food was delicious service was excellent ambiance was great We was celebrating our 50th Anniversary and our daughter and son-in-law was just married a couple of days before. We was just having a nice dinner after all the celebrating with family. it was fabulous.
Jeremy Hankins
I’ve been here twice now for dinner and it is awesome! I haven’t been to Italy, but this seems like a very authentic Italian experience. The service has been great both times, the food is amazing and the ambience is superb. I highly recommend going to Matteo’s for a lovely Italian meal. They also have live music on Wednesdays! We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
peggy
Quaint, almost Godfather like atmosphere, which was enjoyable for a small town Italian restaurant. For an appetizer, we ordered Fritto Misto Italiano. Taste was excellent but it was overcooked. The ravioli was hard and crunchy. The sauce was served a bit on the skimpy side as well. Both our meals came out lukewarm almost as if they were reheated and served. The lasagna was extremely salty and I don't think there was any cheese in it. Sauce was poured over the top, which I prefer some of it to be baked into it for a juicier lasagna. It was extremely dry. My partner ordered the Apollo Amore, which he said was delicious and he would order again. He is a wine connoisseur and could tell he was not served what was ordered. Service was a little slow but I'm guessing they may have been down a server, so understandable. The bread and oil served was nothing special. This was great for us because we refrained from eating it then. Allowed us to save on a lot of unnecessary calories. HA!
Thomas G.
Excellent menu and presentation. Busy place, so you must have a reservation. Reasonable wines.
Lance
My girlfriend and I love this place - we've gotten to know the staff and owners over the years, and they've gotten to know us. Each time we visit, it's like visiting family - everyone's genuinely personable and it's always great "catching up". The food and service are terrific, and it's great to have a nice, classy place in Noblesville (just 10 minutes from our home), rather than having to drive 40 minutes to downtown Indy for a similar (and pricier) experience. We've got great respect for this establishminet and the entire team. When COVID-19 closed down their in-door business in the winter of 2020, they doubled down on providing takeout orders, and when the weather got nicer, they took advantage of the alley behind their business, cleaned it up, and provided outdoor dining on a large scale. Have I mentioned we love this place? Enjoy!
Kevin Aldin
Jordan was very attentive, food was piping hot and fresh. A great ambiance, enjoyed very much!
David Farber
What a disappointing experience. While food was just ok, the service was sorely lacking. I’m not sure if they were short-staffed, but even when our waitress showed up, she didn’t seem like she wanted to be there. We won’t be going back. Time to find another Italian restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Alex Suarez
The best Italian restaurant in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CReed
Matteo's is excellent. We had a wonderful server who met our every need. She was kind, helpful and made our experience lovely. The food was amazing from the bread to the chopped salad and our main course, the tortellini. The music wasn't too loud and the tables are far enough apart that we could have good conversation without yelling or feeling like we were imposing on our neighbors. We made reservations so we were seated as soon as we walked in. Loved everything about our dinner at Matteo's.
William Kerr
Everything was great. Best veal parmingana I have ever had. A bit pricey, but everything was perfect.
My wife and I LOVE Matteo's ! We have NEVER had a bad experience or meal there. When we try other Italian restaurants, we believe that they never compare. And we always come running back to Matteo's. And we love how the owners are always there to greet the guests and to help the staff!
Rocco D.
The food, service, and Ambiance week all excellent. I highly recommend Matteo's. I paired the pistachio martini with the pistachio pasta and it was out of this world. Our waiter was perfect and very knowledgeable about the menu.
melanier
Wonderful authentic Italian cuisine. Our server was very attentive and always knew what we needed before we even asked. Wonderful place for an intimate dinner with friends or family.
food was delicious service was excellent ambiance was great We was celebrating our 50th Anniversary and our daughter and son-in-law was just married a couple of days before. We was just having a nice dinner after all the celebrating with family. it was fabulous.
I’ve been here twice now for dinner and it is awesome! I haven’t been to Italy, but this seems like a very authentic Italian experience. The service has been great both times, the food is amazing and the ambience is superb. I highly recommend going to Matteo’s for a lovely Italian meal. They also have live music on Wednesdays! We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quaint, almost Godfather like atmosphere, which was enjoyable for a small town Italian restaurant. For an appetizer, we ordered Fritto Misto Italiano. Taste was excellent but it was overcooked. The ravioli was hard and crunchy. The sauce was served a bit on the skimpy side as well. Both our meals came out lukewarm almost as if they were reheated and served. The lasagna was extremely salty and I don't think there was any cheese in it. Sauce was poured over the top, which I prefer some of it to be baked into it for a juicier lasagna. It was extremely dry. My partner ordered the Apollo Amore, which he said was delicious and he would order again. He is a wine connoisseur and could tell he was not served what was ordered. Service was a little slow but I'm guessing they may have been down a server, so understandable. The bread and oil served was nothing special. This was great for us because we refrained from eating it then. Allowed us to save on a lot of unnecessary calories. HA!
Excellent menu and presentation. Busy place, so you must have a reservation. Reasonable wines.
My girlfriend and I love this place - we've gotten to know the staff and owners over the years, and they've gotten to know us. Each time we visit, it's like visiting family - everyone's genuinely personable and it's always great "catching up". The food and service are terrific, and it's great to have a nice, classy place in Noblesville (just 10 minutes from our home), rather than having to drive 40 minutes to downtown Indy for a similar (and pricier) experience. We've got great respect for this establishminet and the entire team. When COVID-19 closed down their in-door business in the winter of 2020, they doubled down on providing takeout orders, and when the weather got nicer, they took advantage of the alley behind their business, cleaned it up, and provided outdoor dining on a large scale. Have I mentioned we love this place? Enjoy!
Jordan was very attentive, food was piping hot and fresh. A great ambiance, enjoyed very much!
What a disappointing experience. While food was just ok, the service was sorely lacking. I’m not sure if they were short-staffed, but even when our waitress showed up, she didn’t seem like she wanted to be there. We won’t be going back. Time to find another Italian restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
The best Italian restaurant in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matteo's is excellent. We had a wonderful server who met our every need. She was kind, helpful and made our experience lovely. The food was amazing from the bread to the chopped salad and our main course, the tortellini. The music wasn't too loud and the tables are far enough apart that we could have good conversation without yelling or feeling like we were imposing on our neighbors. We made reservations so we were seated as soon as we walked in. Loved everything about our dinner at Matteo's.
Everything was great. Best veal parmingana I have ever had. A bit pricey, but everything was perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan
Restaurantji Recommends
Enjoyed our food. Service was great. My only suggestion would be for some music to be playing while dining. We will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Lasagne, Chicken Parmesan
Great dinner. Very good creme
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I LOVE Matteo's ! We have NEVER had a bad experience or meal there. When we try other Italian restaurants, we believe that they never compare. And we always come running back to Matteo's. And we love how the owners are always there to greet the guests and to help the staff!
The food, service, and Ambiance week all excellent. I highly recommend Matteo's. I paired the pistachio martini with the pistachio pasta and it was out of this world. Our waiter was perfect and very knowledgeable about the menu.
Wonderful authentic Italian cuisine. Our server was very attentive and always knew what we needed before we even asked. Wonderful place for an intimate dinner with friends or family.