The driest oldest cake I’ve ever tasted. I was excited to try out the gorgeous cakes they had available. I got the raspberry jam cake for same day gathering, it looked stunning. Served it less than 3 hours of purchasing it and as soon as we made the first cut, the frosting broke off the cake like it was a cast!!! The sponge cake was sooo dry and the buttercream filling was too sweet! It was the biggest disappointment! I wonder how many days was it sitting in the fridge at the store before I purchased it? I would say at least 10 days going off how dry and stone-like it was. I was so embarrassed infront of my guests as if I served them old cake. Never stepping foot in that bakery again.
Food: 1
Keyona F.
Came here last minute because my order with another bakery fell through just before my baby shower. I was desperate and really needed cake and cupcakes within 72hrs. I called up this bakery and they accommodated me in every way they could, they even found a way to do my cake in less than the turn around time minimum (2wks)they usually require. The staff was nice the owner was just as nice. And over all this was a wonderful experience! The Baked goods themselves where very delicious ! Everyone asked where I got the cake and cupcakes from and the compliment were consistent the whole night! If your going to this bakery for an event or just to grab a slice of cake etc. this place is very good and worth going to. Everything was/is good. Thank you guilty Bakery for making my baby shower memorable.
Kayla Lithgow
My partner and I went in for a last second cake for my birthday, and we were amazed at the selection! There are cakes ready made, sandwich cookies, macarons (and macaroons!), and all sorts of other treats that are displayed perfectly. We ordered one of each macaron, oatmeal cream pies, two cake pops, and a small vanilla/vanilla cake for a party we're hosting. The service was amazing and fast, the prices were totally reasonable, and the baked goods were amazing.If you're looking for a bakery to try out, you have to go to Guilty Bakery! We're so glad that we did stop in and see what kind of selection that they had. The cake is perfectly soft and the frosting is the right amount of sweet. The macarons are baked to perfection with just the right amount of filling. You can taste the care that they put into their products!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Egan
Not a fan of places that don’t display prices $$$$ peanut butter cookies fell
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Sarah Calnan
I will say, the desserts are delicious. However, after placing a dessert order for my sisters baby shower and then calling to confirm the order, when my mom picked up the desserts they gave us 40 less cupcakes than ordered and put the wrong frosting on half of them. To say it left me disappointed and in a bad spot is an understatement.
Food: 5
Service: 2
Lauren M.
I was looking for something other than that traditional 6 piece Italian pastry dessert tray that I'm so tired of eating. The bakery offered so many unique delicious choices that are so far from the typical cannoli or cupcake. I picked an assortment of desserts for a birthday party and they were a huge hit. The oatmeal cream pies, the mini carrot cake cupcake and the mini smore cupcake were some of the fan favorites. Highly recommend.
Stef Dami
We went here for a wedding cake tasting and the samples were excellent. Cake had wonderful soft texture and the frosting was packed with flavor. The employees and the owner were a pleasure to speak to. I couldn’t be more excited to work with their team to create our dream wedding cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sabrina Mierzwa
We ordered our wedding cake from Guilty Bakery and it was fabulous! They were on the preferred vendors list that our venue provided and we are so glad! Amy made the tasting and selection part so easy and we didn't have to worry about anything after that! We just showed up on our wedding day and had the most beautiful cake waiting for us! We also got to choose 3 flavors which were all to die for! Highly recommend them for any wedding cake needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Jayda Sylvestre
Guilty Bakery made me a BEAUTIFUL 21st birthday cake! It tasted delicious and looked amazing. Amy and her team made my visions come to life and made it so easy for me. I highly recommend and will most definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sydney Sherrell
We had a desert table from guilty bakery at our wedding reception. They were our first and only choice. We dreamed and still dream about their deserts. Every single desert we ordered was amazing. They're the only bakery we'll ever use.
OMG! The mini pumpkin cupcake was delicious! Not too sweet and so much flavor. I have not written a review in years, but had to write one because it was that good.They had a lot of other delicious looking options -different flavored macaroons, whoopie pies, granola, cookies, etc. the decor and merchandise was cute as well.
Kendra Sinclair
Excellent bakery. I went to Guilty Bakery this afternoon with my daughter for her birthday. She wanted macaroons and they were excellent and flavorful. The bakery was clean and the staff working today was very friendly. We will be back.
Michael Golden
Hands down the greatest chocolate chip cookie I have every eaten.
Lauren Troisi
The lemon raspberry cookie sandwich is divine! No guilt to be had. Totally worth the calories! Will be recommending this place to everyone in the area.
