Tarnished Hollow Brewing Co.

412 N Anderson St, Elwood

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katie Nakanishi

I love discovering a brewery off the beaten path. Driving through Elwood a flag proclaiming "Brewery" caught my attention and the neon "Open" sign drew us in...as well as the promise of a cold draught beer.

This small brewery in a renovated house offers a nicely varied tap list and a cozy small town brewery feel. My husband had a flight and particularly enjoyed their peanut butter porter as well as the Crackerjack cream ale which had the aroma of popcorn, a slight aftertaste of caramel and still tasted like beer! I enjoyed their hazy IPA "Wish that I had Juicy's Girl".

The interior is small but inviting and our bartender, the owner, was friendly and happy to chat about their beer. The atmosphere was very friendly and laid back, which is exactly what we love in any brewery.
I would highly recommend stopping in for a pint or a flight if you're in the area or anywhere nearby.

Wanted to make an honorable mention of the decor, which is a great mix of Midwest themed food artwork and cerebral gothic touches. I especially enjoyed the purple velvet couch, ink blot artwork printed on vintage dictionary pages, and skull wallpaper in the bathroom that is illuminated by the neon sign.

All in all, this spot is a gem of eclectic beer and atmosphere!

Holly Garrett

I met the owner/brewer at a festival two years ago... latched onto his vision - he's community minded and produces fantastic product!

Katelynn Schiffner

What a great place! The Captain Crunch drink is a must try. Live music and a food truck really made the night special! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Craig Owens

Great little brewery to visit!

Troy Spiker

Great beer

Brogan Baxter

Awesome place; excellent beers

corey schneider

Great beers. Great atmosphere. Awesome owner. Always a good time. Food truck options always solid. A Must visit

trenton finley

The finest establishment in Elwood to relieve oneself. The bathroom is so majestic that it reaches out to your soul to visit it. The brews were great as well.

Edux9903

Delicious unique beers and awesome chill vibes

Samuel Dumas

Great beer. I really like the decor. You have got to use the bathroom here.

Matt M.

Great beer, better people. Easily worth the drive up from Indy

Loading...

Tarnished Hollow Brewing Co.

412 N Anderson St, Elwood, IN 46036