauce but that’s me being picky. Excellent draft list with lots of local seasonal selections. Servers are super chill and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sherry S.
Decent bar food. The chicken was good n the different sauces. The cheese curds and French firs were limp and greasy. The rose' cider was good. The service was relaxed by very good. Every we had contact with that worked there were very pleasant. Sports on television for my spouse, old time pinball machines for me. It was great.
Nathan P.
Unfortunately, my experience at Replay in Andersonville was less than stellar. I cannot speak to the food quality as our experience was cut short before we could even be served. Our first interaction was with the bouncer, who was dismissive and unnecessarily brusque. While I understand that establishments may have policies about bringing in outside beverages, how we were told to step outside with our coffee was off-putting. A simple, polite request would have sufficed and might have even prompted us to purchase a beverage from their menu. Instead, the interaction left a sour taste and led us to cut our visit short. While I hope others have had better experiences, I'm reluctant to return or recommend Replay to friends based on this initial interaction. Service and first impressions matter; unfortunately, they missed the mark during our visit.
I've got a teen, so if course he loves coming here and playing the retro video arcade games for free, and I've always liked their burgers. But I recently had they're fried chicken there and BAM!, as they say. It was REALLY good! So I already had them at 5 stars, but they still went up in my book.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We frequently come to Replay for their Tuesday night BYOBeans Drag Loteria. The drinks are delicious and good quality food. All the staff is friendly and attentive. Super unique and fun night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots
I like Replay, but some of the prices are out of control. Roughly $23 (pre-tip) for a Manhattan? Maybe understandable if this was top shelf liquor, but a bottle of Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon is currently $31.99 at Binny's.
I went on a date and we enjoyed ourselves. Nice Bartender and host. Some of the games were broken but the games are free soooo...it's all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The food and drinks here was so delicious. The ceasar salad was a big portion size, and I liked that they massaged the dressing into the salad so it was evenly spread. The arcade area is small, but they have fun games! Great for a date night, and service was friendly.Vegetarian options: They have salads and veggie burger available.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just ate my Thanksgiving dinner from Replay. The menu on line sounded great, well, it was not great. The turkey was not roasted breast as you’d think, it was formed, pressed turkey breast. No Cranberry orange sauce, no green bean mushroom casserole. It was plain green beans. It was edible, but disappointing. Former chef here.
Food: 2
Great sports bar. Their Cuban sandwich reminds me of having one in Miami. Great place to watch games and have drinks
Just stopped in Monday for a quick bite! Blake was friendly and attentive, I had the chicken tenders which I highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rose Wine
Food was okay. I got the burger and it was really salty. Cheese curds were good tho although, $12 for that small of a portion is a little crazy. They give you like 12 cheese curds, sad they had no marinara for them, only ranch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Halloween night a friend and I decided to choose Replay for a quick bite to eat before a show. We had a server named Sam who was out of this world. Sam was by far one of the most personable, kind and attentive servers I've had at Replay, and dare I say, one of the best service experiences I've had while dining in Andersonville. Thank you Sam, for making my night one to remember.
Restaurantji Recommends
Went here for a quick bite and some drinks, and it was great! The drinks are delicious, the staff is friendly, and the tater tots and chicken fingers are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I've never gone on a super crowded night, but it does get busy! Lots of fun events and activities to do!
They have downsized their tap beer to 11 oz. but charge pint prices. A little insulting.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great food. Reuben needed more sauce but that’s me being picky. Excellent draft list with lots of local seasonal selections. Servers are super chill and helpful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent bar food. The chicken was good n the different sauces. The cheese curds and French firs were limp and greasy. The rose' cider was good. The service was relaxed by very good. Every we had contact with that worked there were very pleasant. Sports on television for my spouse, old time pinball machines for me. It was great.
Unfortunately, my experience at Replay in Andersonville was less than stellar. I cannot speak to the food quality as our experience was cut short before we could even be served. Our first interaction was with the bouncer, who was dismissive and unnecessarily brusque. While I understand that establishments may have policies about bringing in outside beverages, how we were told to step outside with our coffee was off-putting. A simple, polite request would have sufficed and might have even prompted us to purchase a beverage from their menu. Instead, the interaction left a sour taste and led us to cut our visit short. While I hope others have had better experiences, I'm reluctant to return or recommend Replay to friends based on this initial interaction. Service and first impressions matter; unfortunately, they missed the mark during our visit.