OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

55 Boylston St Suite 5578, Chestnut Hill
(617) 505-6446

Recent Reviews Order Online

Featured items
Peanut Butter S'mores
Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate chips, and marshmallow. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, PEANUT, GLUTEN)
Miso Cherry
White miso butterscotch base with sour cherries. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, SOY)
DIY Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
Chewy chocolate chip cookies with your choice of ice cream in the middle (a kid's-sized scoop), rolled in your choice of crunchy topping! Note: cookies are made at a separate facility and may contain traces of peanuts/tree nuts. Contains gluten/dairy.
Cookies and Cream
Sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS, DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)
Sweet Cream and Sprinkles
Sweet cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)
Coffee Crunch
Coffee ice cream with our house made coffee soil (micro grated coffee beans, butter, sugar, salt, almond flour, flour, and coco powder) (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN, ALMOND)
Dark Chocolate Chunk (Dairy)
Dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
Sorbet with mango, guava, passionfruit, and banana
Dark Chocolate Chunk (Vegan)
Dark chocolate cashew milk ice cream with chocolate chunks. (ALLERGENS: CASHEW)
Strawberry Jam
Strawberry sweet cream base with ribbons of Oregon strawberry jam. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY)
Cookies and Mint
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)
Vanilla Bean
Sweet cream vanilla base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)

Tubs
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
Sorbet with mango, guava, passionfruit, and banana
Miso Cherry
White miso butterscotch base with sour cherries. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, SOY)
Peanut Butter S'mores
Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate chips, and marshmallow. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, PEANUT, GLUTEN)
Cookies and Cream
Sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS, DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)
Coffee Crunch
Coffee ice cream with our house made coffee soil (micro grated coffee beans, butter, sugar, salt, almond flour, flour, and coco powder) (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN, ALMOND)
Sweet Cream and Sprinkles
Sweet cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)
Dark Chocolate Chunk (Dairy)
Dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)
Strawberry Jam
Strawberry sweet cream base with ribbons of Oregon strawberry jam. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY)
Cookies and Mint
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)
Dark Chocolate Chunk (Vegan)
Dark chocolate cashew milk ice cream with chocolate chunks. (ALLERGENS: CASHEW)
Vanilla Bean
Sweet cream vanilla base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)
Saffron Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
Saffron passionfruit base with pieces of candied apricots, and pistachio. ALLERGENS (DAIRY, EGG, PISTACHIO)
Carrot Cake Cream Cheese
cream cheese base with chunks of housemade carrot cake

Ice Cream Sandwiches
DIY Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
Chewy chocolate chip cookies with your choice of ice cream in the middle (a kid's-sized scoop), rolled in your choice of crunchy topping! Note: cookies are made at a separate facility and may contain traces of peanuts/tree nuts. Contains gluten/dairy.

Ice Cream Cakes
Peanut Butter S'mores Cake
10" ice cream cake made with our peanut butter s'mores ice cream and finished with chocolate cookie crumble, chocolate fudge frosting and marshmallows.
Sprinkles Cake
10" ice cream cake made with our Sweet Cream & Sprinkles ice cream and finished with chocolate cookie crust, chocolate fudge frosting and whipped cream. Contains: dairy, gluten, eggs.

Milkshakes
Milkshake (16oz)
16oz blended milkshake made using your choice of ice cream flavor(s) and milk. Check out our "tubs" menu for allergens on particular flavors.

Party Packs
OddFellows DIY Pack
Choose as many tubs as you like, and round out your party pack with any of our toppings to complement them! Priced accordingly by item.

Extras
Soda
Different soda varieties

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: ubereats
+24 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+23 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I know about OddFellows Ice Cream. I have been eating their ice cream since about 5 months after they opened their first store in Brooklyn. I don't get back there any more it seems, so I was overjoyed to find them here in Chestnut Hill during my vacation trip. I had the Raspberry Rosé Cider, which is "ice cream infused with Aval’s Rosé Cider, complete with a sweet and tangy raspberry jam swirl". That sound really good, doesn't it? It exceeded my expectations.My...
June 2023
Very nice place, convenient location at a mall with a free parking lot. Pleasant interiors, clean restrooms. Good service, pretty good variety of ice cream flavors.They allow sampling, using metal spoons that are washed, that's much better than disposable.Only 4 starts because the prices are high ($7.40 for one scoop and a cone), and because other reviews mentioned some ingredients that are not so natural and healthy.
March 2023
The server was great. I got a mixed cup - chocolate soft serve, which was delicious, and mint ice cream which deducts 1/2 star(though I cant post a 4.5 so I gave it a 5 to be generous for the great service)... couldn't put my finger on it, but next time, I'll get all chocolate soft serve for a TRULY 5 star experience. I will definitely be back ...the serving size was VERY generous, and I loved the soft serve.
March 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Legal Sea Foods - Chestnut Hill - 55 Boylston St
Seafood, Bar, Gluten-Free
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery - 49 Boylston St
Bakery
Shake Shack Chestnut Hill - 49 Boylston St #4900
Hamburger, Burgers, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, American, Fast Food

OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

55 Boylston St Suite 5578, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467
(617) 505-6446