Carolyn T.
This bakery is outstanding. Desserts are amazing. Store is spotless and the help outstanding.
The driest oldest cake I’ve ever tasted. I was excited to try out the gorgeous cakes they had available. I got the raspberry jam cake for same day gathering, it looked stunning. Served it less than 3 hours of purchasing it and as soon as we made the first cut, the frosting broke off the cake like it was a cast!!! The sponge cake was sooo dry and the buttercream filling was too sweet! It was the biggest disappointment! I wonder how many days was it sitting in the fridge at the store before I purchased it? I would say at least 10 days going off how dry and stone-like it was. I was so embarrassed infront of my guests as if I served them old cake. Never stepping foot in that bakery again.
Food: 1
Came here last minute because my order with another bakery fell through just before my baby shower. I was desperate and really needed cake and cupcakes within 72hrs. I called up this bakery and they accommodated me in every way they could, they even found a way to do my cake in less than the turn around time minimum (2wks)they usually require. The staff was nice the owner was just as nice. And over all this was a wonderful experience! The Baked goods themselves where very delicious ! Everyone asked where I got the cake and cupcakes from and the compliment were consistent the whole night! If your going to this bakery for an event or just to grab a slice of cake etc. this place is very good and worth going to. Everything was/is good. Thank you guilty Bakery for making my baby shower memorable.
My partner and I went in for a last second cake for my birthday, and we were amazed at the selection! There are cakes ready made, sandwich cookies, macarons (and macaroons!), and all sorts of other treats that are displayed perfectly. We ordered one of each macaron, oatmeal cream pies, two cake pops, and a small vanilla/vanilla cake for a party we're hosting. The service was amazing and fast, the prices were totally reasonable, and the baked goods were amazing.If you're looking for a bakery to try out, you have to go to Guilty Bakery! We're so glad that we did stop in and see what kind of selection that they had. The cake is perfectly soft and the frosting is the right amount of sweet. The macarons are baked to perfection with just the right amount of filling. You can taste the care that they put into their products!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a fan of places that don’t display prices $$$$ peanut butter cookies fell
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
I will say, the desserts are delicious. However, after placing a dessert order for my sisters baby shower and then calling to confirm the order, when my mom picked up the desserts they gave us 40 less cupcakes than ordered and put the wrong frosting on half of them. To say it left me disappointed and in a bad spot is an understatement.
Food: 5
Service: 2
I was looking for something other than that traditional 6 piece Italian pastry dessert tray that I'm so tired of eating. The bakery offered so many unique delicious choices that are so far from the typical cannoli or cupcake. I picked an assortment of desserts for a birthday party and they were a huge hit. The oatmeal cream pies, the mini carrot cake cupcake and the mini smore cupcake were some of the fan favorites. Highly recommend.
We went here for a wedding cake tasting and the samples were excellent. Cake had wonderful soft texture and the frosting was packed with flavor. The employees and the owner were a pleasure to speak to. I couldn’t be more excited to work with their team to create our dream wedding cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered our wedding cake from Guilty Bakery and it was fabulous! They were on the preferred vendors list that our venue provided and we are so glad! Amy made the tasting and selection part so easy and we didn't have to worry about anything after that! We just showed up on our wedding day and had the most beautiful cake waiting for us! We also got to choose 3 flavors which were all to die for! Highly recommend them for any wedding cake needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Guilty Bakery made me a BEAUTIFUL 21st birthday cake! It tasted delicious and looked amazing. Amy and her team made my visions come to life and made it so easy for me. I highly recommend and will most definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a desert table from guilty bakery at our wedding reception. They were our first and only choice. We dreamed and still dream about their deserts. Every single desert we ordered was amazing. They're the only bakery we'll ever use.
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG! The mini pumpkin cupcake was delicious! Not too sweet and so much flavor. I have not written a review in years, but had to write one because it was that good.They had a lot of other delicious looking options -different flavored macaroons, whoopie pies, granola, cookies, etc. the decor and merchandise was cute as well.
Excellent bakery. I went to Guilty Bakery this afternoon with my daughter for her birthday. She wanted macaroons and they were excellent and flavorful. The bakery was clean and the staff working today was very friendly. We will be back.
Hands down the greatest chocolate chip cookie I have every eaten.
The lemon raspberry cookie sandwich is divine! No guilt to be had. Totally worth the calories! Will be recommending this place to everyone in the area.
This bakery is outstanding. Desserts are amazing. Store is spotless and the help outstanding.