A Slice of New York

2407 Nicollet Ave, Minneapolis
(612) 871-4334

Recent Reviews

Marlena Riddell

Great food and prices! Will go back again and again. Thanks guys!

Kaylin Brook

Wow, best pizza I’ve had in years! New York style with the best crust! Same thing for the lasagna really good! Friendly workers as well!

Treiii Mami

I really loved this place, but sadly a co-worker pulled a knife out on my fiancé and threaten to stab him. This happened April 11, 2020. He came there around 9ish pm to get us both pizza while I waited in the car. He claims the man was rude to him as soon as he walked inside the restaurant and made a big deal about anything he asked. My fiancé even got it on camera of him putting the knife back into his pocket. I am furious and we WILL take action about this situation. He’s from Puerto Rico and I thought I could share this favorite place of mine with him which he grew to love because of me. He was no threat to this man working that night it was poor behavior and unprofessional of him. As I said I am going to take action and thinking about posting it onto Facebook.

Robert B.

As a transplant from Buffalo, NY this is my go to joint whether I'm craving a whole pie or a couple HUGE slices. Parking can be scare on Hennepin Ave so you may have to walk a little to get there but you won't be disappointed. Guys behind the counter are awesome as well. 26 years living here and I've never had a bad encounter. Check it out if you're in the area.

Missy Warning

They serve delicious pizza! We stopped in when a property nearby no showed for our tour, and I’m so glad we tried this place! They serve giant pieces of pizza New York style! If you have been to New York you know exactly what I’m talking about. We will be back for sure!

Kerry C.

New Yorker born and raised here! A word to my Minnesotans: this is the BEST pizza you will find in the Twin Cities. A word to my New Yorkers: if you go in with Bronx expectations, you'll be disappointed. The minerals in the water just don't create same chemical reactions in the dough but this is the closest you will get in the midwest. Dough deficits were more prominent in the calzone, so I'd skip and go straight for a classic cheese pizza. Cheese and sauce were delicious. The thin doughy-ness of the crust was just right. Those who complain in other reviews about reheating don't get that the brick and oven reheat is essential for bringing the flavors come together. Pizza here is both fresh and flavorful. Cannoli was a delightful treat to top it off. Decor created a true NY vibe. Online ordering process was smooth. I also appreciate the PayPal option (as a secure online payment option). Order was confirmed immediately and came out quicker than expected.

Katie Andrist

Great pizza and friendly service! I enjoy dining in as I live in the neighborhood and have also ordered delivery many times. Has never disappointed!

Kolton L.

This is a must spot for pizza. It's a very chill ambiance. The pizza isn't always fresh but regardless they heat it up and it's still just as good. They have many options and unique food.

Andrew Meggs

This place is actually pretty legit. There aren't many good places in Minneapolis to get a slice, so of the options you could definitely do a lot worse. Nothing too fancy, not a lot of frills, but a good chewy crust and good ingredients. Would recommend.

Trey Joiner

good place to go to late night. pretty chill and the staff is nice.

Anthony Proulx

Love this place. Very New York style of buying slices and they heat them up for you on the spot.

Sam Stokley

Great eat in options. The stromboli is bomb. We love to get a pepperoni pizza when we don't feel like cooking and it never disappoints.

Alex B.

Came here twice while I was visiting for the weekend. Great prices and service. I would prefer freshly cooked but they reheat your order. Still a good value for the price. I would definitely go again if I were back in Minnesota and it was close to the hotel.

Peter Eklund

Pizza is overpriced but the calzones aren't. The perfect chaser to several drinks at Icehouse

Emily Stone LandOf10KEats

Seriously if you want New York pizza here in Minneapolis, THIS is the place!! The interior was covered in New York memorabilia, and it just gave you an instant NY vibe. The pizza was spot on! It was thin, foldable, and had you curing all your cravings for this kind of pizza. It’s simple, it’s cheap, and it’s so worth it. Also the garlic bread was the best I’ve ever had!

Simon B.

A late night must. I highly rec the calzones. I usually buckle and get a slice with the calzone because I'm nasty like that. Totally worth the grease and pain.

Hima M.

Delicious slices that taste like home. You know a pizza place is legit when you crave their basic cheese pizza!

Keerthi Naidu S.

Best cheese pizza in the world. So in love with this place. I have told my entire circle about this pizza everyone tried it and no regrets. A MUST TRY place when you are in the neighborhood. Thank you so much for making such a delicious pizza.

Jaklyn McElveen

Wonderful little spot. Always good food. There is a good variety of options; pizza by the slice, stromboli, calzones and much more. All served NYC style.

Arjun Berry

I felt it was alright. Having been to Manhattan maybe I expected more, but it was okay-ish. I am glad though they have a good NYC theme inside and they are open for a good part of the evening.

