Scartozzi's Trattoria

822 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City
(219) 878-0458

Recent Reviews

Caitlyn Caldwell

Stuffed shells are absolutely amazing! Customer service was great!!!

Jailynn Meier

Great quality, friendly fast service.Love how fresh and authentic the food is here.Quite affordable for the high quality, and always tasty! Go to take out place from now on :)

Luke P

Love their Italian beef with cheese and hot peppers! The meatball sandwich is excellent as well.

Richard OBrien

Authentic & a great bang for your buck

Amber Faulkner

I’ve been eating here for yrs.. always great tasting and good quality food

Lacy Shuck

This place is a must visit for us each time we are in the area. The staff is very friendly, helpful, and welcoming and the food is top notch. We LOVE the mussels! Try it!

Jennifer B

Great spot for an affordable family-style Italian dinner! Check their website if you aren't familiar with a trattoria... it's not super fancy Italian fare but it is family friendly, and delicious! If staying at 4411 hotel this is really close by. Everything we had was great and packaged neatly for our to-go orders. Really liked Jo's Special: angel hair with veggies (long fresh green beans, baby carrots, broccoli, corn) and chunks of seasoned chicken breast in a light cream sauce. Plenty of veg in this dish, which is refreshing because a lot of places advertise a vegetable pasta but you end up with a disappointing 3 stems of broccoli. No worries here! Would have taken pics but honestly I ordered it two nights in a row and scarfed it down both times it was so tasty. My toddler loved the rigatoni bolognese. Orders came with a soft and tasty buttery rosemary bread. Give them a try and I'll be sure to return next time I pass thru Michigan City.

Sara Bauer

Amazing!!! They made food for our wedding and everyone loved it! Highly recommend! Delicious!

Robert Stark

Very nice, great food

Aug H

I really love the food. The fettuccine alfredo with chicken was outstanding. I also ordered ravioli but was a bit disappointed when I found 6-8 of them in the take out cartoon for $9.95. Nonetheless, I'll be back but will be ordering noodles going forward.

John Jackson

Thank you Scartozzi’s for my families Friday night Dinner. My grandpa “Denny” (regular of the establishment) the kitchen staff and owner went above and beyond tonight. Denny called and told them he needed 5 Italian Beefs in to go containers. They had the Italian beef in a separate pan, the cheese separated, the bread separated and Au juice ready right away at 5 pm sharp. Came home put the bread on a tray added the cheese and added the meats! Very reasonable pricing! My family had to wait an hour or so for me to arrive home since we reside in Plymouth. It was the best Italian beef we have ever had even better than my homemade! I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a new place to eat lunch, or dinner!


From a small pick up order for 4, to a catered event for 30, Scartozzi's has never failed to serve up absolutely delicious food, for an extremely reasonable price. We are so proud to offer Scartozzi's deliciousness to guests - knowing we can depend on them to dish up amazing food!! (So so good!!) Highly recommend!!

Keith Evans

This place is simply the best family-owned trattoria I've been in in the United States. We had an awesome lunch on the picnic table outside with our dog. They brought the food out to us and the service and the food were both 5 star!

Susan Zimnawoda

Love this place. Was very grateful to a man ,,//chef who worked us in to fill our order quicker. This place was packed for orders,. Thank you sir. And the eggplant parmesan. Was excellent. We sat outside since they don't have indoor seating bit. That was ok. Beautiful weather


Ordered catering for a party. Great food and super friendly service!

Load More