My wife and I were in town enjoying Lake Michigan and ordered a deep dish from Papa’a Pizza and it was delicious. It was better than the deep dish I experienced at a famous place in Chicago. I ordered on the phone and picked up in person and the staff were super friendly.
Jason Benway
Based on the reviews we should have gotten the deep dish, we did not. The pizza was underwhelming and didn't even save the left overs.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Stephen Smith
In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa’s Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless décor, family games, and an ever-present charm.
We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza’s unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie.
Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molten cheese coupled with the tasty spices on top. Last but certainly not least, we had the Italian Bread, which when paired with their pizza sauce, was absolutely fantastic.
Our experience was marvelous thanks to the entire Papa Pizza Crew.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Karnes
We had a wonderful meal at Papa’s Pizza. The deluxe cheese deep dish pizza was amazing! The service was impeccable. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Smith
In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa’s Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless décor, family games, and an ever-present charm.
We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza’s unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie.
Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molten cheese coupled with the tasty spices on top. Last but certainly not least, we had the Italian Bread, which when paired with their pizza sauce, was absolutely fantastic.
Our experience was marvelous thanks to the entire Papa Pizza Crew.
Kelly Atchison
Sandwiches were burnt!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Hattierose Balcom
I have been coming here for my whole life. I love the pizza, but the italian bread is what we always get and it is like a childhood memory for me. And Papa’s never misses. I highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Felton
Our first experience with Papa’s was before the pandemic and it was exceptional! We returned in late May of this year, happy to see it open. The pizza that time was the Chicago deep dish. It was ok but the toppings were minimal, except for cheese. There was plenty of that, probably enough for at least 2 pizzas. The sauce and other toppings were hard to find.
This time, we tried the Sicilian. Same issue only with MORE cheese! What little sauce was on the pizza was good, just not enough and again, meat & veges weren’t easy to find.
I really hate that our favorite pizza place has gone this route. Maybe they’re still trying to make it their own, but save on the cheese and put more sauce and veges on there, please!
Very good pizza and a real at home atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yummy food - awesome remodel - great team!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I were in town enjoying Lake Michigan and ordered a deep dish from Papa’a Pizza and it was delicious. It was better than the deep dish I experienced at a famous place in Chicago. I ordered on the phone and picked up in person and the staff were super friendly.
Based on the reviews we should have gotten the deep dish, we did not. The pizza was underwhelming and didn't even save the left overs.
Food: 2
Service: 4
In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa’s Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless décor, family games, and an ever-present charm.
We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza’s unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie.
Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molten cheese coupled with the tasty spices on top. Last but certainly not least, we had the Italian Bread, which when paired with their pizza sauce, was absolutely fantastic.
Our experience was marvelous thanks to the entire Papa Pizza Crew.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a wonderful meal at Papa’s Pizza. The deluxe cheese deep dish pizza was amazing! The service was impeccable. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa’s Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless décor, family games, and an ever-present charm. We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza’s unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie. Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molten cheese coupled with the tasty spices on top. Last but certainly not least, we had the Italian Bread, which when paired with their pizza sauce, was absolutely fantastic. Our experience was marvelous thanks to the entire Papa Pizza Crew.
Sandwiches were burnt!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
I have been coming here for my whole life. I love the pizza, but the italian bread is what we always get and it is like a childhood memory for me. And Papa’s never misses. I highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our first experience with Papa’s was before the pandemic and it was exceptional! We returned in late May of this year, happy to see it open. The pizza that time was the Chicago deep dish. It was ok but the toppings were minimal, except for cheese. There was plenty of that, probably enough for at least 2 pizzas. The sauce and other toppings were hard to find.
This time, we tried the Sicilian. Same issue only with MORE cheese! What little sauce was on the pizza was good, just not enough and again, meat & veges weren’t easy to find.
I really hate that our favorite pizza place has gone this route. Maybe they’re still trying to make it their own, but save on the cheese and put more sauce and veges on there, please!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Waited over a hour and a half for pizza and wings. The pizza was ok. Staff was great. 72$ dollars for 2 pizzas and wings.
Downhome pizza, subs, and more! Great staff, great service, and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Hawaiian Pizza! Thank you! Finally found what I was craving made perfectly!
Amazing food, kind and patient 🥰
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super pizza is life changing. Order up, this place is a gem.
Loading...