Michael Nguyen

Solid New York style pizza in the Twin Cities. Street parking around is easy to get. Enjoyed the friendly neighborhood service.

Kim G

Great pizza spot. I like to eat local when I'm traveling. Nice comfortable atmosphere.

Katy Gray

I'll start my review by saying this is probably the best pizza you can get in the Twin Cities! I've been to NYC and this is the quality of pizza you can expect. It definitely lives up to the name! Why not 5 stars? The delivery drivers have forgotten our ranch that we pay extra for several times, and never deliver to the door, despite our instructions on the Slice app to dial our apartment to enter the building. For a $4 "delivery fee" plus tipping the driver, I think it's not too much to expect a knock on my front door with pizza waiting. Note: I was a pizza delivery driver during college, and making a customer put on shoes to come out to meet me on the street was unheard of. The staff is lazy, and this is why they only get 3 stars. We even called them to let them know they forgot the ranch on the previous order, and they didn't send an extra one to make up for it (which from working in the service industry, to me is obvious, but apparently not to this place). We will keep ordering because the pizza is awesome. Probably the best you can get in the area! But I wish the employees would try a little harder to give good customer service.

Steve Gretch

Pizza had a very nice thin crust, which is my favorite. Was happily stunned when I got the bill. Not a big place but had a beautiful sunny winter window seat.

Soapysantanaful ..

Very nice thin crispy crust. They do have to cut up and reheat but it still tastes very fresh. I will definitely be back.$4 for a giant slice.

Katy G.

I'll start my review by saying this is probably the best pizza you can get in the Twin Cities! I've been to NYC and this is the quality of pizza you can expect. It definitely lives up to the name! Why not 5 stars? The delivery drivers have forgotten our ranch that we pay extra for several times, and never deliver to the door, despite our instructions on the Slice app to dial our apartment to enter the building. For a $4 "delivery fee" plus tipping the driver, I think it's not too much to expect a knock on my front door with pizza waiting. Note: I was a pizza delivery driver during college, and making a customer put on shoes to come out to meet me on the street was unheard of. The staff is lazy, and this is why they only get 3 stars. We even called them to let them know they forgot the ranch on the previous order, and they didn't send an extra one to make up for it (which from working in the service industry, to me is obvious, but apparently not to this place). We will keep ordering because the pizza is awesome. Probably the best you can get in the area! But I wish the employees would try a little harder to give good customer service.

Jose Luis Cabrera

I order the lasagna and the New York Pizza, it wasn’t good at all. The lasagna was flavorless and the pizza was cold and didn’t even fit in the box it was put in. I asked and paid extra to have ham in the pizza and they put a couple of really tiny pieces of ham. I won’t be ordering from here again, even the way the food was package was really bad, the sauce from the lasagna was coming off from the sides of the plate.The only good thing was the delivery guy, he was really nice.

Taylor H.

I've never actually been to this restaurant, but I get their pizza delivered all of the time. It is the bomb!

Steven Black

Absolutely delicious food served, especially the lasagna and pizza. opens till midnight on the weekends, and till 2:00 on the weekdays so this is really the only restaurant open that’s good till that time which is AWESOME!!! Also ordered for my daughters birthday party it was a blast everyone loved it!

Noah Brady

Really great pizza, for sure recommend great taste good crust overall 5 stars. ordered for me and my wife she loves it. great owner and people coming again for different things to try out.

Gino Muhammad

I ordered the Salad there it was very nasty not fresh and it has hair on it. The food is dry they didn’t wash the salad. I recommend not going I’m never going there again. Nasty!

Erik Jensen

This place is great truly a hidden gem, you can get one of those big slices and a Coke for around five bucks when you're in a rush.I really wish they had a deep fryer for wings or fries sometimes but they don't . something about a license.

Ashley Thomson

Good food good service. I’m from New York and this is real New York traditional pizza. I recommend you to come.

530stanw

Unique place made to look like a New York pizza place. Haven't been to one on NY so can't compare but it was very good. Order at the counter and they bring it to you.

Amanda S.

Best pizza and calzones. Staff is always friendly and they are open late to accommodate bar hours on the weekend.

Monica Robinson

Holy! Best pizza that I have EVER had! The fact that the. Rust is homemade and u can see the chef throw the dough in the air is soo cool!Their tomato basil n cheese was beyond amazing! Sorry no pictures I was too hungry n stuffed my face!

Brad Kvanbek

Great place for a quick lunch. They finished my slice off in their oven. It was hot and with perfect crust. Good value

Brad K.

Great place for a quick lunch. They finished my slice off in their oven. It was hot and with perfect crust. Good value

Alison Rippentrop

Amazing pizza and bread sticks. Well worth the money and it's not expensive! Definitely worth trying!

Paul Wichser

Parbaked slices, baked to order. Crispy crust, gooey cheese, classic and Mediterranean flavors. Best fast food option for the space