The staff is great, friendly and the food is always good and love the lettuce and the sweet peppers and the cost is reasonable, Leroy is the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub, Chicken Fingers, Steak
Jenna Myers
My fiancé and I tried Turtles Subs for the first time today. He loved his sub and the wings were amazing! Great food and friendly staff. We will be back!!!Update... this is the only place I get wings now. Wings from anywhere else are just
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Schectman
Turkey and Swiss all day for me. The food is as friendly and easy going as the owner and the dining area. No frills. No apologies. The atmosphere is very plain but I give it 4stars for being clean neat and organized. The food is made to order, one order at a time. Subs filled to bursting and the oil drizzle and signature seasoning he puts on top is perfect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A F
I have no idea how this place has gained such a high rating...From the moldy ceiling panels, stained flooring and countertops, the stench of cigarettes flowing the air as the workers step just outside the front door to smoke, to the store bought, mediocre sandwich items...this place gives off more bar vibes than restaurant/sub place.The sub condiments were taken out of packaging and the bread stale and old. The prices are outrageously priced for the quality you receive.Maybe a year ago (the average time of these ratings) this place was decent but most definitely not now. I rarely do bad reviews but this place is deserving of one of my lowest rated places.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Jennifer May
Great food. Great service. My husband and I have enjoyed this place for years, and hope to enjoy it for years to come!Edit: 6 years later and we still love it here. ? The owner is amazing and works really hard at keeping this place great. I can’t eat gluten anymore and now enjoy their salads… the seasoned lettuce and sweet peppers are everything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittanie Harris
Best subs/salads in town... Just wish they were open longer☹️
Jeffrey Attimy
The place is great. The food taste delicious but I wish there was an option for a footlong hoagie. Again the food tastes great but the cost is a bit high especially for the size of the sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Jody Rockenbaugh
Been a customer for 20+yrs The best subs, salads and so much more! Always fresh and Delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kathy everly
Good food ,excellent service, very clean ,great atmosphere ,the owners goes above an beyond for their place of business God bless
Michelle Adams
This is my *ALL TIME* FAVORITE CHEESE STEAK place. Hands down.. NO one tops turtles!
Fries were delicious. Steak tastes like meatloaf, not seasoned at all. Not a fan
Nicholaus Harvill
Got the “Italian”. It was 1 slice of bologna and 1 slice of ham with some oregano lettuce on top and a cheap undercooked sub par roll. Never ever ever ever again
Jared Silberzahn
Fresh, tasty food. Fast and friendly service. Very clean establishment. It's clear the ownership takes great pride in all the details. They even flavor the lettuce on the subs with a home-made house dressing and grow their own peppers. If you're in the Hagerstown area and looking for subs, this is the place to stop. We look forward to going back soon!
william boyd
Disgusting one of the worst steak and cheese I ever had in my life uneatable will go in the trash
Sherry D.
I think I just made the wrong choice of sandwich. I was looking for a tuna wrap and they don't make wraps so I had a tuna sub......it's just not the way I wanted it because a sub roll is too thick. It might have been better to get a steak and cheese. The owner was behind the counter and so nice! I hadn't been to Turtles in about 20 years and it was previously in downtown Hagerstown. Now it's on the outskirts of Hagerstown. We talked about how long the business has been around. I might return to get a steak and cheese because of the popularity of that sub but my search was for a wrap because it's less bread, thinner. It just wasn't what I was in the mood for.
The staff is great, friendly and the food is always good and love the lettuce and the sweet peppers and the cost is reasonable, Leroy is the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub, Chicken Fingers, Steak
My fiancé and I tried Turtles Subs for the first time today. He loved his sub and the wings were amazing! Great food and friendly staff. We will be back!!!Update... this is the only place I get wings now. Wings from anywhere else are just
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Turkey and Swiss all day for me. The food is as friendly and easy going as the owner and the dining area. No frills. No apologies. The atmosphere is very plain but I give it 4stars for being clean neat and organized. The food is made to order, one order at a time. Subs filled to bursting and the oil drizzle and signature seasoning he puts on top is perfect.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have no idea how this place has gained such a high rating...From the moldy ceiling panels, stained flooring and countertops, the stench of cigarettes flowing the air as the workers step just outside the front door to smoke, to the store bought, mediocre sandwich items...this place gives off more bar vibes than restaurant/sub place.The sub condiments were taken out of packaging and the bread stale and old. The prices are outrageously priced for the quality you receive.Maybe a year ago (the average time of these ratings) this place was decent but most definitely not now. I rarely do bad reviews but this place is deserving of one of my lowest rated places.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great food. Great service. My husband and I have enjoyed this place for years, and hope to enjoy it for years to come!Edit: 6 years later and we still love it here. ? The owner is amazing and works really hard at keeping this place great. I can’t eat gluten anymore and now enjoy their salads… the seasoned lettuce and sweet peppers are everything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best subs/salads in town... Just wish they were open longer☹️
The place is great. The food taste delicious but I wish there was an option for a footlong hoagie. Again the food tastes great but the cost is a bit high especially for the size of the sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Been a customer for 20+yrs The best subs, salads and so much more! Always fresh and Delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food ,excellent service, very clean ,great atmosphere ,the owners goes above an beyond for their place of business God bless
This is my *ALL TIME* FAVORITE CHEESE STEAK place. Hands down.. NO one tops turtles!
Restaurantji Recommends
Fries were delicious. Steak tastes like meatloaf, not seasoned at all. Not a fan
Got the “Italian”. It was 1 slice of bologna and 1 slice of ham with some oregano lettuce on top and a cheap undercooked sub par roll. Never ever ever ever again
Fresh, tasty food. Fast and friendly service. Very clean establishment. It's clear the ownership takes great pride in all the details. They even flavor the lettuce on the subs with a home-made house dressing and grow their own peppers. If you're in the Hagerstown area and looking for subs, this is the place to stop. We look forward to going back soon!
Disgusting one of the worst steak and cheese I ever had in my life uneatable will go in the trash
I think I just made the wrong choice of sandwich. I was looking for a tuna wrap and they don't make wraps so I had a tuna sub......it's just not the way I wanted it because a sub roll is too thick. It might have been better to get a steak and cheese. The owner was behind the counter and so nice! I hadn't been to Turtles in about 20 years and it was previously in downtown Hagerstown. Now it's on the outskirts of Hagerstown. We talked about how long the business has been around. I might return to get a steak and cheese because of the popularity of that sub but my search was for a wrap because it's less bread, thinner. It just wasn't what I was in the mood for.