Absolutely fantastic experience!Other than trying to find the place, which is a bit confusing, everything was spectacular.For anyone not familiar, you have to go to the unmarked door, next to the back door for Alchemi and hit the little button on the call box to use the password.Cocktails were absolutely some of the best I've had...and not overly pricey for what get.Food options were extensive for a cocktail bar of this type and everything was cooked to perfection and delicious.The bartender and staff were also extremely helpful and attentive. We will definitely return.Keep up the great work!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mushroom Arancini
DLodge
Absolutely fantastic experience! Other than trying to find the place, everything was spectacular. Cocktails were absolutely some of the best I have had. Food options were extension for a cocktail bar of this type and everything was cooked to perfection and delicious. The bartender and staff were also extremely helpful and attentive. We will definitely return. Keep up the great work!!!
Ashish Madan
food was really great. drinks ok. ambience is alright, it was just uncomfortably cold in the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
NICHOLES
The drinks are always fantastic and this visit was no exception. We sat at the bar and had wonderful service. The bartender was friendly and engaging despite being busy. We always appreciate the staff when we visit Johnny's!
AngelaR
Loooove the vibe of it all! The music was on point to the theme. The food was scrumptious and the drinks are strong enough and aesthetically pleasing. Was a little too dark at my table and I had to use a flashlight to see my food but that was my only complaint.
LaurynM
This is our second time coming to Johnny's and we already can't wait to come back! A definite date night or night out hit! Drinks were fantastic and the whiskey/bourbon selection is pretty good! The food is also excellent!
Jole
Not sure on how the food is, but the drinks are pretty much the same as Alchemi, just in a nicer location, more intimate area. Overall, enjoyed the atmosphere and the bartender was great that night!
BrittneyR
Easy to find, friendly staff to assist entry to the speakeasy and waitress. Ambiance was adorable and they have live music on Sundays. Drinks were delicious. Lobster bisque was creamy and delicious. Lamb was underwhelming due to lack of seasonings. Crème brûlée was sweet and creamy. Will come back but to try a different entree.
Jorge Cherriz
Best speakeasy in town, the experience here is like being in new your city with a jazzy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cast Iron Seared Prime NY Strip
Ricardo Hearn
What a wonderful experience... This place is the new standard and absolutely exceptional!!!
Not the place it used to be... issues getting in, nobody would answer the phone, now that they are using a reservation site it doesn't text you a code — at least it didn't for us — drinks were watered down, steak came out cold (server scraped it off my plate rather than take the whole thing back), lobster was way over salted... the only thing that seems to still be good is the crème brûlée. Seems they have over complicated the menu and experience, when it was incredible when they first got going. For $225 plus 20% it's not worth it.
Pronob B (Pro)
The food wasn't anything to get crazy over but the drinks were perfect and the atmosphere is very nice to sit in. Exceptional service.Creme Brulee was solid but charcuterie board was not worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Morgen Panning
I just visited for a second time on Saturday night with some girlfriends. Our drinks were unique (presentation and taste) and delicious, the service was amazing (fun, friendly, and prompt), and the atmosphere is just so cool. Didn't try the food this time around but it looked delicious and was plated nicely.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ken Rowls
Been a fan of Johnny's since my friend Katherine Biles introduced me to it back in 2022, when she was the manager there. I took an old friend for a date, and despite that date didn't go as well as I hoped, yet the staff there were very hospitable, the non-alcoholic drinks and food was wonderful, but the highlight of the night was Sheila Landis and Rick Matle providing the entertainment for the night! It was a pleasure to see them again, and look forward to the next time (with a different date for sure)!Vegetarian options: They served crab cakes to my date, and I had some type of rice and lentils, with some bread that had cheese on the inside, which was definitely good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joie F.
Cute space underneath Alchemi which basically serves the same food/drink menu which i eventually realized. Food was good, the lamb ragu came in a largeee portion. I've never ordered pasta ever and it did not disappoint except for the extra side of pasta water. Regardless, amazing service and the drinks were well crafted. Get the espresso martini, best one i've had ever !
