The bakery manager Chelsea O. is just the most RANCID DISGUSTING HUMAN in Lexington.If you know her- you know her carnally or your ex does, or you husband does, or boyfriend does, or your brother does, or your dishwasher at Logan's does, or the homeless guy on the street "knows her- knows her". Literally, any man or woman that knows her- KNOWS HER
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Beth Clay
Stopped in n for the first time this afternoon. Butterscotch cheese cake…I think it was the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. I’m not even that crazy about butterscotch but the way he described it, I had to try it. No Regrets! We also tried the pecan and chocolate Creme pies. Excellent! Well worth the trip and the money. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doram-Seger T.
Hello do you have a fresh Butterscotch pie available? Yes we do , I purchased it took it home to serve for after dinner. Pie was tasteless, filing was a paste consistency. I could not serve this pie to anyone. I contacted Missys , information given, offered to return the pie. They said no need our office will reach out to you. It's been a month, that did not happen . Now i know it's about the money and quantity and not about the customer or quality.
Brian Nelson
Real eyes realize real pies. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peanut Butter Pie
L.I.T Long Island Tedium
If you're gonna change your hours from 8-5 change the giant sign that's been there my entire life that day 8-8. Have gone here late for years and this is the 3rd time this has messed me
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Aaron C.
Walking into this little store front you get the sensation that you'll be eating a damn good pie. It's all hustle and bustle, early morning prepping to stock their shelves and store orders. Great selections await you, cream, fruit, brownie, and cheesecakes. I ordered two slices and they happily finished my pie before slicing it. Can't get much fresher than that!!! Black bottom banana cream is a fabulous choice. Everything about it is perfectly balanced! Crust is homemade and can be tasted in every bite. Wish I lived closer so I could enjoy every pie option they serve.
Jessica B.
Buy all my holiday pies from here.. The banana creme pie is the best!!! May day make it to all my holidays!!
Kesha Richardson
I just picked up my pie for Thursday. I pray for continued blessing for the owner and the ABSOLUTE BEST pie "house" EVER. For all you do...THANK YOU. Oh yeah, and the butterscotch pie to so worth the extra pound!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erica Sardar
It’s not Thanksgiving in Lexington without a pie from Missy‘s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Logan M.
I had the pleasure of trying the peanut butter pie at Missy's Pie in Lexington, Kentucky, and it was absolutely delectable! The flavor was outstanding, and it's a must-try for any dessert lover. However, I was a bit disappointed when I visited as the outdoor furniture was chained up, which wasn't very appealing. Despite this, the pie made the visit worthwhile. Don't miss the chance to satisfy your sweet tooth at Missy's Pie!
Got the caramel apple pie of the month for a birthday pie. DELICOUS! Great service, tasty deserts, nothing else matters!
Liz M.
Stumbled on Missy's pies while shopping in downtown Lexington and got a piece of the pear-blueberry crumble pie and the mayday pie. Both were amazing! The pear-blueberry reminded me of my grandmother's pear pie. I ended up going back 2 days later and taking 2 whole pies back to Nashville with me!
Sandra Dunahoo
Lexington’s all time favorite pie shop. Delightful crust, fluffy peaks of meringue but the actual pie filling is a little thinner than earlier versions of Missy’s. Still, a tasty offering but the old version was a 10+
Luke B.
YES! Their food is F****** YUMMY. Mmmmmmmm! Like damn! Coconut pie was making me lick my lips! Lady serving me was a total cutie too!
The bakery manager Chelsea O. is just the most RANCID DISGUSTING HUMAN in Lexington.If you know her- you know her carnally or your ex does, or you husband does, or boyfriend does, or your brother does, or your dishwasher at Logan's does, or the homeless guy on the street "knows her- knows her". Literally, any man or woman that knows her- KNOWS HER
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Stopped in n for the first time this afternoon. Butterscotch cheese cake…I think it was the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. I’m not even that crazy about butterscotch but the way he described it, I had to try it. No Regrets! We also tried the pecan and chocolate Creme pies. Excellent! Well worth the trip and the money. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hello do you have a fresh Butterscotch pie available? Yes we do , I purchased it took it home to serve for after dinner. Pie was tasteless, filing was a paste consistency. I could not serve this pie to anyone. I contacted Missys , information given, offered to return the pie. They said no need our office will reach out to you. It's been a month, that did not happen . Now i know it's about the money and quantity and not about the customer or quality.
Real eyes realize real pies. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peanut Butter Pie
If you're gonna change your hours from 8-5 change the giant sign that's been there my entire life that day 8-8. Have gone here late for years and this is the 3rd time this has messed me
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Walking into this little store front you get the sensation that you'll be eating a damn good pie. It's all hustle and bustle, early morning prepping to stock their shelves and store orders. Great selections await you, cream, fruit, brownie, and cheesecakes. I ordered two slices and they happily finished my pie before slicing it. Can't get much fresher than that!!! Black bottom banana cream is a fabulous choice. Everything about it is perfectly balanced! Crust is homemade and can be tasted in every bite. Wish I lived closer so I could enjoy every pie option they serve.
Buy all my holiday pies from here.. The banana creme pie is the best!!! May day make it to all my holidays!!
I just picked up my pie for Thursday. I pray for continued blessing for the owner and the ABSOLUTE BEST pie "house" EVER. For all you do...THANK YOU. Oh yeah, and the butterscotch pie to so worth the extra pound!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s not Thanksgiving in Lexington without a pie from Missy‘s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the pleasure of trying the peanut butter pie at Missy's Pie in Lexington, Kentucky, and it was absolutely delectable! The flavor was outstanding, and it's a must-try for any dessert lover. However, I was a bit disappointed when I visited as the outdoor furniture was chained up, which wasn't very appealing. Despite this, the pie made the visit worthwhile. Don't miss the chance to satisfy your sweet tooth at Missy's Pie!
Restaurantji Recommends
Got the caramel apple pie of the month for a birthday pie. DELICOUS! Great service, tasty deserts, nothing else matters!
Stumbled on Missy's pies while shopping in downtown Lexington and got a piece of the pear-blueberry crumble pie and the mayday pie. Both were amazing! The pear-blueberry reminded me of my grandmother's pear pie. I ended up going back 2 days later and taking 2 whole pies back to Nashville with me!
Lexington’s all time favorite pie shop. Delightful crust, fluffy peaks of meringue but the actual pie filling is a little thinner than earlier versions of Missy’s. Still, a tasty offering but the old version was a 10+
YES! Their food is F****** YUMMY. Mmmmmmmm! Like damn! Coconut pie was making me lick my lips! Lady serving me was a total cutie too!
Delicious cherry pie... but $30??