OP Italian

10 S West St, Indianapolis
(317) 860-5777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Selina Lemay

Couldn't find the entrance, took about 45 minutes to find out its closed for construction...

Shane

Fish and chips were overcooked. The breading was dark brown and the fish was falling apart.

Jim

We were very disappointed. The restaurant presented itself online as being an "Italian" restaurant, which it was not at all. Food was good, but not much selection and clearly over-priced. Don't recommend this place at all!

Kim

Service was horrible we were there almost an hour before we even got a cup of coffee we had asked several times about drinks and our meal the food was good when we finally got it. It was not busy at all so I'm not sure what the problem was the manager said the waiter was new but if he's that new he can't even get drinks out someone should be helping him. Just an overall bad experience. Even though the food was good we will not go back

Dave

We went to OP thinking it was still the high-end Italian restaurant we visited several years ago. It's not really an Italian restaurant, but a bar/pub atmosphere with a limited menu. Fairly good wine list, although they were out of 2/3 Chards they listed. Service was fair. Very loud throughout the restaurant. Food OK, but not stellar. Probably won't be back but perhaps great for the downtown bar scene folks.

Pat Younger

(September 28-30, 2024) We ate there on three different occasions, both getting different entree’s. Everything was wonderful! They use high-quality, fresh ingredients. The food arrives quickly and at just the right temperature. The servings are ample. The wait staff is phenomenal and make you feel as though you’re the only customers in the room. The menu is small and limited but all dishes are done to absolute perfection and they encourage and allow changes or additions/deletions to their offerings. Pricing is right in line for the quality and quantity of food. Best pizza I’ve ever had, club sandwich is huge and packed with meat and cheeses. If I lived in Indianapolis, I would come here to eat frequently.

Wheelchair accessibility: Located on the lobby floor and easily accessible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chocolate Cake, Caesar Salad

Dawn

NOT Italian. It's bar food. Nothing inspiring or unique. Management needs to make immediate brand and marketing changes so customers aren't misled into thinking they're going to an Italian restaurant. No blame on the staff, this is all on Marriott. But you are definitely setting your restaurant people up for failure. What a let down. And overpriced entrees on top of it. We expected more from a Marriott Bonvoy hotel although we've learned that hotels don't really put much thought or effort into their restaurants. Maybe that's why their employees seem less than happy to be there.

Staci

Alan, our waiter, was amazing and really helped us select the best entrees. Our steaks were perfect. The band in the bar set a great old supper club vibe. It's not cheap, but worth the splurge.

Lisa

We went here because of close proximity to our event. This was our first visit. The food was marginal. I sent my soup back twice because it was cold and the biscuit that was supposed to be with it did not come back. I was then told they were out. My husband had to wait a while for the chicken that was supposed to be on his salad. Lastly, our friend's meal was cold, had to be sent back and then didn't come out for a long time. Not sure we will go back.

Nathan P

This is the worst place we ate at on our trip. The wings were cold, and the cheese on the nachos wasn't melted. Two of our group got the rigatoni, one dish had twice as much food as the other. The manager did come by and took our feedback. Eat here if you are in a rush or have no better options. Definitely expected better from a restaurant in the Marriot.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Kelly

The food, drinks, ambience, and service were all amazing!! And on top of that, I had a small medical emergency (blood pressure drop) and the manager and staff immediately came to my assistance to make sure I was okay. They even offered a free brownie to help me get better. I’m very grateful. I also love that the restaurant is connected to the JW Marriott hotel as I’m staying here for a conference so I was able to just go upstairs to room to rest.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steve Hines

Staying at the Marriott where this restaurant is located and opted for breakfast here instead of going out. Had the yogurt and granola, mixed fruit and muffin and a side of turkey sausage. Would definitely return. Also had lunch here the prior day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

eswar prabhath

Brownie here is one of the best I ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly

The food, drinks, ambience, and service were all amazing!! And on top of that, I had a small medical emergency (blood pressure drop) and the manager and staff immediately came to my help to make sure I was okay. They even offered a free brownie to help me get better. I'm very grateful. I also love that the restaurant is connected to the JW Marriott hotel as I'm staying here for a conference so I was able to just go upstairs to room to rest.

N

Wine ordered when we sat down came out after meals arrived. Side of fries was delayed. Food was just ok. Nothing special.

Loading...