Asked them to cut off tail end of Grouper.They didn't want to do that, wanting to sell 1.25# filled. I was also purchasing 1# Crab Meat. I said no problem if you don't want to cut filled I will go to Platts. So, she with attitude agreed to cut filled down to 1#. Didn't see what the cost was until I got home.They charged me for the entire filled and kept the 3 oz piece.When I called them no results just rudeness and claiming I got what I paid for. Then told me don't come back no more..They ripped me off $12.00
Roudy71 S.
Food is ok.Servicei s ok unless Captian Jacks Widow waits on you.she comes across as very unhappy and mean and doesn't appreciate her customers.If you dare to find out ask her to peel you some of the Shrimp in the cold case. Sincerely a 15 year former customer
Karen Kenney
Friendly and very helpful associates. Good selection of fresh seafood.
PK Fbook
Our go to at OIB for fresh seafood during our stay and for seafood to take home at end of our trip. Great quality and selection, farm fresh eggs and locally made key lime pie to grab for the week as well! We enjoy ceviche, tiradito and poke bowls and always find sushi grade fish we can enjoy in these dishes.
Barbara Martin
Hands up Best Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes! They are made there and they are fabulous. I lightly browned them in The Olive Press Meyer Lemon EVOO.
Pete Garich
Good place for fresh seafood.
Joseph Silivestro
Good people, selection a bit limited.
Wendy Tinsley
Waited literally an hour before our food was served but the 2 young people serving were super bz. Food was ok, but the crab cakes were not cooked through so we couldn’t eat and didn’t want to wait another hour to have more cooked! The sweet potato is not a sweet potato .. it’s some gunk in a bowl in a nasty sauce: but in all fairness the seafood was ok!
Kevin W
This place is a must stop for sea food. Great selection, super friendly staff.
Vince
Love Captain Jacks, easy to get in, out great selection always fresh
Best seafood market I’ve gone to yet!! Very kind, neat and clean.
randy daniels
I really like this place. The fresh food and many selections aren't a bad price. And the fact that there's NO PORK served at all in the restaurant is a big win for me! I'll be returning many more times for sure.
Nicholas Tyrance
Great place for seafood if your visiting sunset beach, lots of variety, and the best part, it does not smell fishy, they take pride in cleanliness and I appreciated it
Rita Mix
We buy most of our seafood here and the service and quality are excellent.
Soo Kim
I'm from south jersey. I went there cause my friend said it is best place. I got 2pounds of tuna and 1pound of salmon, I'd asked her if I can eat as sasemi after 4 day she said it would be good... bought it on Friday came come Monday morning still its was awesome. Thank you.
Asked them to cut off tail end of Grouper.They didn't want to do that, wanting to sell 1.25# filled. I was also purchasing 1# Crab Meat. I said no problem if you don't want to cut filled I will go to Platts. So, she with attitude agreed to cut filled down to 1#. Didn't see what the cost was until I got home.They charged me for the entire filled and kept the 3 oz piece.When I called them no results just rudeness and claiming I got what I paid for. Then told me don't come back no more..They ripped me off $12.00
Food is ok.Servicei s ok unless Captian Jacks Widow waits on you.she comes across as very unhappy and mean and doesn't appreciate her customers.If you dare to find out ask her to peel you some of the Shrimp in the cold case. Sincerely a 15 year former customer
Friendly and very helpful associates. Good selection of fresh seafood.
Our go to at OIB for fresh seafood during our stay and for seafood to take home at end of our trip. Great quality and selection, farm fresh eggs and locally made key lime pie to grab for the week as well! We enjoy ceviche, tiradito and poke bowls and always find sushi grade fish we can enjoy in these dishes.
Hands up Best Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes! They are made there and they are fabulous. I lightly browned them in The Olive Press Meyer Lemon EVOO.
Good place for fresh seafood.
Good people, selection a bit limited.
Waited literally an hour before our food was served but the 2 young people serving were super bz. Food was ok, but the crab cakes were not cooked through so we couldn’t eat and didn’t want to wait another hour to have more cooked! The sweet potato is not a sweet potato .. it’s some gunk in a bowl in a nasty sauce: but in all fairness the seafood was ok!
This place is a must stop for sea food. Great selection, super friendly staff.
Love Captain Jacks, easy to get in, out great selection always fresh
Restaurantji Recommends
Best seafood market I’ve gone to yet!! Very kind, neat and clean.
I really like this place. The fresh food and many selections aren't a bad price. And the fact that there's NO PORK served at all in the restaurant is a big win for me! I'll be returning many more times for sure.
Great place for seafood if your visiting sunset beach, lots of variety, and the best part, it does not smell fishy, they take pride in cleanliness and I appreciated it
We buy most of our seafood here and the service and quality are excellent.
I'm from south jersey. I went there cause my friend said it is best place. I got 2pounds of tuna and 1pound of salmon, I'd asked her if I can eat as sasemi after 4 day she said it would be good... bought it on Friday came come Monday morning still its was awesome. Thank you.