Cold Stone Creamery

71 Silhavy Rd Ste 161, Valparaiso
(219) 476-3430

Recent Reviews

maddie

I wanted cookies and cream and they don’t even have that like how are u gonna be an ice cream place and not have one of the most basic ice cream flavors…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Johanna Myers

Picked up my order over heard one of the workers explain her reason why she didn't put the order in the freezer (not knowing it was mine) because she didn't feel like it. So I asked if I needed to come in instead of ordering online so I don't have melted ice cream.

Christopher Nablo

Very artificial tasting and no seating in restaurant.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

Donna Aubrey

Everybody was very friendly. Always great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Doughn't You Want Some, Peanut Butter Cup Perfection

Tami Johnson White

Great service on a snowy evening. Always great ice-cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Fudge Brownie and Chocolate Chocolate Chip in a Chocolate Dipped Waffle Cup, Create Your Own Creation

Alaina O.

I don't come here often but when I do, I have nothing but bad experiences with the staff. Today I walked in wanting chocolate ice cream, but saw that they didn't have it. There was a girl doing something at the counter and when she turned around I was in the middle of asking her politely if they had any more, and she slammed it into the freezer and gave me the nastiest look, and then completely ignored my question. When we ordered what we wanted, we got eye rolls as if we did something wrong. We were nothing but nice, but will no longer be coming back! Great ice cream but terrible customer service.

Angela Sheeler

This place was just okay! The customer service was great but in my opinion the ice cream was extremely overpriced. I think I paid close to ten dollars for a single scoop of ice cream in a waffle bowl. It was a clean place and overall friendly!

katie filipas

Where was my song?! I gave a tip expecting to be serenaded like I was in pitch perfect. Highly disappointed. So sad. Maybe next time. ????

Amanda Myers

Definitely my favorite Cold Stone store. The ice cream and waffle cones are always fresh. The ice cream is absolutely delicious. The service is always good.

Sara Frey

It was pretty busy for Mother's Day but the girls worked together and got us out fairly fast!!! Plus it was delicious ?

Susan Lesio

Good ice cream and happy staff. Nice visit.

Bonnie Paciga

It's ok ! Not one of my favorite ice creams to me it's to sweet! Service was good!

Jojo HARD WICK

They gave us 3 of the wrong apples 28 dollars. Noticed soon as we walked out and went back in immediately. Owner Russ said yes those are wrong apples. Sorry. Give me ur debit card and ill refund it ...ok no problem. He proceeded to write down all my card numbers and security codes and wouldn't give me a receipt or anything. I left and was like no this doesn't feel right. I walked back in told him I didn't feel comfortable..I wanted the paper back...I got the "mam" proper business nice nasty attitude and told that I could come back in 30 minutes when the manager got there to do the refund or I could just eat it . Im like sor you ARE THE OWNER just give me the cash back or do the refund ...he told me sorry n walked off. WOW

Corrina Anderson

Fantastic ice cream the reason for the for star is because the employees working in the back weren’t helping the poor guy up front and he was slammed . The two ladies in the back were farting around in the back

Gina Colburn

Love the ice cream! But their hours have been all over the place the last couple years. I was there this past Monday thinking they would be open until 9 and there’s a sign on the door saying due to being short staffed they’re closing at 8. It was 5:55 PM and their doors were locked. I drive 30 minutes to get ice cream and I’ve had a handful of times where they close before they are supposed to or change their hours. This does not make my kids happy, which makes me unhappy. Thankfully Chick-fil-A is right next door now, so they are going to for milkshakes.

Load More