Absolutely fantastic experience!Other than trying to find the place, which is a bit confusing, everything was spectacular.For anyone not familiar, you have to go to the unmarked door, next to the back door for Alchemi and hit the little button on the call box to use the password.Cocktails were absolutely some of the best I've had...and not overly pricey for what get.Food options were extensive for a cocktail bar of this type and everything was cooked to perfection and delicious.The bartender and staff were also extremely helpful and attentive. We will definitely return.Keep up the great work!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mushroom Arancini
Absolutely fantastic experience! Other than trying to find the place, everything was spectacular. Cocktails were absolutely some of the best I have had. Food options were extension for a cocktail bar of this type and everything was cooked to perfection and delicious. The bartender and staff were also extremely helpful and attentive. We will definitely return. Keep up the great work!!!
food was really great. drinks ok. ambience is alright, it was just uncomfortably cold in the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
The drinks are always fantastic and this visit was no exception. We sat at the bar and had wonderful service. The bartender was friendly and engaging despite being busy. We always appreciate the staff when we visit Johnny's!
Loooove the vibe of it all! The music was on point to the theme. The food was scrumptious and the drinks are strong enough and aesthetically pleasing. Was a little too dark at my table and I had to use a flashlight to see my food but that was my only complaint.
This is our second time coming to Johnny's and we already can't wait to come back! A definite date night or night out hit! Drinks were fantastic and the whiskey/bourbon selection is pretty good! The food is also excellent!
Not sure on how the food is, but the drinks are pretty much the same as Alchemi, just in a nicer location, more intimate area. Overall, enjoyed the atmosphere and the bartender was great that night!
Easy to find, friendly staff to assist entry to the speakeasy and waitress. Ambiance was adorable and they have live music on Sundays. Drinks were delicious. Lobster bisque was creamy and delicious. Lamb was underwhelming due to lack of seasonings. Crème brûlée was sweet and creamy. Will come back but to try a different entree.
Best speakeasy in town, the experience here is like being in new your city with a jazzy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cast Iron Seared Prime NY Strip
What a wonderful experience... This place is the new standard and absolutely exceptional!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Not the place it used to be... issues getting in, nobody would answer the phone, now that they are using a reservation site it doesn't text you a code — at least it didn't for us — drinks were watered down, steak came out cold (server scraped it off my plate rather than take the whole thing back), lobster was way over salted... the only thing that seems to still be good is the crème brûlée. Seems they have over complicated the menu and experience, when it was incredible when they first got going. For $225 plus 20% it's not worth it.
The food wasn't anything to get crazy over but the drinks were perfect and the atmosphere is very nice to sit in. Exceptional service.Creme Brulee was solid but charcuterie board was not worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I just visited for a second time on Saturday night with some girlfriends. Our drinks were unique (presentation and taste) and delicious, the service was amazing (fun, friendly, and prompt), and the atmosphere is just so cool. Didn't try the food this time around but it looked delicious and was plated nicely.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been a fan of Johnny's since my friend Katherine Biles introduced me to it back in 2022, when she was the manager there. I took an old friend for a date, and despite that date didn't go as well as I hoped, yet the staff there were very hospitable, the non-alcoholic drinks and food was wonderful, but the highlight of the night was Sheila Landis and Rick Matle providing the entertainment for the night! It was a pleasure to see them again, and look forward to the next time (with a different date for sure)!Vegetarian options: They served crab cakes to my date, and I had some type of rice and lentils, with some bread that had cheese on the inside, which was definitely good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cute space underneath Alchemi which basically serves the same food/drink menu which i eventually realized. Food was good, the lamb ragu came in a largeee portion. I've never ordered pasta ever and it did not disappoint except for the extra side of pasta water. Regardless, amazing service and the drinks were well crafted. Get the espresso martini, best one i've had ever !