Timothy's | Restaurant & Pizzeria

54 Main St, Lee
(413) 243-8220

Recent Reviews

Andrea Elsenbeck

Based on the food and service this was 100% a terrible experience. I actually can’t believe they are still in business. The waitress was extremely rude and seemed annoyed that we were even there. She served the children water and did not come back to take a drink order after that. Finally she came to the table to take our food order (still no drinks) and when our sister in law asked about egg in the pasta she proceeded to stomp away and talk to a man sitting at a table. Without saying a word she returned to slam a box of uncooked pasta on the table for her to read the ingredients herself. When she finally came back my sister in law asked if there was cheese in the marinara sauce, to which she rolled her eyes and walked away again. She finally came back after awhileand took our order. When we asked if bread and salad came with our meals she said no very rudely. Important to note that the menu says “meals comes with salad and garlic bread”. The rude waitress then walked away after taking our order and still we had no drinks. At this point the restaurant was filling up. I felt bad for people coming in because she was rude and they were confused by what she was saying. She greeted them by asking if they had a reservation and when they said “your website says you don’t take reservations” she said, “we don’t”. Ok. Next she walked by our table and I tell her we would like to order an appetizer. She looks at me and says sternly, “Well you didn’t say that”. After dinner we weren’t offered dessert or coffee and we finally paid the bill and left. The food was just ok. The service was a disgrace. I would never recommend this restaurant.

alicia d

Excellent Italian comfort food, including but not limited to pizza, with very friendly service and atmosphere. The food tastes freshly prepared and servings are very large, we had enough for a second dinner the next night. Most of the diners were greeted by name when they arrived and clearly were regulars - we could understand why, if we lived near Lee, we would eat here regularly, too.

Barbara Diehl

This place was delightful! Food was incredible. Huge portions and Timothy and Kristin were very ingaging. The scampi sauce was to die for. Penne Tuscany, Chicken Parm and even the salads were huge and delicious! Will definitely go back! Highly recommend but go hungry!

GeoEla

I will forgive the fact that we never got the bread that comes with the meal, despite having asked 3 times. I will forgive the fact that my marina sauce was too spicy for me because that is a matter of taste. But I cannot forgive getting to the end of the meal and being told “we don’t serve dessert or coffee”. Servers were very pleasant or I would have given the restaurant a two rating.

TravelFan15

Pizza may be my favorite food so I have eaten a lot of it. The pizza at Timothy’s surely ranks at the top of my list. We had a simple sausage pie but the flavors were anything but simple. The crust was just right: tasty and crisp, not too thin and not too thick, and the sausage tasted exceptionally fresh. The pizza was low on tomato sauce and I learned that I like it that way! The flavors of the cheese, sausage, and crust were not overwhelmed by tomato sauce, and I will be thinking about that pizza for a long time to come. The service was good, though my heart went out to the few servers on staff. It is a very popular restaurant in Lee, every table was taken, and it was clear that the restaurant is having trouble finding help so those poor servers were overwhelmed. That said, we got what we wanted, were served with a smile, and enjoyed every last bite and sip. ‘Can’t wait to go back, and I just hope they have managed to hire a few more people by then!

Karen Parrish

Best Italian Restaurant around. Was not really looking for an Italian restaurant but happy we have it a try. The Lasagna, it's enough for at least 2 people to share. The Penne Tuscany was simply delicious. Great staff, great atmosphere.Parking: Street parking was avaliable.

louisemontague

My lasagna was very, very good. My husband's Mediterranean Pasta was ridiculous. The portion was enough for 3 people, and floating in liquid..he ate 25% and the rest went to the garbage. Such a waste.

Jean Ripple

The seafood casserole was a taste delight! Generous portions of fish, scallops, and shrimp with a seafood stuffing topping the casserole to perfection!

Smita M.

Timothy's us such a wonderful restaurant. The staff are amazingly kind, very friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. They had such great recommendations. The food was so hot, fresh and so flavourful and the portions were very generous.

jdjbooth

We stopped on our way to Tanglewood. Great little place in the center of Lee. Pizza was wonderful -like REAL pizza. Had the trio of meatballs. Very nice. Would def go again if in the area.

Leeasmom

Timothys may be deceiving from the outside. Looks more like a pizza place than a full scale Italian restaurant with an extensive menu! The staff was so friendly and accommodating and each of our meals was absolutely delicious. Best food we had in town!

Mary C.

Speed was very slow, but portion size was huge. The quality was very good and wait staff were very friendly. For the Shire this is 5 stars compared to what is around. In Boston this would only me 3.5/4 Stars

dean dfw

Average pizzaDelicious meatballs appetizerDelicious Bruschetta appetizer!Great beers on tap.

dean d.

Average pizza Delicious meatballs appetizer Delicious Bruschetta appetizer! Great beers on tap.

TeamMan

But no "Wow." Try their signature Lasagna, the Chicken Marsala or any Italian classic and you won't be disappointed. The portions are very big and everything comes out piping hot. The prices are more than fair. For example, the Chicken Parm and the Lasagna are each only $19. If you not in the mood for a big meal, you can get a Meatball Sandwich or a Pizza or even a burger. Timothy's has a very extensive menu. The servers are all locals and very friendly. There is also a nice vibe to the place. Love the old wooden bar (see photo).

Load More

Timothy's | Restaurant & Pizzeria

54 Main St, Lee, MA 01238
(413) 243-8220